Jump to content

Guiding Light Discussion Thread


Paul Raven

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 17.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

  • Members

It made as much sense as Holly flirting with Alan, who was both ally and enemy to Roger over the decades. 
 

Or Sebastian. Ick. 
 

Pushing Holly at the “age-appropriate” men, then another psycho, was just desperately trying to undo all the Nursery Rhyme Stalker nonsense that undid Holly for good on the show. 
 

But they tried. Remember Tom Wiggin as Sam, the farmer/con man?  Was he really going to be in a triangle with Holly and Cassie?  (And Wiggin came back in the final year as a businessman in an Olivia story. He needed to come back to ATWT!)

 

The improbable Ed/Holly reunion barely saves the day in two short scenes. And I would’ve brought Matt Hulswit back, not Simon. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

A) I adore Tom Wiggin. I was literally obsessed with Kirk/Iva back in the day, and actually learned how to hook up our two VCRs together to make myself edits, back before I knew what edits were. I was less enthused about either of his GL stints.

B ) while I understand the impulse to throw three treasured vets into a story and let them run with it, I can't think of two men less likely to interest Holly. I love and adore Billy, but he had an explosive temper I don't think she could've dealt with, not to mention the way her former obsession with Roger would've rubbed him the wrong way. And I think selling the idea of Buzz falling for the woman who'd kidnapped his two children and two grandchildren is ridiculous. From the interview, it seems like Labine liked Justin and Maureen and decided they'd be great together. (Jordan is apparently an afterthought "the guy who played the brother"...indeed. RME)

Honestly, the Billy/Buzz "friendship" always kind of rubbed me the wrong way anyway. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

That's probably because she had written for them both at RH; and while I do think JD and MG played well together, I would agree that the history between Buzz and Holly precluded them from pursuing a romantic relationship.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I honestly didn't know before I read that interview that they'd both been on Ryan's Hope. I know plenty of actors hopped between the P&G soaps, but once out of the circle of shows I watch, my knowledge is spotty.

it still slays me that Kathleen Widdoes played mom to both Lisa and Maeve's characters on different shows. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

This is a rare opinion that I don't see online enough, but it's one I agree with. I think Lloyd Gold's tenure wasn't so bad and was a vast improvement from the tail end of B&E and the Labine's. He got rid of San Cristobal, wrote for Claire (I think she partnered up with Alan), was the one who had Meta in charge of the Lighthouse Gala (which never happened). I do think his one misfire was the time travel storyline, but with Rauch in charge there's plenty of blame to go around lol.  His predecessor Millee Taggart tenure didn't start to really run on all 4 cylinders until Carolyn Culliton joined the show.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

When did shows really start to acknowledge their anniversaries? I found myself wishing this morning that Guiding LIght had done a celebratory montage like ATWT did for their 40th. I know GL did the week with fan favorite moments, and I think they started doing big celebrations for the last week of June (the Blackout episodes, the Josh/Reva '02 wedding that replaced the Lighthouse renovation when Mary Stuart got sick, Billy and Vanessa's second wedding) but I don't really recall them being touted as marking the anniversary.

Forgive my rambling, but I started down this question because a) I can never remember GL's anniversary like I do ATWT's and b) listening to Frankie Goes to Hollywood's "Relax" on the radio this morning (which is used in the ATWT montage). And it taking me weeks to figure out that Billy and Vanessa got a montage over the closing credits after their second wedding (which I've only seen GL do after Maureen's death) because it was the anniversary show.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The first soap opera I remember acknowledging an anniversary was Another World for the show's tenth anniversary. I believe this was in May 1974, when AW was still a 30-minute show.  On the anniversary day, AW broadcast a 60-minute episode featuring the wedding of super-couple Alice and Steve.  Although the show's anniversary was not mentioned in the dialogue, it  was mentioned by the show's announcer during the opening credits, and the episode had been advertised and promoted as a "special 10th anniversary episode."  

