lol..I loved that Ryan called Kellie on being fake and even her response sounded fake. I really cant stand her

Exactly. She gets on my freaking nerves. I hate her and want her gone.......sooooooooooonnnn!!

The best ----- Bucky (he WAS in his element), Katharine (her singing was bluesly country, but was country), Paris (I don't get the dislike of this very, very good singer), Chris (surprised me, I thought he might not do good with country, but I did think he might since he sung Johnny Cash's 'Walk the Line' so good, I want him to record it and make a single of it), & Ace (his best performance ever IMHO. I voted for Bucky, Chris, Paris & Katharine.

I think Taylor Hicks sucked and I sure hope he goes home, he also gets on my freaking nerves and is highly over-rated and looks like he's 49 (I agree with Simon on that). I also thought Mandisa wasn't very good with Shania's "Any Man of Mine", she totally picked the wrong song for her voice IMHO.

I'd also put Kellie Pickler in the bottom 3. She's irriatating and not that good of a singer.

Exactly. She gets on my freaking nerves. I hate her and want her gone.......sooooooooooonnnn!!

The best ----- Bucky (he WAS in his element), Katharine (her singing was bluesly country, but was country), Paris (I don't get the dislike of this very, very good singer), Chris (surprised me, I thought he might not do good with country, but I did think he might since he sung Johnny Cash's 'Walk the Line' so good, I want him to record it and make a single of it), & Ace (his best performance ever IMHO. I voted for Bucky, Chris, Paris & Katharine.

I think Taylor Hicks sucked and I sure hope he goes home, he also gets on my freaking nerves and is highly over-rated and looks like he's 49 (I agree with Simon on that). I also thought Mandisa wasn't very good with Shania's "Any Man of Mine", she totally picked the wrong song for her voice IMHO.

I'd also put Kellie Pickler in the bottom 3. She's irriatating and not that good of a singer.

I agree about Ace. This was his best performance last night!!

I don't like how Ace gives smoldering looks to the camera. It's gettting old.

I hope Ace goes tonight.

Save Bucky!

Yes..let Ace go and save Bucky!!

Bottom 3 tonight will be Mandisa, Taylor, and Ace

Wow, not to spoil anything for anyone, but I HATE HATE HATE how they seat them! It's SO obvious which group will be in the bottom three and which group won't be.

They need to alternate them or something because they make it so damn obvious and it completely ruins the suspense (not that it's hard to venture a guss, but still).

The first group of 3 with Mandissa, Elliot and Paris better be safe bc those are my 3 favorites. It will suck for me if they are bottom 3. It better be the last group formed with Ace, Katherine and Bucky

NNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!

Off the bat, please excuse my language...

AMERICAN IDOL IS FULL OF DAY OLD REFRIED [!@#$%^&*]!

MANDISA SENT HOME? WHO'S COUNTING THE VOTES? THE BUSH WHORES FROM FLORIDA OF 2000?

WOW I can't believe it's Mandisa.

SHOCKING BOTTOM 3!!!!!!!!!!!

Guess the anti-gay thing didn't go well for Mandisa...if that's truly the case, it's nice to see there are a lot of pro-gay people in America. ha - but you never know. I mean Mandisa did NOT deserve to go - she should be top 5...but it's about personality too and her preaching stuff got in the way.

No words can seriously describe how pissed I am.

I am honestly ready to quit watching. This is pure and utter bullshit. I knew once the groups were divided that Kellie, Taylor and Chris were safe. Say hello to our final three folks. Kellie, Taylor, Chris, Ace and Katharine and Bucky are our top six.

It's just bullshit.

SHOCKING BOTTOM 3!!!!!!!!!!!

Guess the anti-gay thing didn't go well for Mandisa...if that's truly the case, it's nice to see there are a lot of pro-gay people in America. ha - but you never know. I mean Mandisa did NOT deserve to go - she should be top 5...but it's about personality too and her preaching stuff got in the way.

What did Mandisa say or do that was anti-gay?

I am not shocked for a number of reasons.

Whenever they do the groups elimination thing, it is always for shock value. When I saw Ace, Bucky, and McPhee in a group, I knew they'd be safe.

I am not surprised about Mandisa either. She hasn't wow-ed me since her audition. And everything with the anti-gay this week, I mean it fits. Not saying I think she's anti-gay, but you know the media....

I wanted to like Mandisa's performances a lot more than I did.

Well I guess DialIdol was on point this week. Mandisa was last in the votes all night I think.

Oh well, I heard about all that anti-gay writer/speaker or whatever that she supports, but I don't know the whole story. Its not like she posed topless for an internet site

that Kellie, Taylor and Chris were safe. Say hello to our final three folks.

It's just bullshit.

Just like Simon predicted...suprise, suprise. Idol sucks this year...it just feels so scripted. The critisms are always the same, its never constructive. I should just stick to Nashville Star.

That being said, I think the "right" person (Chris) will win this year.