Jump to content

April 20-24, 2009


Toups

Recommended Posts

  • Members

GH is just hollowed out. If that many fans would tune out because of a constipated cyborg and a smug, self-righteous ice princess, then there was obviously nothing left. I would like to see GH continue, and improve, but more than any other soap on the air now (I would even say ATWT, AMC, and GL), those who run it have taken away every part of what made GH special.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 195
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I think people still care. People make posts rooting for soaps to get bad ratings, but lets ask all the Guiding Light peeps if they will miss their show. GH and all the shows below it are at around the same ratings as Passions was just two years ago, and we saw how that worked out for the Lopez-Fitzgerald and Crane clans.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Guza and Phelps are not gong any where. I expect them write GH into cancellation. It would be great if ABC exes hired Sri Rao or someone else to consult to help dig GH out of its hole.

For all the joy here at GH's ratings decline, if it doesn't rebound soon, all the ABC soaps will be off the air in a couple years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Exactly. Nobody is forced to watch the show, but why wish cancellation on a show you don't even watch? I was not a watcher of GL by any means and I felt really sad it was canceled. Passions I watched and hated to see that canceled too. Canceled soaps are just no fun. :angry:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I'm sad about GH not because it's great, but because it's like they are trying to gradually fix things. But whoever said it's a shell of it's former self is right. Everything remotely entertaining like the Quartermaine family were gutted, the Cassadines are a shell of what they were, the Spencers with no Laura or Bobbie is almost a waste. But I wonder if these shows care as much about Neilson's as we think. It's an antiquated system and perhaps the ABC shows like Y&R and B&B have other revenue streams contributing to keeping them afloat

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I watched GH for many years, but I have considered it unwatchable for some time now. If ABC ever decides to change the show completely, and I mean totally and completely, I might consider watching again. If GH goes off the air because of ex-viewers like me, oh well.

So CarlD2, instead of the constipated cyborg and the ice princess, it's now the constipated cyborg and the twice-convicted prostitute/con artist who would have sex with a dog? Yeah, like that's a huge improvement.

I refuse to watch a soap whose entire focus is criminals and their money-grubbing sluts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Jason and Liz were the reason I tuned GH out, for the most part. I tuned ou. not because they were pulling them apart, but because they put them together in the first place... what utter garbage. Good girl Liz, mother of two helpless children, selling her dignity to be with a murderer. I thought it was such crap, but it was just one more signal the writers would never understand that for fans like me, that wasn't 'romance', it was a flippin' insult. Everything to do with Sonny and Jason annoys me these days.

I'm not even sure why they spent so much money rebuilding the hospital set when so much of the show is centered at Sonny's, or Jason's, or the docks (or so it feels for me).

I still tune in, but I don't watch every day. I don't have the stomach for it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Personally with Sonny and Jason at least I know what I am getting and they make no bones about the fact that they are in the mob. They kill people and they know it.

What bothers me more are the other guys that daytime TV pushes off as HEROES these days who are murderers and fans don't seem to care. They constantly point fingers at Sonny and Jason and make excuses for the others.

Just look around soaps:

Tad is now a MURDERER!

Zach Slater - MURDERER!

Todd Manning - just look at the list of crimes that guy has done

EJ DiMera - rapist and the one that shot John but they forgot about it

and others.

I mean at least with Jason & Sonny they kill as part of their crime organization. Someone like Zach Slater supposedly kills out of love and it is built up as a romantic gesture.

AT least with Jason & Sonny there is no hypocrisy involved.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

It is getting better. I'm amazed at the continuity, the return of characters to the people we know and remember, the focus on family and interpersonal drama rather than stringing plot-points together. Their dialogue is sharp and funny as hell (especially Sam asking Jason why Sonny can't keep it in his pants and how he impregnates anyone who comes in close contact). The changes fans have been demanding are happening, so now we just have to get that message out. It's easier to go down then up, but I think if those of us who see the improvements start talking more then the rest who dismiss summarily won't be the only voice heard. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

There is hypocrisy in that Sonny and Jason are the bestest good guys and heroes on GH. They are the symptom of GH's main problem which is the twisted morality that is pervasive on the show today. I accept that the mob and their crew are major part of GH, but they should not be the good guys and certainly not 80% of the show. Guza's obsession with mob violence, Sonny, Jason, Carly, Spinelli and now Claudia has thrown GH out of balance. It is made worse that he has run out of ideas for his favorite characters so now he repeats these stories with their predictable endings. The damage that these stories with their lack of morality have inflicted on GH for years is incalculable. Reducing the mob, re-establishing the hospital, finding romance (I don't mean silly Liz/Jason or Spinelli/Maxie), and telling more coherent stories would do GH a world of good.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • On the way to her own engagement party? I've read that the show had trouble getting the audience to sympathize with Rita, but...that seems bizarre. Maybe I can understand the issue with the censors, given that at the time, rape wasn't depicted the way it is now, and marital rape was even less acknowledged.  Wasn't Chris Brooks' rape one of the first honest stories on the subject?
    • Yes it was! My mom and I convinced my dad to get one. He was--how shall I put this?--on the thrifty side, but one day he came home with one as a surprise. To this day, I'm convinced it fell off a truck. (He knew people with "connections."

      Please register in order to view this content

      ) BUT, we had our VCR and we could watch our soaps. That thing lasted forever! It was built like a tank. Even when we got new ones with more features, we kept that one.
    • Please register in order to view this content

        Blasphemy!  (Haha, I get it.  But, you should try watching AMC! 80s-90s was so good.)
    • I thought about saying how I resented the fact that those two newbies were tripping up the Puppetmaster of all Puppetmasters, when the best others could do was a stalemate (or less...). But, well...*sigh*
    • I read years ago that both Zaslow and Lenore both complained that it came off as a seduction because of CBS censors, so Lenore asked if she could say, "you raped me" to leave no doubt with the audience, and that Zaslow insisted that Holly's rape played realistically 
    • Wow it’s official, Gatwa is out… https://www.avclub.com/ncuti-gatwa-addresses-doctor-who-finale-statement DW fandom on Reddit is in a furor over how things went down and apparent last minute scrapping of the original ending. Also…Billie Piper again really?
    • He comes pretty close, talkin' about how Reva is full of love and joy, blah blah....which is bilge considering he was the one responsible for throwing her out of Josh's life over working with Alan. 
    • Just watched the episode concerning Olivia's drug use and Abby's persistence, etc. Donna Mills did stellar work in this episode, as did Tonya Crowe and Brian Austin Green (Brian).
    • But by Dinah and Hart...Hart especially looked as if he could not tie his own shoes!  Ed, Holly, Alan, Alex Henry and Vanessa among others were not able to put Roger down....Dinah???
    • The preaching seems to end before the Barnes settle in late December, 1981. The stuff that felt overly religious (the Davidsons believing a miracle will save Lori rather than a surgeon, Jeff's miraculous recovery from a beam of light) was quickly nixed because it wasn't working. The closest thing that you get to that under the Barnes is when Dennis Fraser, the drunk driver who killed Nora and Scott, turns his life over to god. The born-again redemptions out of nowhere seem to stop fairly early into the Barnes' run. I do think Miriam's transformation was much more delicately done with her turning on her bestie Nancy because Nancy was seducing Charles, Miriam's wealthy father, so Miriam offers to testify for the Davidsons in the trial against Nancy over possession of Nora's house. In turn, Nancy repays the favor by pumping an emotionally distraught Miriam with barbituates while Miriam carries on her affair with low level thug turned political aide Norm Elliott. Miriam is used by everyone into her life and finally lands herself in the hospital becasue she has become so addicted to the pills. At the hospital, it is the friendship and kindness of the Davidsons that brings Miriam to a more peaceful place. The Davidsons ability to forgive is both appealing and, at times, dramatically limiting. In this case, the Davidsons lead Miriam to her new Mama, Ione Redlon. Now, under Vinley, Miriam is determined to reconnect with her son, Frederick, and her ex-husband, Paul.   My bigger issue with the Barnes' writing is that they write the storylines with twist endings that sorta come out of nowhere. I know the resolution to the Kate Carrouthers mystery sorta plays out like that so I am curious to see how I feel about that.  The biggest change throughout the writing teams has been the view of morality. Winsor had many characters who could be viewed purely through the lens of black and white, but others explored the shades of gray (often younger people). The brief head writerless period was much better at embracing an action doesn't make a person and there characters were much more gray or at least evil at a more local level (Nancy, in this period, only flirts with her brother-in-law where as later she is actively providing pills to Miriam to keep her addicted and away from her own father). The Barnes, for the most part, seem to embrace this level of political corruption that seems to permeate throughout the show making it clear that power (as well as money) is the root of evil. Even criminal Vince Cardello is presented as less evil than Charles Carpenter, though Carpenter's murder of a resident of his complex was rewritten to relieve Carpenter of any responsibility in the matter. Vinley's work seems more into exploring the why or delving deeper in general. Babs Farley, the hooker who is looking to reclaim her life, is such an intriguing character. She is given such meaningful monologues regretting her decisions and desperately trying to keep away from the hands of her former pimp, Ron Washington, who hasn't appeared yet. Monk and Fernandez seem to be wrongly accused of Lori's attack and there seems to be hints of racism that the show is looking to address. Marianne confronts Gil about his feelings towards God in relation to their mother's death years earlier.  There does seem to be a layer of misogyny to Vinley's work, but it's early so I'll be curious to see how this plays out. There are a lot of attacks on women (Lori is nearly raped, Babs was beaten, Nancy is on the verge of being blackmailed for sex by Tab, and the Russ / Marianne / Gil scenario has hints of toxic masculinity. It's very early so it'll be neat to see if that is maintained.  Jerry TImm lasts about a year I think (March, 1982 - March, 1983). One of the episodes on TouTube has a comment suggesting that Timm was fired by CBN because he had done something in his past that came to light. It didn't seem to be clear what that was.  I like what I've seen of Timm as Gil. He has such a presence that it covers up some of his weaker acting choices. It's unfortunate that he didn't get to play as much of the Gil - Stacey - Amber triangle as his replacement does.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy