7 minutes ago, carolineg said:

 

I was going to name her, but I felt bad.  It was too much.  Same with Robin Christopher's foray on all the ABC soaps

 

Someone claimed recently that JFP wanted Robin to be a Cassie recast on OLTL in '99. I've never heard that but it wouldn't shock me.

3 minutes ago, Khan said:

I can't believe no one thus far has mentioned Kelly Sullivan.  Shame, too, since she's a Broadway legend and all.   

🤮I thought I had completely blocked out Paprika/Oregano from my head completely! 

I loved Kale Browne on AW as a kid but he was horrendous on OLTL and then the GH stuff just got laughable.

 

I always liked Robin Christopher on all the ABC soaps but I can see why people didn't.

 

Did anyone like Alicia Leigh Willis either time? GH definitely tried to make her a thing and for someone who ate up so much airtime, she's basically forgotten on the show. I don't think people really hated her, but I don't think anyone was sad to see Mary Beth Evans leave GH. Jensen Buchanan was of course also awful on GH.

 

It's not the exact question being asked but GH history is filled with characters the show trie to make happen that never took off. Some of them even had big names in the role. 

Edited June 12, 20205 yr by AdelaideCate007

Just now, Vee said:

 

Someone claimed recently that JFP wanted Robin to be a Cassie recast on OLTL in '99. I've never heard that but it wouldn't shock me.

 

I couldn't see her as Cassie at all, but she was all wrong for Lorna on AW and that didn't stop JFP lol.

 

I think Robin is fine as Skye on AMC, but not on every soap on ABC.  

Speaking of Kale Browne does anyone else remember for a couple years on Days I’d say during the Sheffer years Browne kept playing a go to doctor that everyone had when they went to the hospital or had hospital scenes? I wonder if Browne’s role was suppose to be bigger like John Callahan’s character was or if Browne just needed the paycheck lol.

33 minutes ago, AdelaideCate007 said:

I loved Kale Browne on AW as a kid but he was horrendous on OLTL and then the GH stuff just got laughable.

 

I always liked Robin Christopher on all the ABC soaps but I can see why people didn't.

 

Did anyone like Alicia Leigh Willis either time? GH definitely tried to make her a thing and for someone who ate up so much airtime, she's basically forgotten on the show. I don't think people really hated her, but I don't think anyone was sad to see Mary Beth Evans leave GH.

 

It's not the exact question being asked but GH history is filled with characters the show trie to make happen that never took off. Some of them even had big names in the role. 

 

ALW's Courtney was slightly promising in the beginning with AJ.  But awful after that.  I do sorta remember liking her with Jax at first, but the drab 4 years were just so much..  And I think Spencer remembers her?  But agreed she never spoken about in any other context.  Mike doesn't even mention her.

 

I like Katherine Bell.  I liked MBE as a bitch and in the Ned/Lois story and with Lucy.  But it was when they paired her with SN's Stefan and pushed her off a parapet  a million times it was done lol!

Edited June 12, 20205 yr by carolineg

Courtney appeared as a ghost a few years ago. It was mostly a showcase for a Frank Valentini fave, little Nicolas Bechtel, who in fairness has become a decent actor since then but really should be recast/SORASed as Spencer.

Another name: Christopher Douglas.  Couldn't happen on OLTL, Y&R (although, that one probably wasn't his fault) or on PASSIONS.

Jordi Vilasuso keeps getting miscast in role after role.

Daniel Cosgrove

9 hours ago, carolineg said:

Agree on Sarah Brown, but I would say Tamara Braun.  GH twice, Days twice, and AMC.  Granted she was popular on her first stints on Days/GH, but her 2nd stints were failures.  

 

Scott Clifton was/is heavily pushed on all his soap roles. 

 

Michael Easton in all his roles especially his 10 million GH roles.

 

Are we talking about multiple failures in roles or just one really heavily pushed role like Cameron Mathison or Alicia leigh Willis (not counting her fairly minor AW role)?

 

I know he is a big part of B&B but was Clifton that pushed on GH and OLTL? OLTL fired him and threw him under the bus for godawful Rex. 

6 hours ago, carolineg said:

 

I couldn't see her as Cassie at all, but she was all wrong for Lorna on AW and that didn't stop JFP lol.

 

I think Robin is fine as Skye on AMC, but not on every soap on ABC.  

 

I think she was cast on AW pre-JFP, but I agree she was wrong for the part. 

7 hours ago, soapfan770 said:

 
Pretty sure Justin had the last laugh on that one. Was Phelps also responsible for bringing in Timothy Gibbs aka Dash from Santa Barbara? I remember all the brouhaha in the soap mags over Phelps “stealing” Gibbs away from AW around the time Amy Carlson was leaving.

 

He was already on AW at that time, but she pushed him into a central role. 

Scott Clifton was a surprise hit for GH along with Lindze Letherman as Georgie and their pairing together, so they quickly overexposed him while just as quickly beginning to disenfranchise her for not being 'hot' enough. They worked to push him with Julie Berman's Lulu, with anyone else, but ultimately his run petered out when non-Georgie story for Dillon failed and ran dry. By the time he did OLTL he was yesterday's hot guy, which is probably why they were allowed to have him. He had no favorite treatment or protection there and was sadly discarded right as the show was planning to pair him with Daphnee Duplaix's Rachel. Then he went to CBS and he's got security for years to come.

What constitutes as “happening” and not “happening?”

1 hour ago, All My Shadows said:

What constitutes as “happening” and not “happening?”

For me, “not happening” means someone who hops from soap to soap (edit: or is force-fed to us intermittently on a single soap), is pushed heavily or paired with popular characters romantically or as part of a core family, only to be greeted with a “meh,” a quick axing or a ticket to the backburner. Some of these people seemed like they happened with brief success on one soap but were revealed to be a flash in the pan when they tried to re-create that success elsewhere in daytime. IMO Scott Clifton, as awful as Liam is, definitely “happened” on B&B. He’s led that show for years.

Edited June 12, 20205 yr by Faulkner

Steve Burton was an utter disaster on Y&R, no wonder he ran back to GH. 

AMC tried to make Zander, Raquel, and Kit happen. Have any of them appeared on TV since?

4 hours ago, DRW50 said:

 

I know he is a big part of B&B but was Clifton that pushed on GH and OLTL? OLTL fired him and threw him under the bus for godawful Rex. 

 

I think she was cast on AW pre-JFP, but I agree she was wrong for the part. 

 

 

I guess my point about Clifton is that he was heavily featured on all 3 soaps he was on at some point and he's totally bland to me in every way.  And not someone I would think would have this long of a soap career.

 

I would consider Jacob Young the same way.  Not necessarily a failure, but wholly unimpressive in all his roles.

 

Didn't know that about RC/JFP, I think I always assumed she was responsible for the Lorna recast.