You know, I'm not a Sursok fan, but I do think she takes a rather harsh beaten around the boards. Adrianne Leon was a fine Colleen, when the writing was there -BUT half the time she slept walked through her lines. To me, LF will always be the definite Colleen, hands down.

At last, a voice of reason!

Or Billy.

Ii was trying to list all of John's kids and grandkids (also Kyle and Keemo and [!@#$%^&*], probably a few more, idk) and missed Billy completely. Probably because his last portrayer looked like Mask.

You know, I'm not a Sursok fan, but I do think she takes a rather harsh beaten around the boards. Adrianne Leon was a fine Colleen, when the writing was there -BUT half the time she slept walked through her lines. To me, LF will always be the definite Colleen, hands down.

I'm bedazzled by Lyndsy Fonseca on Desperate Housewives. It'd be great if she could return. Or Adrianne. After those two, it's too hard for me to accept Sursok in the role. She ISN'T and NEVER will be Colleen I want to see on television. And Korbel worked fine with Adrianne... now it just isn't it.

AL was a good actress. but she wasnt *the* colleen. even as good as LF is she doesnt own colleen. it is still a very recastable role as no actress, imho, has ever really put a mark on the role. it is, IMHO, a role that is NEDDED on the show. and they need a great actress to play it.

Probably because his last portrayer looked like Mask.

:lol: :lol:

AL was a good actress. but she wasnt *the* colleen. even as good as LF is she doesnt own colleen. it is still a very recastable role as no actress, imho, has ever really put a mark on the role. it is, IMHO, a role that is NEDDED on the show. and they need a great actress to play it.

And Tammin Sursok doesn't fit that "need."

And Tammin Sursok doesn't fit that "need."

i agree.

if they're doing this maybe they can bring back billy and mac! and get back on topic people!

Ii was trying to list all of John's kids and grandkids (also Kyle and Keemo and [!@#$%^&*], probably a few more, idk) and missed Billy completely. Probably because his last portrayer looked like Mask.

*SNORT* Do you know how painful it can be to have hot tea pass through your nostrils ?

AL was a good actress. but she wasnt *the* colleen. even as good as LF is she doesnt own colleen. it is still a very recastable role as no actress, imho, has ever really put a mark on the role. it is, IMHO, a role that is NEDDED on the show. and they need a great actress to play it.

Well then it's a good thing they have one now!

Edited June 14, 200817 yr by y&r_fan

Well then it's a good thing they have one now!

It's a good thing that they refuse to write anything substancial for her to play too.

It's a good thing that they refuse to write anything substancial for her to play too.

The fact that they don't write for her baffles me. She deserves a big storyline. Hopefully Hogan Sheffer can do something about that...

The fact that they don't write for her baffles me. She deserves a big storyline. Hopefully Hogan Sheffer can do something about that...

If Sheffer is stupid, he will If not, she will remain gone forever. I can't bear seeing her crap on the show like 99 % except you

If Sheffer is stupid, he will If not, she will remain gone forever.

She returns this week...

For me, ever since Tammin took over, her romance with Korbel stopped being interesting. They were a good pair previously, but nothing happened with that after that. And Tammin ISN'T Colleen.

If I read it right (in SOD), Colleen is supposed to return with a decision in regards to her relationship with Adrian. Personally, I'm hoping she and Korbel are done. Like you said, dmarex, as soon as TS took over as Colleen, the chemistry in that relationship; and for a character as bland and direction-less as Prof. Korbel, that's lethal.