Jump to content

15? 30? 45? 60? 90? Which is the best and worst runtime for soaps?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 28
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I'm surprised these streaming platforms haven't attempted to do their own soap opera. I think a 30 minutes soap like BB with about 19-22 minute long episodes, if executed properly can do well on these platforms. It will also help them by holding onto viewers that subscribe to watch a particular series and then cancel when done binging as this will run continuously and it will also bring back viewers regularly to watch and then move onto other content on the platform. 19 minutes doesn't seem like much of a commitment which is beneficial with today's fickle viewership. 

 

I'm sure there are many factors which have also kept these streaming services away, like production cost, a long-term commitment as most shows have a small episode order, and the performance of current soaps on TV. Either way, it would be interesting to see how soaps with perform on streaming platforms with a fresh perspective. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

For me, it would depend on the writing, but I would lean more towards 60 minutes. Looking at some old 30-minute soaps, they did a lot of exposition scenes. Two people have a conversation or interaction and the particulars of that event are then retold at least one other time, if not more, to other people, who then continue to talk about it amongst themselves. Some of it was necessary to make other people aware of the event for story purposes but, beyond that, it got repetitive.  Granted, it likely resembled real daily life in that sense, plus it probably also made people feel so familiar with the characters. In the 60s and 70s, with fewer options, the audience was probably used to that and the resulting longer play-out of storylines. Write like that now and it would probably bore people who want to see more action-driven stories, or something more than characters having repeated conversations about the same incident. In this case, 30-minute soaps would take too long for most people's tastes at this time to tell a story. If I were having to watch Ryan's Hope and Dark Shadows now in real time (an episode a day, no fast forwarding option), I would probably fall away from them from getting tired of the repetitiveness of dialogue.

For years now, I've tended to watch dramas rather than sitcoms...some serialized, some stand-alone, some sci-fi, some real-life based. I like being told a story that builds up in that episode, has conflict and may or may not get resolved in the same hour. It's hard to do that in 30 minutes with any real depth. 
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The best is probably 30 minutes. Nice, succinct, tighter focus.

 

There are exceptions - if any soap really benefits from being an hour, it was classic Y&R, who had the time and space to unfold things in their own, measured pace.

 

 

It's the classic daytime vs primetime debate. I've always loved the talk scenes too. Daytime has the time to do them; if they are done well, they provide character interactions and character work. It still annoys me today that we don't see characters react to things in primetime that much. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members


Oh, I enjoyed them up to a point, too. I just think people nowadays have a mix of shorter attention spans, more options, less time or patience, desire for "shock and awe", etc. Back then, that's what we knew and choices were limited so, of course, we watched. Using the 2 soaps I mentioned before...in the case of RH, I think it worked well in the sense that you really got familiar with the characters, their frustrations, flaws, family interactions, motivations, etc. Very realistic to have people repeat conversations and stories, just like people do in real life...and those conversations often colored the characters' interactions with one another. How many people heard about the Ryans or Delia's shenanigans before getting to know either well enough on their own? I've recently started binging DS on Amazon (up to where Barnabas is about to debut) and I made mention in another post of how that early period seemed very slow-moving and repetitive, talking about the same incidents and with not much in the way of action. Even in binging mode, it seemed to drag on. For someone to watch that in real time now, I wonder if they wouldn't give up pretty quickly. That being said, I have never watched the current 30-minute soap "The Bold and The Beautiful" (not sure what the acronym is, BB??) so I'm not familiar with its storytelling pacing. Has it changed in the years it's been on? If someone were to be introduced to it now, how would it seem?

Conversely, if they were to write without a lot of that exposition now, that might cause a certain disconnect or disinterest with a viewer who's interested in character building. I just think, with anything less than 60 minutes, they're having to make decisions of how much do they show and tell in an episode, drawing and maintaining viewer interest over a longer period of time to tell a story. Do they spread it out over time and risk viewer impatience or sacrifice more in-depth character study for the action?

It just came to my mind the 30-minute soap that probably depicted these differences in storytelling the best: Port Charles. We started out with a conventional soap with conventional characters, much like any other soap. Somewhere it was decided that wasn't working and the whole format was changed. The hospital setting was now an accessory rather than a focus. A continuous throughline became 13-week arcs that were told independently of each other. Character buildup and personalities were tossed aside to accommodate the plots that were now supernatural. How many new viewers took notice? How many current viewers liked it or hated it? In the new arc format, it was already a given that, for better or worse, a particular story was going to be told in that amount of time. They did what they had to do to make the story work...turned heroes into villains, destroyed long-term relationships, etc. By the next arc, that could get changed again. It all comes back to the writing and pacing.
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I get your argument, but I feel is more of effective in discussing 60-minute soaps than it is in discussing 30-minute soaps. The characteristics of 30-minute soaps that you've described are due more to the period in which 30-minute soaps reigned (1960s and 1970s) than they are to the 30-minute format. This was before the VCR age, before the turn to action/adventure storylines, before the desperate pursuit of younger audiences, etc. Even Ryan's Hope, as a half-hour soap, was affected by these and became less dialogue-heavy as time went on.

For the record, I'm a big fan of dialogue-heavy soaps for the reasons @YRBB gave. When daytime was presided over by the classic writers, those scenes created a strong sense of character, relationships, and community. Agnes or Irna, I can't remember which one, called it "the luxury of time." Soaps had it, no other medium did, and once upon a time, soaps were soaps and catered to people who wanted to watch soaps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members


That's why I asked the questions about B&B, since it has the distinction of being not only the sole 30-minute soap today but also one that's been on since the 1980s, offering up a comparison of their old vs. modern storytelling styles and viewership. Could that serve as a barometer for measuring how a new 30-minute soap might do? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

30 mins. It this age with all the entertainment options to choose from, it's much easier for someone to keep up with a 30 min soap. If you decide to binge a week's worth at once, and fast forward through the commercials, it adds up to the average length of a movie, which isn't bad.   

 

It's also better from a production standpoint in my opinion as well. I feel like 30 min soaps are more focused, the stories keep moving forward and you don't have characters having the same conversations day in and day out, just to fill time. 

 

I feel like Brad Bell does a really poor job taking advantage of B&B being 30 mins. I've watched several European soaps on and off, they are all mostly 30 mins and do a great job overall. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Brad Bell can't tell a story. B&B would have been better off a decade ago if he handed off the show to a competent head writer and simply produced the show. That's all I'll say because I don't want to spill the tea (as they say...).

I believe Irna said that either just before or just after the launch of ATWT

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I actually found an article online a few days ago and I wish I had saved it, but it mentioned how returning soaps to 30 minutes might be the future of soaps. I believe it was written in the late 2000s and it was obviously wishful thinking as we know that networks actually preferred canceling soaps altogether rather than reducing their runtime. It mentioned that GL and OLTL might be the first soaps to experiment with the time reduction as they were the lowest rated. 

 

I always hoped networks would have reduced GL and ATWT as well as AMC and OLTL into 30 minute shows and package them as an hour block to affiliates. It would ultimately give affiliates an hour back in programming while still maintaining the shows on air where fans were used to tuning in to watch. Shifting OLTL and AMC online was a nice thought but it changed the entire dynamic of how people ordinarily consume their soaps...it wasn't like they were experimenting with new soaps. They were taking already established soaps and changing the familiarity as far as consumption for the audience.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I agree with you about reducing the struggling hours to half-hour shows and then selling the hour as a block. That would have been smart for CBS and ABC. The networks seem to forget that they can have a higher CPM in a half-hour soap versus an hour soap opera because there are fewer ads. Scarcity leads to higher ad prices. CBS could reduce Y&R to half an hour, lose one soundstage, halve the cast/crew/staff, up the ad price, and suddenly they'd have a very profitable show!

Oh, maybe another day! That's what I get for cruising message boards after three cocktails!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • They interacted before when Dani and Pamela were at the casino. 
    • The last few episodes have been good; the acting, the emotions. It's nice to see that GH can still do classic soap opera. I do wish that they would respect their long term audience more and do it without all the silly rewrites though. And where do they go from here? I'm a bit pessimistic and fully expect the show to go back to the drama-less, boring mess it usually is. I'm giving it a month, tops.
    • RATINGS & PREEMPTIONS UPDATE:   1979-Present: 4 Weeks of data missing:   1 Fast Weekly Week: 8/24/81...This week is missing the prelim ratings and full/partial preemption data.   3 Partial Regular Weeks: 12/14/87, 5/20/91, 5/27/91. These three weeks have ratings data (one from Daytime TV; the other two of the three weeks have ratings & share data from Soap Opera Weekly) These weeks are missing the affiliates/clearances and partial preemptions data. Full preemption data is confirmed by comparing the # of telecasts in the preceding and succeeding books.   TOTAL: 4 Weeks of data missing from 1/1/79-Present (out of 2,422 weeks) 99.9 percent complete!   1973-1978: 35 Weeks of data missing:   10 Full Regular Weeks: 9/3/73, 9/10/73, 9/17/73, 9/24/73, 10/1/73, 10/8/73, 10/15/73, 10/22/73, 4/10/78, 4/17/78. These ten weeks are missing the final ratings/shares/affiliates/clearances and partial preemptions data. Full preemption data is confirmed by comparing the # of telecasts in the preceding and succeeding books. For September 1973, the full preemption data is not confirmable, but newspaper listings & Vanderbilt News telecast listings provide the best list possible in its place.   25 Fast Weekly Weeks: 4/23/73, 6/25/73, 8/27/73, 12/24/73, 4/22/74, 6/24/74, 8/26/74, 12/23/74, 4/21/75, 6/23/75, 8/25/75, 12/22/75, 4/19/76, 6/21/76, 8/23/76, 12/20/76, 4/18/77, 6/20/77, 8/22/77, 12/19/77, 3/20/78, 4/24/78, 6/26/78, 8/28/78, 12/25/78. These 25 weeks are all missing the preliminary ratings and full/partial preemptions data.   TOTAL: 39 Weeks of data missing from 1/1/73-Present (out of 2,735 weeks)  98.6 percent complete!   Note: From the Days of Our Lives and Another World research, the full & partial preemptions should be all available, even from the 39 weeks above.
    • Yes. They were very much out of ideas for Reva by this time. A talk show, blindness...the time travel story... That would have made sense.  (were they acknowledging the Beth/Bill relationship by this point)
    • Will be up tomorrow.   lepää rauhassa Taina Elg

      Please register in order to view this content

          TAINA ELG          3/9/1930 - 5/15/2025 THE DOCTORS         Diana Ross      "Tomorrow Is Ours Today" week of 2/3/64 THE GUIDING LIGHT      Dr. Ingrid Fischer     1980 ONE LIFE TO LIVE     Olympia ___Buchanon "Nicole Bonnard"  1980-81 THE EDGE OF NIGHT      Madame Forrester        1984 ALL MY CHILDREN           Countess Irina Korsova         Unknown Year   LOVING                           Mrs. Mulryan           1993 and HERE'S HOLLYWOOD      Self   1961 MISTER BROADWAY    Self    1964 YOKYOPELIT     Self    1966 CA' C'EST L'AMOUR   On Camera host    2003 movies SUOMISEN PERHE     Lapsi Ollin Kutsuilla    1941 NAIMISIIN  PÄIVÄKSI    Tanssija Kabareessa    1946 THE PRODIGAL      Elissa         1955 DIANE       Alys         1956 GABY     Elsa     1956 LES GIRLS   Angele Dueros    1977 IMITATION GENERAL     Simone    1958 THE 39 STEPS       Fisher    1959 WATUSI    Erica Neuler      1959 THE BACCHANTES     Dirce     1961 SUOMALAISIA MAAILMAN   TURUILLA -- TAINA ELG     Self     1963 JUHLAT LINNASSA    Isabelle Oopperan Pikku Tanssijatar   1966   (Made for T. V.) HERCULES IN NEW YORK     Nemesis     1970 THE GREAT WALLENDAS    Helen Wallenda    1978   (Made for T. V.) LIEBESTRAUM       Old Mother Ralston    1991 DON'T DRINK THE WATER    Anna Gruber      1992   (Made for T. V.) THE MIRROR HAS TWO FACES    Female Professor    1994 TRUE LOVE      Self     2003 STARRING -- TAINA ELG   2003      (Made for T. V.) KUMMELIN JACKPOT     Mrs. Skogstedt    2006 BROADWAY LOOK TO THE LILIES        3/29/1970 - 4/19/1970      Sister Albertine UNCLE VANYA     6/4/1973 - 7/28/1973     Standby --   Yelena Andreyevna  WHERE'S CHARLEY?      12/20/1974 - 2/23/1975   Donna Lucia D'Alvadorez  ****  TONY AWARD NOMINEE -- BEST FEATURED ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL THE UTTER GLORY OF MORRISSEY HALL       5/13/1979     Mrs. Delmonde STRIDER      11/14/1979 - 5/18/1980    Replacement --  Viazapurikha; Methieu; Marie   2/5/1980 - ???? NINE      5/9/1982 - 2/4/1984   Guido's Mother    CABARET    3/19/1998 -1/4/2004     Standby -- Fraulein Schneider TOURING IRMA LA DOUCE     1/4/1962 - 8/25/1962      Irma La Douce I MARRIED AN ANGEL    1964      Angel      GIGI      9/9/1964 - 6/22/1965   Inez Alvarez THERE'S A GIRL IN MY SOUP - NATIONAL TOUR    1969     Shubert Theatre   Cincinnati, OH TWO BY TWO   9/15/1972 -3/11/1973      Esther A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC  --  NATIONAL PREMIERE  1973 - 74    Desiree Armfeldt    Australian National Tour ZORBA     1976     Madame Hortense 13 RUE DE L'AMOUR        1978    Léontine TITANIC    1/5/1999  - 9/10/2000      Ida Straus; 3rd Class Passenger THEATER PAUL AND CONSTANTINE     1957         La Jolla Playhouse REDHEAD       1960     Essie       Dallas State Fair THE TENDER TRAP   1963     Poppy Matson   Paper Mill Playhouse CAN CAN        1964   Claudine      Kenley Players   Columbus, Ohio SILK STOCKINGS       1964     Notchka           Melodyland, CA WEST SIDE STORY       1966      Maria   Finnish National Opera   Helsinki THE SOUND OF MUSIC     1966 - 71     3 Productions UNCLE VANYA     1974      Standby for Julie Christie   Circle in the Square Uptown SOMETHING'S AFOOT     1986     Miss Tweed    Liberty Hall   Lowell, MA CABARET     1996      FrauleinSchneider    Walnut Street Theatre Main Stage Philadelphia REQUIEM FOR WILLIAM     2003    Connelly Theater, NYC          MEMORY OF SUMMER    Alice O PIONEERS! I HATE HAMLET Family Ties Parents --     Helena Doroumova (an immigrant pianist) and Ake Elg  (Ake Ludwig) also a pianist Marriages      Carl Bjorkenheim   1953 - 58    Divorced   1 Child -- Raoul Bjorkenheim      Rocco Caporale    1982 - 6/30/2008      His Death         LAURA PILLMAN   THE BOLD AND THE BEAUTIFUL      Cassandra    4/24/2025   NURSES' BALL DANCER                            RODRIGO VARANDAS      GENERAL HOSPITAL     Nurse Jack       5/21 - 23/2025 movies VIVENDO COM ZIKA        2016 LET'S DUB: VOXX STUDIOS COMMERCIAL     Audience    2016 BIO FILTER   Mr. Ramirez    2020 PSYCHE     Entity      2025 RED SOULS FEELING GOOD A MINUTE TO LOVE Upcoming SEESAW     Max      TBA    In Production THEATER ORIGINAL -- THE MUSICAL: THE LIFE STORY OF JANIVA MAGNESS    Candlelight Pavilion LEGALLY BLONDE     Candlelight Pavilion THOROUGHLY MODERN MILLIE          Candlelight Pavilion SINGIN IN THE RAIN     2015      Ensemble    WEST SIDE STORY       2015     Pepe     Candlelight Pavilion  EMPIRE   (World Premiere)   Jesse; Ensemble CHILDREN OF EDEN    2016   Storyteller; Snake    Cabrillo Music Theatre WOMEN ON THE VERGE OF A NERVOUS BREAKDOWN       2017        Carlos IRVING BERLIN'S WHITE CHRISTMAS   2017      Ensemble    Long Beach IN THE HEIGHTS        2017      Swing; Ensemble    Musical Theatre West CABARET    Herman -- Kit Kat Boy     2018      KINKY BOOTS     2020    Announcer; Angel       Cerritos, CA MAMMA MIA       2021   Pepper; Ensemble    Understudy -- Bill     SHREK    Dragon Puppeteer; Big Bad Wolf   YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN   2022     Ensemble           1776           Leather Apron;  Painter A FEW GOOD MEN    William T. Santiago  ROMEO AND JULIET     Romeo TOURING PETER PAN      Cecco SINGIN' IN THE RAIN     2014 https://stagescenela.com/2016/03/juan-caballer-rodrigo-varandas/       WANTED TO LOCK TRACY UP                                      JEFFERY THOMAS JOHNSON       Also Credited as Jeff Johnson   PARTY OF FIVE 2.0    Officer __ Bryce   2020 GENERAL HOSPITAL    Sheriff __ Lewis   April 2025 and NEWTON'S CRADLE     Officer Goodloe   2020 MY SECRET AGENT HUSBAND    Maverick Thompson     2024 HER POSSESSIVE GUARD       Gage      2024 movies THE TWO JAKES      Golfer    1990 QUEENS LOGIC      Club Patron     1991 DRACULA      Van Helsing's Student     1992 TEXAS PAYBACK     Board Member    1995 CALL GIRL    Man in Black   1995 CITIZEN RUTH   Harlan's Biker Friend     1996 LOVE ME TWICE     Phillip   1996 AMERICAN TIGERS     Krause    1996 THE BRAVE       Clerk    1997 CONTACT     Mechanical     1997 THE POSTMAN      Rope Bridge Soldier   1997 GETTING THERE     Waiter in Ski Lodge    2002 OPERATION TERROR     Federal Agent Thomas   2012 LIFE TRACKER   Brigadier General Anthony Morris    2013 CARDINAL MATTER      Jeremy Ryan    2016 THE DEVIL HAS A NAME      Police Captain     2019 AQUARIUM OF THE DEAD     Smith    2021 SUPER VOLCANO    Guillerman     2022   (Made for T. V.) 20.0  MEGAQUAKE     Guillerman   2022   (Made for T. V.) ICE STORM      Guillerman    2023    (Made for T. V.) BIRD OF PARADISE     Dominic Dunaway     2023 THE LAUNDRESS    Guy Sullivan    2024 DEAD WRONG     Mason    2024 24 HOURS TO D-DAY      Major Jones     2024 THE SIX TRIPLE EIGHT    Colonel Davenport    2024 Upcoming FIRE ANT     Nolan Karr   TBA   Post Production  INCIDENT AT COTTER CREEK     Mason     TBA    In Production JOY RIDGE    David Whipliton     TBA   In Production ALL PAID FOR     Jack    TBA     Pre Production                            ASHLEY CAPLE   GENERAL HOSPITAL   Hot Girl at Pool    6/14/2023                            Charlie's Pub Waitress     1/28/2025 and TREASURE KING      Daisy Duke    2014 HEROES WITH ISSUES    Cortara     2016; 2018 movies DESTRUCTION: LAS VEGAS   Spring Break Female    2013 ENTOURAGE      Sloan's Friend     2015 THE GUEST HOUSE   Kristy   2016 DOES SIZE MATTER     Girl in the Park  # 1     2016 HOOKED ON A HEIFER    Hot Babe # 1  Brutus' Girlfriend   2017 TALES OF FRANKENSTEIN    Adelina   2018 ASS CLOWNS: CONSTIPATED   Pool Girl   2021 OFF THE RECORD      KLM Casting Girl    2024 Upcoming NOIR      Mistress    TBA    Post Production     RED CARPET DUDE                                   GEORGE PENNACCHIO   GENERAL HOSPITAL    George Pennacchio, Red Carpet  Nurses' Ball 206; 2018; 2019; 2023; May 2025 movies SPLENDOR     Newscaster     1994 FOUR FINGERS OF THE DRAGON    Self      2003 THE LEGACY     Self    2010 SILENT LIFE: THE STORY OF THE LADY IN BLACK   T. V. Reporter   2023 Appeared in the sitcom Less than Perfect in 2003. Serves on the Board of the charity group, The Thalias. Has been the Entertainment Reporter since 1996 at ABC-7 in Los Angeles. He also hosts Oscar Specials.  
    • I can see why the Sam/Amanda story went downhill so fast. Thomas Gibson was a terrible replacement. I don't remember the circumstances of RKK quitting  (if his contract was over or if the departure was more acrimonious), but Gibson just sucks the energy out of every scene. He has no chemistry with anyone.
    • They have renewed my interest back into Hayley. I hope they keep writing her like today. She was fun and looked fabulous. Facts on top of facts! And that is the area that I want them to deep dive into more.  I forget what her purpose was for even visiting him at this point. Leslie had a great May but she can not do more of the same in June and July. I became very excited to see them interact. I don't know where it is going, but it could be a joy to watch. 
    • Dani and Doug interacted for the first time I believe. Could that be indicator that they will hookup? As wacky and drama filled as Dani is I think she'd have a lot more respect for Doug than Vanessa does and Vanessa really needs a dose of her own medicine.
    • I remember it was reported at the time that the character of Noah was originally planned for Harley but plans changed.   Beth should've shared her experience as well.
    • I really hope they fix this soon. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy