Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (โ‹ฎ) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

American Idol

Featured Replies

  • Member

Speaking of AI, has anyone seen the hilarious spoof of Clay Aiken on Mad Tv? Ike Barenholtz is hysterical when he mocks him!

  • Replies 1.6k
  • Views 151.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member

Aren't the figures a little mislead since Kelly has released two albums compared to one from everyone else?

  • Member
Well it hasn't even been a full year since Carrie won, so I don't think it's quite fair to compare her to Kelly (as far as albums being sold) right now. But I do think it says something when her first year isn't even finished and she's already passed Fantasia and is about to catch season 2 idols. I think it's premature to say she doesn't have staying power. If she doesn't, I'd chalk it up to youth. How many teenage stars stick around for the long haul in a music career anyway? How many teen sensations from the 80s or 90s are still recording today? Not very many. Here's the thing... we all like different styles of music. I didn't see the first season of AI, so I really can't say too much about Kelly since I don't listen to pop music anyways. I liked Ruben & Clay, and third season I cheered for Latoya & Jennifer~however, I felt like season 3 was not as good as season 2 or 4, talent just wasnt there. I couldn't stand Fantasia, she just seemed like she had a chip on her shoulder... the fact that Simon told her at the beginning that she didnt need this competition didn't sit well with me either. It was if he was trying to make it impossible for anyone else to win. Last season, it didn't matter to me whether it was Bo or Carrie. I liked them both...

Now, back to this year; does anyone know if there's any plans to re-broadcast Tuesday & Wednesday's audition episodes?

Exactly couldn't agree more.

This is a message a dude left on the freaky tan chick's Myspace:

"Well first off yes I'm here cause I saw you on Idol, I can't believe you didn't make it to the next round cause you are legitamently a good singer.

But anywho I'm glad you didn't let their rude comments get you down and just think now your famous!

So don't let go . . .

You've got the music in you :)"

Haaaahahahahahaha! What a liar. He just wants to get her number.

:lol: OMG that was so great. I agree with KR-thanks for posting that.

Carrie has released one album, and has not found her true creative direction yet. Despite that, she has the #1 country song and #1 country album in America and her CD is flying off the shelves. She's going to continuing to thrive at country radio and in sales and will probably have a lot of crossover success as well.

Good show last night. I liked Ace.

Again I agree. Kelly's album was the same way. I liked her first album but her second was great. Carrie's first is good so once she finds what she wants to be and what direction she wants she will be successful. The girl has talent and is very likable IMO. Her album has doen very well so she is off to a good start, much like Kelly was, so its a good sign for her.

Aren't the figures a little mislead since Kelly has released two albums compared to one from everyone else?

Again I agree but she is off to a great start and its only her first album. We shall see but Kelly and Carrie are definitely my favorite winners while Bo, Vonzell, and Clay as my favorite runner-ups/contestants.

  • Member

I am so happy that AI2's Josh Gracin has done very well since the show... He's probably the only one not in the top 2 who has had considerable success.

And with Carrie, she appeals not only to the big country audience, but the mainstream audience as well... I don't think Carrie will sell more albums than any other Idol before, like Simon said, but she will definitely be successful for many years. Kelly has proven herself to be a legitimate star, musician, singer, songwriter.

American Idol as a show is definitely a much bigger success than most of the stars they churn out

  • Member
Aren't the figures a little mislead since Kelly has released two albums compared to one from everyone else?

Clay's Christmas Album and Ruben's Gospel Album are included in those numbers, but ...

We can just do debut albums if you like :) The rankings would be ...

#1 Clay 2.7 million

#2 Kelly 2.3 million

#3 Carrie 2.1 million

#4 Ruben 1.8 million

#4 Fantasia 1.8 million

Idol stats this week.

Billboard 200

Kelly Clarkson falls to #12

Carrie moves up 2 spots to #3

Breakaway hits the 5 million in sales.

Because of You is #14 on the Hot 100

Jesus, Take The Week is #25 on the Hot 100

Bo moved up 6 spots and hit Gold status this week. (500,000 units sold)

Carrie has the #1 Country Album, #1 Country Song, and #1 Country Single Sales

Kelly has the #1 Adult Top 40 Recurrent

  • Member

Damn, that Lil' Kim wannabe is fixing to diss Paula. !@#$%^&*] better back up! Ugh!

  • Member

WTF? They acted like she was gonna !@#$%^&*] out Paula to her face. LOL, what a let down!

What a delusional !@#$%^&*] though! Paula was so nice to her. She needs to shut her damn mouth.

  • Member

I've been very annoyed with AI's editing this season.

Also, what was with showing all of the guys in NC during that like unattractive guy montage? Most of those guys weren't even shown auditioning and some of them seemed pretty normal looking to me......

The editors and producers of AI really piss me off sometimes.

  • Member

Geeze...that Rhonetta was nasty!! LOL...i laughed my ass off!! However in some ways..i loved her attitude..and at other times i wanted her to shut up already!! :lol:

  • Member

OMG that guy who danced with Paula was great. I also liked the guy who said he had a Paula and Randy DVD and said that they taught him how to sing or something. My God Simon was on cloud nine after hearing that and he was actually hilarious today.

That Rhonetta chick had no right to go off on Paula like that when Paula didn't say a word to her. Her offering her a drink was a kind gesture. The judges were clearly pissed off at her though because she was taking her sweet time in the audition and screwing around. She was hilarious in a Springer sort of way. Man though she had a big mouth :lol: !!!

The AI audtions this year have been great IMO. Some of the editing has been annoying but I love how we see what the judges say after the people leave the room and there are some really bad and weird people coming in this year. IMO this has been the best auditions ever in terms of entertainment value. I sitll like it when we get down to the good singers though but so far I am enjoying the auditions.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions โ†’ Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.