Jump to content

As The World Turns Discussion Thread


edgeofnik

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 17.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • DRW50

    2970

  • DramatistDreamer

    1958

  • Soapsuds

    1716

  • P.J.

    823

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

  • Members

Thanks DRW50 for posting that Willows story conclusion:

Technically, I can see that a few scenes dragged a bit (Grant, Ellen & David) but I generally liked the flow of the dialogue. For the most part, I think all the technical aspects complemented each other really well. There was that one scene where Lisa was describing reading Ruth's journal about her love for Bennett and how it turned sour, the music heightened to the edge of being overly melodramatic but for the most part that music was subtle but evocative of the scenes.

The lighting is very reminiscent of those theater productions from the late 70s that you see on TV every now and then, in a good way, at least for me. Yes, the makeup was noticeable but Kim and Lisa both looked beautiful and the lighting helped illuminate that. Lisa looked luminescent, freckles and all and I liked the way they were both outfitted, lush but it suited the occasion and both women could pull it off.

I do see what people meant about the way Ellen was outfitted though. She looked older than she should have. I the mid '80s, she was styled much more suitably. I do like the fact that in the scenes with Grant, they juxtaposed the anxiety over what was going on at the Willows with wondering what's going on with Dee but those scenes needed some sort of pick up. I'm all for actors taking their time but the dialogue at times dragged just a little bit more than what I would've preferred-- to the point of almost meandering.

The camera work is great though and I really like those dissolves from one scene to the next. It adds to the dark dreamscape quality of the episode. Today's soaps seem to have very sharp cuts from one scene to the next, unless they're doing some sort of montage (complete with musical interlude) but this episode featured gentler cuts, almost as if each scene were cut with a scalpel--if that made any sense--but the cuts were delicately executed. It worked for me. Those directors, cameramen and post production editing crew really knew how to ply their trade!

Maybe because this episode featured family and close family friends but there was a definite intimacy in these scenes that I find lacking in some of today's soaps, even in scenes featuring family members. In the scenes with Tom and Bob, up worried about Lisa, and Bob preoccupied with other relationships. Even in the scene with Grant, David and Ellen, I didn't find myself wondering why he would be there at almost midnight, it made sense that they'd want to be where they are.

Maybe all the close ups where you can get close to the characters, see their expressions, you don't feel as though you are being kept at a distance, you're being invited in, even in the midst of all that dark intrigue.

But yes, I do realize that they would also need subsequent episodes featuring a young set as well to mix in. For this episode, though, I thought the set of characters were enough to craft an intriguing episode.

Edited by DramatistDreamer
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I'm a ways behind - I think I'm on the one where Kim finds the note on Ruth's dress. I leave my comments on the videos but it's nice reading them here.

I do feel like there's a sense of community in these episodes. I was thinking of the last clip I watched, where so many other characters were involved in the business problems between Ralph and Jay.

(poor Jay dressed like a Scotch tape dispenser)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Rose was a favorite of mine. And the relationship with Scott Holroyd's Paul.

I loved Cassandra Creech. I have never understood why another soap didn't snap her up - well, I do know, it's because they mostly don't care about black women. She did a bit a few years after this on GH as a lady assassin working for Faith Rosco, and she was great.

Is that Craig Lawlor as Adam? Jesus, he was wonderful and I don't know why he left but when they brought Adam back later it was some completely different character who had no resemblance to the boy everyone watched grow up. P&G seemed to delight in mutilating those young legacy characters in the last decade.

Edited by Vee
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

There were so many poor decisions made during the final decade of the show, it almost hurts to discuss it.

Cassandra Creech cuts a powerful figure (and I mean that in the best possible way) and to keep Denise vital as a character would have required a strong writer that had a genuine understanding of Denise's complicated backstory and elevate the character without judging her past or sanitizing the character.

There was a lot of upside to the character but writing for her seemed to be beyond the capabilities of the writers of the last decade, most notably Sheffer who got ratings moving at first but had the attention span of a gnat and often resorted to hair-brained crazy storylines characterized by scenes featuring pratfalls (having Barbara go through a window after doing a Grouch Marx impersonation was too much for me).

Hope could have been/should have been an important character in Oakdale. She should have been deeply connected to the Dixons, the Snyders and the Hughes. Her connection to Faith would have been explored and they should have grown up knowing this special connection even if they became eventual rivals. Yeah, but Hope got the 'Bonnie treatment' only worse because at least Jessica remained in Oakdale for some years after Bonnie was sent away (nevermind the fact that Jessica was eventually demeaned and stripped of most of the qualities that the character became known for).

I know P&G wanted to extract themselves from producing soaps but sometimes it seemed as if they had a very willing partner from the creative side. Or in Sheffer's case, a fairly indifferent one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I don't know...I know Denise bothered a lot of people for selling her baby. And I know I never bought her romance with Ben. I do think it's too bad Kim never got to spend any time with her ONE biological grandchild.

Sometimes I don't really think it's Sheffer's fault. He needed a strong co-writer. One who literally understood why you can't and/or shouldn't repeat plots (like that stupid island Lily&Simon and Katie were stuck on) or write entire stories that take place "out" of town, and literally strand a group of characters by themselves for the duration. Knew how to develop characters instead of relying on stunt casting to facilitate a change in character. I think he was in over his head from day one, he just had a strong enough staff to write his ass out of it. Once he bought into his own press, he was toast.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Denise was very unpopular with fans at first, because she sold her baby, and because her story was heavily featured from the start, which is a bad idea for new characters.

I did like her, and I'm sorry they didn't do more with her, especially outside of Ben, as I thought they had no chemistry. I remember when she and Rose had some dance school for kids, Raindancers or something, but nothing came of it.

I think Craig Lawlor was fired, which was a mistake, as he would have been like Scott Defrietas, or even better.

I think deep down Goutman had contempt for any ATWT that had come before him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recent Posts

    • Based on script (and script alone), it feels like they're shifting Lois out of story altogether, unfortunately.
    • Lois should be seen more.  Away from this story lol!  With a sexy love interest!
    • Lois is there to [almost] drop the news of Gio's parentage. lmao. And plus, Rena is iconic and should be seen more!
    • Hmmm...Stefano being Benjy's dad is a whole other thing I suppose. Pocket would be (most likely) a grown man now.  It could be interesting for Phillip if he showed up.  I totally get what you are saying about soaps and adoption.  The minute someone finds their biological parent the poor adoptive parents are entirely forgotten about.
    • Thanks for posting that. I didn't know about "Invisible Man" by Ralph Ellison. I knew only "The Invisible Man" by H.G. Wells.   I just spent some time learning about Ellison's novel.  Now I have a lot of work to do, to learn more, to read more.
    • Because it wasn't posted here is the ONLY reason you can still post here. Numerous other examples were posted here, including, but not limited to, your insinuation of a romantic relationship between two actors on General Hospital, the medical condition of another actress from the same show, and the death of an actor from the same show (which you quickly deleted as it clearly wasn't verified, and still hasn't been), just to same a few. You are the reason I implemented the edit button time limit in the first place as you've repeatedly posted something inappropriate (as noted in my previous post and above), got called out on it by other members, and quickly deleted or removed the offending post before @Toups or I even got a chance to see it. As for Drake, I don't care who the hell told you about his medical condition. It wasn't YOUR right to say anything about it. In fact, your post on X/Twitter at the time wasn't worded in the manner in which you were responding to the news being publicly shared. You posted it to break the news. You even PM'd me and Toups, virtually threatening us with an alert that you planned to post it on the Community itself! The [!@#$%^&*]?!?!?! Stop playing innocent or victim. You are neither. Either post as you've been repeatedly asked to, or find some place else. I don't care.
    • Also, I recall the old analogy Max:Brady as Benjy:Johnson (and I guess Pocket:Kiriakis - but, you know I don't like it when they undermine adoptions by calling the biological carriers the “real parents” on soaps — Tyler has lived with his family for a long time now, he is one of them)
    • Frankie Donner and Max Becker are no biological relation, but Frankie took care of him as best he could until Shawn and Caroline adopted them both, changing their name to Brady. Max was mute for a time. Frankie is Carly's brother, which was a later retcon in the early 90's that didn't make much sense at the time. Kind of like Sarah being Neil's daughter, which coincidentally happened around the same time. Anyway, Trent Becker was Max's biological dad. His mom was said to have died. I forget why Trent had abandoned him, but I think he had scenes with Jennifer and Frankie and decided Max was better off with the Brady's and left him in their care without Max seeing him. This was the original story in the 80's. In 2008, he was reformed to be Trent Robbins, played by Roscoe Born. It was revealed he was Nicole's first husband, never previously mentioned, and that Max had a sister Melanie, Trent taught to be a con artist. Melanie obviously turned out to be Daniel and Carly's kid, and Trent was later murdered by Nick, to protect Melanie. Benjy was a deaf kid that Steve and Kayla ended up befriending. The first of Stefano's retconned children. He left town with his grandfather, Orion Hawk.  Pocket was taken care of briefly by Steve and Kayla. This was in the mid 2000's. He is the biological kid of Philip and Melanie after The Gloved Hand (EJ, and Patrick as his forced henchman) switched the fertilized eggs of Mimi, who was married to Shawn, and Belle, who was then married to Philip. Philip and Mimi ended up letting the baby be adopted. As far as the audience knows, his name is now Tyler Wilkins.  
    • Exactly!  I really want her to turn the tables and outsmart Drew, but will GH have the gumption be that unpredictable for a change.  She was there to blurt out that line at end just to give more reason for Lulu to be annoying. 
    • Max's dad was Trent.  Melanie's "dad" for a while too.   Benjy was deaf.  You have to remember that lol. Tyler Pocket does deserve justice though.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy