I think the storyline needs to be told. Again, it hasn't been done in daytime in several years for anyone to remember. It does happen in real life.

I doubt Brandt, Cook and Fath left becuase of the storyline though. Do you think it even has anything to do with these 3? They all decided to leave even before Hogan came onboard so that's a lie.

I can see Will being the rape victim. They would need to find a better actor that can handle scenes like this because Christopher Gerse just can't do it. It would bring Lucas and Sami together, or it may just tear them apart. It would be such good drama. The only problem with this possibility is the fact that Hogan wants LUMI to be the new comical couple (ala Jack and Jennifer). I don't see anything funny about male rape so maybe Will isn't going to be the victim.

I don't want to see Shawn as the victim either. It wouldn't be believable to me.

I could see Hogie writing something like this too, but would Corday allow him to do it and particularly allow him to write the story the way that he would want it written? Would Corday not interfere with the storyline if there was a negative reaction to it?

Also, I question whether Brandon Beemer could handle a storyline like this. He's a pretty good actor, but if this rumor is true, it would be incredibly challenging material for a newbie. The only other guy from the younger generation that I think could handle a story like this--realistically that is--would be Bryan Datillo. But Hogie has said that he wants Lumi to serve as a comedic duo so that's out....

Can you tell how conflicted I am whether Days would even contemplate a story like this?

I think Corday would probably object to the storyline, but doesn't Sheffer have the control over the writing? I understood that he was supposed to, but maybe I misunderstood.

I also agree that Brandon Beemer doesn't have the acting chops for this kind of story. I'm just not that enthused over the guy.

As for the rumor about this storyline being the reason Cook, Fath, and Brandt left, is total BS.

I think having Will as a rape victim would be an excellent story, but I'm sorry not with Christopher Gerse. Then again, maybe it would make a lot of sense too, because of how Will looks.

Most likely, a storyline like this will probably not even see daylight.

Sheffer don't do it. I know you want to make your mark, but just no.

It wouldn't be the 1st male/male rape in daytime. 'Love of Life' did it to key character Ben Harper (son of Meg, nephew of Vanessa) way back in the mid-1970s. It was shortly after Christopher Reeve had left the role and while Ben was in prison for bigamy (he was married to Arlene Lovett and Betsy Crawford at the same time). From what I've read, the attack wasn't shown on-screen, but heavily implied. I don't know how the after-effects were dealt with.

That is apparently one of those stories that has gone around in the soap world that really isn't true. Some "Love of Life" fans on another board said that while Ben was in prison he was about to be raped, but then there was a fire in the prison and Ben got out and saved his potential rapist I believe.

I hadn't heard that take on it, Dan. That's interesting. In any event, the fact that LoL even broached the topic is still impressive, IMO.

That is apparently one of those stories that has gone around in the soap world that really isn't true. Some "Love of Life" fans on another board said that while Ben was in prison he was about to be raped, but then there was a fire in the prison and Ben got out and saved his potential rapist I believe.

I had heard that too. I have discussed this on my board with some other fans too. Some have that opinion of the story that Ben escaped being raped too. I know that some remember it like I did that even though it was not shown that you know what happened. I guess thinking now years later, it was best to leave it like that and not discuss it much.

I do remember a quote from a book called "The Soap Opera Book". I don't have the book any longer (lost it along with many others), so don't remember who wrote it. But it was the 1970's. But a quote from it said it was an attempted rape too: "This year on Love of Life, Ben Harper was convicted of bigamy and sent to prison. At first his imprisonment was marked by boredom and depression; later he learned of the violence that is equally characteristic of prison life. He was subjected to physical attacks, and even to attempted rape.

The show tried to realistically depict the cruelty and degradation experienced by men behind bars. (In addition, this story marked the first time that male rape was ever discussed on a daytime serial.)"

I remember Christopher Reeve discussing the role once on a talk show - could have been on James Lipton's show. He said that he knew about the proposed story, but was already leaving to take on the role of Superman. It was Chandler Harben's first story as Ben. I remember him saying that the character was raped, but he didn't say if he saw the show or not.

Here is a pic that I got some years ago of Chandler Harben as Ben during the prison story. I don't remember who the other guys were, but some of them look familiar. I didn't save the caption for some reason.

I guess some will debate it for years, and maybe that is what the writers wanted. I do know that most historians agree with those of us who say the rape happened. But who knows for sure.

I don't see the big fuss about a male/male rape scene as brutally as they rape women on soaps. It's actually a common thing for women and nobody seems to care. I remember being particularly disturbed during Bianca's rape on AMC and Emily's on GH.

The closest thing to a male rape would be Kevin getting beat up in prison. That was pretty heartbreaking.

Days has done male rape before (Austin by Sami, John by Kristen - not male/male), but they've never had one that dealt with the effects of the rape.

When did Kristen rape John?

Paris 1996.

Billie raped Bo in the pit.

I knew I forgot one. So Austin, John and Bo have been raped.

maybe it is Will that gets raped that would be a interesting story..maybe its Alan and he's come back for revenge by getting with Sami's son.

IF they recast Will with someone who could act, I'd think it'd be great to have Will be the victim, should it happen to begin with.

Think of the possibilities of Sami confronting her own past rape while trying to deal with Will's.

Sweeney would ROCK those scenes.

maybe it is Will that gets raped that would be a interesting story..maybe its Alan and he's come back for revenge by getting with Sami's son.

Um, I'd doubt that Alan would rape Sami's son to get revenge on her. He's not gay.

It'd be pretty difficult for Alan to rape Will anyway, considering he's got no manhood. I guess they could write around that, but that'd be trying too hard.