Jump to content

American Idol: Discussion Thread


R!ck

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I have to agree with Kenny on this one and say Blake's version of "My Love" was not good - so I'd put him third for Second Song as well. I thought "My Love" was actually his worst vocal of the night. Otherwise I agree with this list. It was Melinda's show until Jordin's last song - goosebumps and she didn't even sing it as passionately as she did the first time!

I'd like to think that was what Simon was doing - the theory amongst some board members here - "blahing" everything Jordin did as a reverse psychology thing with the audience. I voted 15 times for Jordin last night (and I practically never vote) but probably b/c Rosie O'Donnell and the Republican girl were going on and on about voting like crazy for Blake on The View earlier that day. Simon pissed me off but it was those two that inspired me, lol.

It would be awesome if for one year the two people who deserved it most got into the final two, this year that's Melinda and Jordin. Should have been Kelly and Tamyra in year one and you can come up with a scenario for the Perfect Finals missed for most of the years that followed as well.

I love Melinda, but I'm going with Jordin. But whoever wins, if it's between those two, they deserve it! Blake is okay, but I don't want him in the Final Two when there's Melinda and Jordin! No way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Awww man, Jordin is in the finale. I was so rooting for a Blake/Melinda showdown.

GO BLAKE! So rooting for him to win. I felt bad for Melinda though bc she SO deserved to be there with him. I guess Ryan was right earlier when he said she was going home, even though this wasnt what he meant

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

This is totally bullshit, Jordan which sucks stays and Melinda which is the best singer ever on the show goes home :angry: I pretty much knew during the whole show though because of the look on Simon's face, he was not happy, and neither am I. Hell they could have atleast had it Jordan and Meilida and got rid of Blake, but no get rid of the best singer, I HATE this show

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Holly's final big story was the Sebastian mess in late 2004.   Vanessa and Matt were promoted to regulars near the end and were heavily recurring prior to that starting around 2007/2008.
    • Keith has a softer presence, but it would have helped to see him be more aggressive or proactive in protecting them instead of standing around like a mannequin. A man the audience should be hoping and wishing gets back together with his wife. Nicole needs a new husband!
    • She needs to learn to be honest with her husband about her lusty interests because being sex positive only works if you're not cheating on your spouse.
    • https://x.com/JermaineRivers/status/1922782226317529409       https://x.com/JermaineRivers/status/1931204864136396907
    • Very disappointed in the writers in the way they are screwing with Nicole, Ted,  and Kat to make Leslie remain viable. So many holes everywhere.
    • Somebody brought this up elsewhere which emphasizes why this NuTed appears as such a weakling. Why is Kat doing what HE should be doing? And that's everything he can to rid him and his family of this crazy woman. Kat is doing all kinds of things she shouldn't do but now I understand her more. She can't count on her father to eliminate this woman because he's a wimp. He's been too busy inviting her into his home and serving her drinks and offering her invitations to birthday parties. WIMP!!!!
    • It's Men's Mental Health Month.

      Please register in order to view this content

    • This is (maybe) overly simplistic and nonsoapy, but Doug needs to go to Gamblers Anonymous, to deal with the addictive neurological excitement hits that gambling gives him - and which control his life. Vanessa needs to go to therapy to find ways to remain healthfully lusty and sex-positive, but to stay away from anyone who would demean her.
    • YT keeps commending GL clips to me. I discovered Kathleen Cullen was on in Christmas 1987. Was there any talk of making it permanent  or was this just a special visit? I wish they had made the visit permanent. I liked her chemistry with Grant Aleksander.  
    • I'm not sure it's as unpopular as you think.  I just think the show knew they were in a bind, and needed a proven couple for the viewers to invest in. Trying to reunite Vanessa and Ross had just failed in 87. I don't think Ed and Holly's affair was well received, as Simon and Garrett had a brother/sister chemistry. Enter Billy and Vanessa, who give you history and an out not to try and do a Josh/Reva/Billy triangle, which would've really wrecked the relationship between Josh and Billy. I'd have been ok with trying Vanessa/Ross again, and doing a Vanessa/Ross/Holly/Billy quad for a while. I hated Nadine. HATED. She had to be the most insufferable also-ran before ATWT's Julia Lindsay. This is where I wish I knew Roger's history better.

      Please register in order to view this content

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy