It's a real shame what's happened to the show this season and a fair portion of the last. After a strong first two years, they took the wrong lesson from the musical episode in Season 2 and began playing to the Comicon crowds with gimmick episodes more and more, and now it's basically half this season with a lot of forced camp and comedy, as well as more sexcapades than I ever expected for Mr. Spock. It's been very CW superhero-coded, or like a long hangover from Joss Whedon's output 20 years ago. They all seem to be auditioning for writing for those shows instead (even though the CW barely exists anymore) by writing shows as off-beat and off-brand as possible.
The final season next year is only six episodes, and they're entirely too preoccupied with Paul Wesley's mediocre Kirk who keeps showing up way too much. In part because they obviously expected the current production regime to continue, and to get their proposed "Year One" spinoff picked up, where they could follow Kirk's early years as captain of the Enterprise, bring along most of the same cast and essentially remake TOS in the image of their current product. But that goes to the same casual arrogance and laziness I've always taken issue with in the Alex Kurtzman era of the last decade of Trek. Any shows that weren't produced under his team's aegis but via other talented showrunners and became popular (Picard S3/Legacy, Lower Decks, Prodigy) have conveniently been cancelled while instead pursuing Year One or Kurtzman's great white whale, the disastrous Section 31 spinoff movie (after the series plan collapsed following Michelle Yeoh's Oscar win). And now the Kurtzman/Secret Hideout era is likely to come to an end period very soon due to mergers, and Trek will need another reset.
SNW has been two seasons of a great show, one mixed season and one huge mess. There's been a couple good shows this season and I am happy Dee had a good time, but I feel bad for the strong cast and the earlier seasons. This shouldn't be how SNW goes out, even if Season 5 is a brief return to form. We'll see. I do hope more people see the first two seasons, and the good shows in Seasons 3 and 4, like Off-Hour or Terrarium.
By
Vee ·
Create an account or sign in to comment