Jump to content

SOD Feature: Nine Recasts who Proved to be Miscasts!


Recommended Posts

  • Members

SOD ran a feature called "Replacement Battery; Nine recasts who proved to be miscasts! It's pretty good list.

GH: Jennifer Bransford (Carly, April - October 2005)

ATWT: Heather Rattray (Lily, 1990-1993)

DAYS: Tracy Middendorf (Carrie, 1992)

OLTL: Christina Chambers (Marty, 2006-07)

GL: Ann Hamilton (Mindy, January - April 1993)

B&B: Emily Harrison (Bridget, 2004)

AMC: Anthony Addabbo (Dimitri, 2001)

Y&R: Shari Shattuck (Ashley, 1996-99)

Passions: Mark Wystrach (Fox, 2006-07)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 125
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Oh no. Mark Cameron Wystrach made an awesome Fox. He was in no way comparable to Justin but he had his own rhythm as Fox. Not to mention the INSANE chemistry between him and Adrian Bellani. They were hot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I wish I had seen this Charity Rahmer girl. How could someone be so bad in such a short period of time? As for ATWT, Soapsuds is right. Heather Rattray was very different than Martha Byrne (and not as talented), but she acquitted herself OK. Susan Batten is the poster child for all miscasts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Jenny did a great job as Carly. It's just some of the TB lovers never gave her a chance, I think the problem with Tracy Middendorf was that people were just so used to Cristie, cause she was excellent as Steve's crazy girlfriend on 90210. And Emily Harrison was just miscast as Bridget, and it was Brad's mistake for recasting right after Jennifer Finnagen left without giving the audience time to adjust.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

It was bad. I remember watching with a friend of mine when she first came one and we both went WTF. I think she was only on for a month before Martha Madison showed up. I'm sure if you did a few You Tube searches you might find some old Shelle videos that have her in it. Most of her scenes were with Philip and Jan since it was the time when Shawn was locked in the "love cage". I know there was a clip somewhere where she is practically flirting with John Black...HER FATHER.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Okay, now it's my turn to ask about the Thorntons, namely Edna. Did she and Opal have any scenes together? I ask because I was familiar with Opal first, so when I found out about Edna, my biased mind saw her as the first try for that type of character.
    • There is no dispute that Jill Farren Phelps had a successful career in daytime based on longevity, but that does not preclude discussion and dislike of her decisions at various shows. Sure there may have been some misogyny involved BITD(we don't know as I don't recall JFP ever mentioning that) but the head of CBS Daytime at that point was a woman and there were other women involved BTS. I think that so long as an EP could deliver, or at least talk a good game they would be respected.  
    • It surprises/disappoints me too that GL's ratings during '89-'93 don't reflect the quality of the show. But when I call it great soap, I'm not defining that by ratings either.  I'm probably in the minority, but I think Reilly takes something intangible with him when he goes. There's a sense of humor that just disappears in '93. 
    • Ok, I know nothing about Another World except their catchy intro song from long ago, but this makes me want to catch!  That crazy mother keeping her son's girlfriend or wife hostage, wow! 
    • And maybe Hotel could have been placed at 9pm Tues instead of Paper Dolls. Not that I thing it was a surefire thing but at least viewers were familiar with the show and it might have done better than PD. ABC's line up was pretty threadbare at that point. And with a big guest star to launch the season - Elizabeth Taylor- the numbers would have been there initially.
    • Any fan of RuPaul would dispute calling any of these examples “drag”. A costume?, A disguise?, A lame attempt at humor? -- yes -- Drag? -- nope
    • No asterisk. I meant that the circumstances during the first year were in her favor.
    • Maybe I am misunderstanding you? Are you suggesting that her success at GL should have an asterisk next to it because she was smart enough to exploit a weakness in the marketplace to gain ratings?  Note: Try not to take this personally—I’m not accusing anyone of being consciously misogynistic. I’m simply proposing that the origins of certain ideas about Ms. Phelps—such as claims that she was unprepared or a poor manager of her writing staff—may be rooted in misogyny. Perhaps, with the benefit of hindsight, it's worth reconsidering those opinions. At the very least, imagine being one of the few women in the room while a male network executive tries to decide what women want to watch during the day. That context has certainly led me to reassess many of my own long-held views.
    • Through 78 and 79 under Marland and Pat Falken smith GH was still heavily hospital based with a mix of storylines. The Doctors would have been fine had they followed that template. Once GH went with Ice Princess all bets were off.Who knows how much TD would have copied that direction? And OLTL, DOOL went in that direction quite heavily while other shows dabbled in far out stories. The thing is that TD was well set up for an expansion.
    • Thank you

      Please register in order to view this content

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy