Yeah, Erica should be proud if that's how Jack figures this out. David wasn't planning anything nefarious when he figured it out. He saw odd behaviors, and followed the path to put them together. It didn't take him kissing her or sleeping with her, he knew her enough to realize that the behaviors weren't because she was kidnapped or because she was drinking.

David wouldn't have delivered that conclusion either had he not as a doctor noticed the surgical scars.

David wouldn't have delivered that conclusion either had he not as a doctor noticed the surgical scars.

Jack should too, though, right? I mean, theoretically they sleep in the same bed, and he's close enough to her?

It's not even really about David, it's more just about my hating that Jack doesn't know. Or isn't even close to figuring it out. This isn't Erica. He of all people should be putting the pieces together.

That said, no matter what I think...Erica doesn't seem like she's going to be happy with it. Hopefully she'll stick to it, and won't take him back easily.

I'm not a Jack & Erica fan due to Jack. Everybody in Erica's life knows she is acting strange and if that's all David had to go by he too would have been in Jack's boat. There's things that are visible to a physician's eye that wouldn't be visible to me and you due to lack of experience.

Jane: I'm buying everyone lunch.

Toups, you hungry?

I'm not a Jack & Erica fan due to Jack. Everybody in Erica's life knows she is acting strange and if that's all David had to go by he too would have been in Jack's boat. There's things that are visible to a physician's eye that wouldn't be visible to me and you due to lack of experience.

It must be a Jack thing then because Y&R's Jack couldn't tell the difference between his fiancee & her double either.

Gotta( my Jane imitation ) disagree Adam. I don't think he is missing the boat. He has known that something is off since the first day, but Jack doesn't have a criminal and devious mind, so why would he even think of a double/twin etc, had taken Erica's place? I don't think it's farfetched at all for him to not have that cross his mind yet, but after the way she is acting about the girls, it's coming. Can't wait for him to find out what Jane did to Erica and that scumbucket Hayward knew all along.

I hope you are right about them getting married I have always been a fan of the couple. I like their differences, their chemistry, and their history. WW/SL make it work for me and I've only liked her with a couple of other men from years ago. So hopefully the plan is to bring back Reggie/Lily and the K/M family will go out together.

I almost vomited watching Bianca and KWAK holding hands IS Bianca wacky? This woman stole your Miranda. Give me a break already

JR is so freaking hot these days. I would love to see him hook up with Greenlee

Loved Kendall/Griffin today.

I agree with most of what you said, but I'd rather have JR with Amanda than Greenlee.

Trevor knew that "Natalie" was Janet after they had sex for the first time.

Yup, that's how I remember it too and that was how Amanda was conceived.

Yeah, Erica should be proud if that's how Jack figures this out. David wasn't planning anything nefarious when he figured it out. He saw odd behaviors, and followed the path to put them together. It didn't take him kissing her or sleeping with her, he knew her enough to realize that the behaviors weren't because she was kidnapped or because she was drinking.

Like Angela said, David noticed the surgical scars, which wouldn't be apparent to those of us without a medical license. He also saw her have an allergic reaction to fennel, which is one of Erica's favorite foods, before he put 2 and 2 together. If Jack had seen that, he might be more suspicious, too. At least he knows something's wrong, but can't figure out what yet. That makes him smarter than Trevor was, imo!

^It wouldn't be a comfort to me if that was my guy. I don't think Erica will be all that crazy about it either.

Griffin and Kendall had so many opportunities to kiss this week! Friday should've been the day, it would've made for a great cliffhanger (or lead in to Jack finding Doppelgangerica with the drink). I loved everything Griff/Kendall related this week, especially their scenes at the yacht club. Kendall looks stunning in that emerald dress!

I like Minx, but wouldn't it be awesome if Bianca fell for a hardcore butch lesbian? I want to see her with a pool playin' plaid wearin' chick with a nose ring, buzz cut and a Marlboro Red dangling from her mouth. I'll name this lesbian "Ritch" -- and she & Bianca would be known as "Bitch".

Edited June 12, 201114 yr by Pine Charles

Erica would die.

Jane wouldn't tell her.

LOL