Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Language / Behavior Warning

Guiding Light Discussion Thread

Featured Replies

  • Member
13 hours ago, P.J. said:

Judi's Beth is like a saccharine version of ATWT's Lily Snyder or Y&R's Cricket. There's a moment I wound up running into over and over during my rewatch of Josh's accident, during Beth and Lujack's beach story, where Judi is literally running around like a hyperactive chipmunk....and I wonder what I ever saw in Beth.

What helped Judi was her sincerity - I think she has always been one of the "purest" actresses on soaps, even when the character is poor (like whatever DAYS has done with her for decades now). Beth was not much of a character in her own right, but it was probably her best daytime role (I don't think she was ever the right choice for Paulina on AW). Any time I see her work from back then I can understand why she became so popular, especially since the only other ingenue who had sort of had that spark in recent years had been Kirsten Vigard, and the show suffocated that with Kelly and then dumped her.

Edited by DRW50

  • Replies 24k
  • Views 5.3m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

  • Member
6 hours ago, DRW50 said:

What helped Judi was her sincerity - I think she has always been one of the "purest" actresses on soaps, even when the character is poor (like whatever DAYS has done with her for decades now). Beth was not much of a character in her own right, but it was probably her best daytime role (I don't think she was ever the right choice for Paulina on AW). Any time I see her work from back then I can understand why she became so popular, especially since the only other ingenue who had sort of had that spark in recent years had been Kirsten Vigard, and the show suffocated that with Kelly and then dumped her.

You're probably right---I'm just a little too jaded now. Both Judi and Krista were special, and it's one of the few times I can recall a show launching two ingenues who both successfully caught on with the audience.

  • Member

Watching 1986 clips, there is a certain charm and spirit that shines through with watching them. I can understand viewers being confused over the tone of the show, especially if they had been long time viewers... but it's a show going through an identity crisis during this year especially.

On the surface, the tone resembles the Kobe/Long tone minus some of the long term characters that helped ground it... but the follow up writers to Long didn't know how to write her tone so it feels like a big old mess.

The only positive I could find in the show during this time was Reva, and I truly think it was because she wasn't suffocated by weight of 'Bud' and 'Always'. She could function as a character on her own without being judged by her 'true love'.

  • Member
13 hours ago, DeeVee said:

The most difficult part of recasting Rita is Lenore somehow made a fairly unlikeable character sympathetic. Not a lot of people could do that. She never played her as overtly calculating. There was always a softness to her.

I agree. To me, Rita was like OLTL's Tina. She wasn't a "bad girl," per se. She had the best intentions. She just couldn't tell the truth, lol.

  • Member
2 hours ago, P.J. said:

You're probably right---I'm just a little too jaded now. Both Judi and Krista were special, and it's one of the few times I can recall a show launching two ingenues who both successfully caught on with the audience.

It's kind of a shame--Judi could have grown into a mature heroine on the show. Most of her career was working on soaps, so she didn't leave because she was ambitious for a night time or movie career. I think she left because she was unhappy on GL.

Long put a lot into the female characters she created--I wonder if like Reva, Beth and Mindy had aspects of her personality/life woven into the characters. There was a lot of care in creating them, which rarely happened with young soap characters. And of course, the casting was on point. The only time she really flopped doing this was with Jessie and Calla, who were clearly based on her (and possibly her mother) because of the beauty pagent stuff.

2 hours ago, Soaplovers said:

On the surface, the tone resembles the Kobe/Long tone minus some of the long term characters that helped ground it... but the follow up writers to Long didn't know how to write her tone so it feels like a big old mess.

One of the problems with the revolving door of writers that year is they started stuff that got dropped. I really think they were building towards an Alan/India pairing. They even had CB and MKA do a Soap Opera Digest cover and spread. Then they dropped it. Which to me is a shame because I thought they had fantastic chemistry.

There was obviously going to be a major story involving the backstory of Alan's time in San Rios. Big build up and then--dropped. (Actually, I'm glad that was dropped, the "Encantadora" stuff was flashing "CRINGE! CRINGE! CRINGE!" all over the place).

Both Rita and Hope were brought up. Seemed pretty obvious they were planning to bring them back, then--nothing.

2 hours ago, Soaplovers said:

The only positive I could find in the show during this time was Reva, and I truly think it was because she wasn't suffocated by weight of 'Bud' and 'Always'. She could function as a character on her own without being judged by her 'true love'.

Sometimes we forget that RN left not that long after the Reva/Josh pairing was first established. IMO, we think of her being suffocated by him because after he came back it was always Reva/Josh, no matter who either one got involved with. They were always going to be the endgame, period. The fact that they were able to create a popular pairing for her with Kyle before RN came back shows that they did not have to be tethered to each other forever. But I guess TPTB believed the audience always wanted them together.

  • Member
On 4/15/2026 at 7:54 PM, P.J. said:

To which Vanessa would retort: "At least I was having sex. Not simply pretending to. Jealousy is so last season, Nola dear."

LOL.

Why can't I watch THIS alternate GL?!?!?

  • Member
15 hours ago, P.J. said:

snort As long as it wasn't Bill, I honestly wouldn't have cared. It would've been perfectly in keeping with Reva if she had boinked Josh's son while she was "on a break" from whoever she was with at the time. And then had to lie to Josh about it.

It actually would have been much more interesting if TP's Jonathon was brought back as some kid Josh had...(Sonni's kid when she was Solita and dropped him off at the Catfight Convent as she had better things to do) and HATED Reva...same storyline...and he even seduces Reva to show her as the true Slut of Springfield...Kimmer would have both loved it and hated it...and it would be fun to see Rauch's Soccer Mom Reva shown for her true colors. The show was ending anyway...go Big and Go Home!

"The only positive I could find in the show during this time was Reva, and I truly think it was because she wasn't suffocated by weight of 'Bud' and 'Always'. She could function as a character on her own without being judged by her 'true love'."

Reva was so much more interesting when she did have the weight of "Always" to drag around. During this time she had a job, she had friends (its Reva so of course they are all men) and yes, he had someone madly in love with her, bit he was a psycho...she was a real character...and then Jarsh came back. TPTB wouldnt seperate them (despite even Kimmer and RN wanting to work with different people) because the audience writing in wouldnt stand for it.) I wish when they brought her back she was not Amish Reva, but part of her amnesia was her free break from Jeva, and she came back as a woman who didnt want to get invovled with that...(but of course she would.)

Edited by Mitch64

  • Member
1 hour ago, Mitch64 said:

Why can't I watch THIS alternate GL?!?!?

Because we couldn't have nice things. LOL. Although Maeve had resting bitch face before it was a thing, and there are times you knew Vanessa wanted to let loose, but couldn't.

1 hour ago, Mitch64 said:

It actually would have been much more interesting if TP's Jonathon was brought back as some kid Josh had...(Sonni's kid when she was Solita and dropped him off at the Catfight Convent as she had better things to do) and HATED Reva...same storyline...and he even seduces Reva to show her as the true Slut of Springfield...Kimmer would have both loved it and hated it...and it would be fun to see Rauch's Soccer Mom Reva shown for her true colors. The show was ending anyway...go Big and Go Home!

I would've settled for any child of Reva's calling out her out and really sticking with that, instead of worshipping at her feet.

But yeah, it would've been sweet for some kid of Josh's to actively work against her and Reva not being able to do squat about it.

2 hours ago, DeeVee said:

Sometimes we forget that RN left not that long after the Reva/Josh pairing was first established. IMO, we think of her being suffocated by him because after he came back it was always Reva/Josh, no matter who either one got involved with. They were always going to be the endgame, period. The fact that they were able to create a popular pairing for her with Kyle before RN came back shows that they did not have to be tethered to each other forever. But I guess TPTB believed the audience always wanted them together.

I was shocked when I realized he had first left just a year after Kim's arrival.

OMG---I am watching an old Hart to Hart--and who pops up? A dark haired and murderous Rebecca Hollen.

  • Member
2 hours ago, Mitch64 said:

I wish when they brought her back she was not Amish Reva, but part of her amnesia was her free break from Jeva, and she came back as a woman who didnt want to get invovled with that...(but of course she would.)

For all the amnesia stories on soaps, few had a realistic amnesia case. It's permanent brain damage. It's extremely rare to get any of your memory back. IIRC, Jason on GL is the only one on a soap who ever had this kind of realistic amnesia.

If either Reva or Roger had come back with a permanent case of amnesia--think of the possibilities!

In Reva's case, perhaps she would have fallen for Josh again, but without all the baggage of the past. And could Josh live with that? Or maybe she would have no use for Josh. Could he live with THAT?

In Roger's case, everyone would remember all these atrocious things he did, but he wouldn't. Would he still be a bad guy? Would he be a bad guy using the memory wipe to convince everyone he's a good guy? Or would he truly change if a big chunk of his past was gone?

I can't believe that only one soap saw the possibilities of this kind of story.

  • Member

Technically, John Black never really regained his memories.

I think Douglas Marland wanted Holden's (ATWT) amnesia to never be cured and have always wondered how that would have played out.

Edited by Bright Eyes

  • Member
52 minutes ago, Bright Eyes said:

Technically, John Black never really regained his memories.

I think Douglas Marland wanted Holden's (ATWT) amnesia to never be cured and have always wondered how that would have played out.

That remained the case for a few years after Marland's passing. It didn't work out well onscreen. Holden was very cold (he'd been cold for a number of years anyway but it just got worse) and acted like a huge prick all the time.

4 hours ago, DeeVee said:

It's kind of a shame--Judi could have grown into a mature heroine on the show. Most of her career was working on soaps, so she didn't leave because she was ambitious for a night time or movie career. I think she left because she was unhappy on GL.

I believe so, yes. I think there was some talk about how she was resented after she won an Emmy. And various other things. It's very sad.

  • Member
4 hours ago, DeeVee said:

Long put a lot into the female characters she created--I wonder if like Reva, Beth and Mindy had aspects of her personality/life woven into the characters. There was a lot of care in creating them, which rarely happened with young soap characters. And of course, the casting was on point. The only time she really flopped doing this was with Jessie and Calla, who were clearly based on her (and possibly her mother) because of the beauty pagent stuff.

I have a theory on why Jessie and Calla didn't work.

1) The original concept for Beth's cousin was supposed to be a combination of India and Roxie. When casting happened for Beth's cousin, it was in mid 1984 and both MKA and Kristi Farrell read for the part. The casting people liked both actresses and decided to 86 the Beth cousin connection and create two brand new characters. India (who took on the troublemaking aspects of the original character sketch) and Roxie (who took on the spirited and working class elements of the original character sketch).

2) We also have to remember that both Calla and Jessie came on at least a month or so before Long left the show as head-writer so we never got to see the mother/daughter relationship explored in more detail nor did we get to see the Calla/Lillian sister relationship explored. If you watched the November/December 1985 episodes.. you saw Calla guilting Lillian about how she and her husband helped Lillian when she was single with a baby and how it would be nice to have that kindness returned while she seemed to rule her daughter Jessie with an iron fist in the pageant world. Rebecca Staab had just come from playing a working class girl that dressed like a Madonna wannabe and was the bad girl.. so it's possible that perhaps Jessie was going to be revealed to be that way to Beth... but the writer switch happened before that got telegraphed maybe?

Plus, from what seems to have been mentioned by the actors that played Jessie and Simon, it didn't seem as though they were supposed to be paired and that became a thing later on since both mentioned that they hardly interacted at first.. and then one day were told they were being paired.

  • Member
30 minutes ago, Soaplovers said:

you saw Calla guilting Lillian about how she and her husband helped Lillian when she was single with a baby and how it would be nice to have that kindness returned while she seemed to rule her daughter Jessie with an iron fist in the pageant world.

It's funny, I was thinking about this recently. Did they EVER say anything specific about Beth's biological father? I had assumed Lillian was widowed. I always thought it was odd that Beth kept the name "Raines." I wouldn't keep the name of the creep who raped me. Now the implication is Lillian was an unwed mother. Does anyone remember anything about that?

34 minutes ago, Soaplovers said:

Plus, from what seems to have been mentioned by the actors that played Jessie and Simon, it didn't seem as though they were supposed to be paired and that became a thing later on since both mentioned that they hardly interacted at first.. and then one day were told they were being paired.

Someone decided they should try to create a storyline similar to the Beth/Phillip/India triangle. They made India once again look totally pathetic because the only way she could get a man was to blackmail him. I'm surprised MKA stayed on the show as long as she did.

I couldn't stand Calla and used to blame Lisby Larson, until I watched some Texas episodes, and thought, dang, she's actually a pretty good actress. The character was poorly written. No way would I believe that Ross preferred Calla over Vanessa.

  • Author
  • Member

Re Calla/Jessie/Simon

In addition to what's been mentioned I think the fact that they were more new characters being thrust on the viewer. It had just gotten to be too much. There were virtually no characters left from just a few years before.

That is not a recipe for viewer loyalty. New characters have to be introduced slowly and attached to known favorites. There are exceptions of course but overall that is the most sensible course to take.

  • Member

Long originally intended Bradley to be Beth's father but the network got squeamish, so she changed it to step-father.

Also, don't forget that Lillian kept her husband's last name til the last week of episodes-- the abusive husband who did horrible, unspeakable things to her daughter.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 2

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Account

Navigation

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.