I do not remember another soap opera acknowledging an anniversary until the 35th anniversary of As the World Turns in 1986, which featured Chris and Nancy's 50th wedding anniversary.   

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Oddly enough RR and MG had chemistry in that short little scene. It was nice to see Alan have an age appropriate woman who wasn't a pscyho or in love with Josh..and it was nice to see Holly without Fletcher, Billy or Buzz. An Alan/Holly/Ed triangle would be nice, and while I was sick of Alex's obsession with Alan's romantic life, seeing her seethe having her former bestie, nemesis, one who could match her with cutting sarcasm would have been fun. That scene was also going to be the start of Seb vs. Alan in a takeover, which included Josh (who could forget the flirting Seb did with Josh in their scene) Blake, but, it was stopped, which sucked as it could have been good.

 

ATWT's 25th anniversary was Kim and Nick's wedding and the announcer made a comment  "Thank you for 25 great years!" But the show was such a mess at that time, Wagner just quit, DM was used as a walk on, there was no sense of community or family, so it just happened (and now I realize that they were trying to make Kim and Nick the new Nancy and Chris...)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Love this Dinah..she is so much better and believable as a former carny then Moniz was (and I really like Moniz, I didn't like the writing.) Her chemistry with the actor playing Bill is totally brother and sister  (which I don't remember Moniz having with young Bill) and the writing is actually good here. Things could have been turned around at this late date if they focused on the Marler family as the center of things...Ross is the patriarch of town, and I think LK is good as a grown up, licked her wounds, warm and loving but still have an edge Blake.  Instead of recasting Marina and having yet ANOTHER Cooper to stink up the joint, bring back Sam, have more of Holly involved..again, I have never understood several regimes love for the Coopers, except for the fact they were shoving GUSH down our throats 24/7 here.

Matt is still boring and the actor lethargic, and what the hell was with that set?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

To think, Gina Tognoni had only been airing as Dinah for nine or so months by this point, and she was fully immersed both into the cast and the role itself. The writing of these scenes was quite well-done. David Kreizman & Donna M. Swajeski did a fine job together when given the chance. Good use of history in these scenes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Agreed...the writers had Dinah spill a whole lot of exposition and history disquised as a rant, and Gina did great with it.  If you were new you caught up that Blake is Roger's daughter and Roger is shady, that Blake stole Ross from her own mother, that Dinah's mom is married to a younger man, Vanessa and Ross had a relationship and produced Dinah, who she gave up for adoption without telling Ross, Van has a new "start over" daughter....that was a whole lot of history to get across without loosing the energy of the scene. Oh, and I agree with Dinah, Cassie is an annoying biotch but disagree with her, steroid Hart was not worth either of their time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

If there's one reason, on top of many, that I wish GL could've gone on longer, is to see how Vanessa's daughter Maureen would've turned out and how her relationships would've been with Bill and Dinah. Ugh, I could write a whole fan fic on Van and Billy's little family and the Marlers. The material writes itself. 

Edited by MichaelGL
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recent Posts

    • It really is ridiculous how happy episodes from 40 years ago make me. God, MKA is so young!
    • Holy sh.it. THAT was a damn soap opera. I’m at a loss for words for how good that was.
    • A private elevator penthouse with a spiral staircase to the primary suite.  Sign me up! The only deficit was that various riff-raffs seemed to have easy access to the elevator.
    • April 2025 Episode Rankings A total of 22 Episodes aired this Month Thanks as always @jcar03!  1.) Peter Bergman (Jack Abbott) : 13 2.) Michael Mealor (Kyle Abbott) : 12 *.) Zuleyka Silver (Audra Charles) : 12 4.) Hayley Erin (Claire Newman) : 10 *.) Michelle Stafford (Phyllis Summers) : 10 6.) Eric Braeden (Victor Newman) : 9 *.) Sean Dominic (Nate Hastings) : 9 8.) Courtney Hope (Sally Spectra) : 8 *.) Jason Thompson (Billy Abbott) : 8 *.) Susan Walters (Diane Jenkins Abbott) : 8 11.) Christel Khalil (Lily Winters) : 7 12.) Beth Maitland (Traci Abbott) : 6 *.) Nathan Owens (Holden Novak) : 6 14.) Sharon Case (Sharon Newman) : 5 *.) Amelia Heinle (Victoria Newman) : 5 *.) Joshua Morrow (Nick Newman) : 5 *.) Jermaine Rives (Damian Kane) : 5 *.) Melody Thomas Scott (Nikki Newman) : 5 19.) Michael Graziadei (Daniel Romalotti) : 4 *.) Bryton James (Devon Winters) : 4 *.) Christian LeBlanc (Michael Baldwin) : 4 *.) Cait Fairbanks (Tessa Porter) : 4 *.) Connor Floyd (Phillip "Chance" Chancellor IV) : 4 24.) Melissa Claire Egan (Chelsea Lawson) : 3 *.) Mark Grossman (Adam Newman) : 3 *.) Allison Lanier (Summer Newman) : 3 *.) Christopher Cousins (Alan/Martin Laurent) : 3 *.) Eileen Davidson (Ashley Abbott) : 3 *.) Valerie Pettiford (Amy Lewis) : 3 30.) Tracey Bregman (Lauren Fenmore Baldwin) : 2 *.) Melissa Ordway (Abby Winters) : 2 *.) J. Eddie Peck (Cole Howard) : 2 33.) Camryn Grimes (Mariah Copeland) : 1 *.) Kate Linder (Esther Valentine) : 1 *) Greg Binkley (Elliot Matthison) : 1 *.) Elizabeth Hendrickson (Chloe Fisher) : 1 *.) Judah Mackey (Connor Newman) : 1  
    • Same here.  Anyone who voluntarily left Margo's penthouse set (except to go overseas or to Heaven) was immediately on my blacklist.  lol.  
    • https://x.com/MicheleValJean/status/1919575319146856657  
    • The penthouse was my favorite set... and it changed hands from Margo to Draper/April to Miles/Nicole then to just Miles... before he opted to give that beautiful place for that drab house with the even more drab Beth.  That was a jump the shark moment for me LOL
    • The storyline April and Draper are involved in during the summer/autumn of 1979 seems fairly "benign" but soon turns very serious.  April has a VERY intrusive, wealthy mother (Margo Huntington Dorn).  Margo knows that April and Draper (who've recently had a miscarriage and are theoretically never going to be able to conceive another baby) want to buy a house.  Margo hoodwinks them into buying a house they can't afford.  The house is listed at $100,000 (about $400,000 in today's dollars).  Margo pays the first $35,000 and leads Draper to believe the asking price of the house is $65,000 instead of $100,000.  If Draper finds out his meddling mother-in-law paid 1/3 of the cost of the home and tricked him, he'll be mad as hell.   Meanwhile, Draper has received a job offer from a prestigious New York law firm.  Margo pulls some strings and has the senior partner in the firm rescind the offer, to keep April in Monticello.  If Draper finds out about THAT, he'll be even angrier with Margo than he will be about the house trickery.  All of that is "bubbling under the surface" in the fall of 1979 but will be the next major story, as everything begins to spiral out of control.   Yep, you've got the Karrs and their very basic middle-class house, the Victorian-themed place where Miles and Nicole live, April and Draper's old craftsman house with the exposed beams, the Madisons & their Mission revival house, and Margo with her 1970s-chic penthouse.  Each of the sets is completely different.  And their budget was like zero, lol.  
    • It felt weird and out of place.  I get it. While I agree with those on here that say he's gotten better, it's still really bad. I'm not seeing the "good" acting some see...but I'll give him a B for being better than when he first started. There's potential. I'll leave it at that. 
    • It's like watching paint dry at a slow-ass pace. It's bad acting. Entirely. Excellent? With Claybon? Never. Ever. 

      Please register in order to view this content

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy