American Idol

[Jonathan]

Elliot! Elliot! (Reminds me of ET. ) Elliot better not land in the bottom 2 or I'll be pissed. He was great!

[PhoenixRising05]

I actually don't think their will be a shocker tomarrow in regards to who goes. I think we may have a shocker in the bottom 3 but the person who goes won;t be a surprise. Based on everyone I talked to in regards to getting through on the phone lines, the said Bucky and Ace's were barely busy while the others were busy frequently. They said Katherine's they could get through on too but not all that much so for the first time ever, based on all this, I am gonna make predictions on how I think people voted. You can all laugh at me if I am wrong . Again this is not on my opinion but on what I think will happen given fanbases and such.

1. Taylor

2. Kellie

3. Paris

4. Elliot

5. Chris

6. Katherine

7. Bucky

8. Ace

I think I am really going out on a limb here with some of this but its mostly instincts and based on fanbases and such.

Oh my friend just told me to check out dialidol.com and they have this exact order and she said they were right last week so maybe I am not out on a limb .

[KMan101]

Yeah, Phoenix, that site was how I found out ahead of time what might go down.

They have their flaws but are generally correct. I do know Paris/Mandisa/Elliot all shared the lowest number of votes at times last week but it looked like Mandisa was the one going and sure enough... argh.

And wow at the POSSIBLE bottom three. Looks like we COULD get a surprise (in the bottom three that is)... maybe, maybe not. But we gotta also remember that the text votes aren't counted and although they probably aren't THAT massive and change things too much just 1 percent could change someone's entire standing so...

[DaysnPassionsFan]

I think people are checking out DialIdol a lot more now. I know I am. I'm sneaking in a couple votes for Katharine now at 10:57 and I have gotten 7 busy signals and 2 votes! I've never gotten a busy signal past 10pm before

Please, please, please... Chris, Bucky, and Ace in the bottom 3

[KMan101]

From your mouth DaysPassionsFan...

That would so rock. I can already hear the boos of every horny teenaged girl out there when Chris and Ace are called to the bottom three.

If either Katharine or Paris go home I am SO done with this show. If they stay I'm definitely joining up with DialIdol. I love the concept of it and wish I had bothered to investigate it further last week. I probably could of tossed a lot of votes Mandisa's way...

[Gray Bunny]

Regardless of their overall performances tonight, I can't believe Chris is ranked at No. 6 in votes. Lord knows he's got the most talent. But he definitely needs to stretch his horizons and try different songs. He should definitely sing a slow ballad next week. Go for the smouldering, sensual songs.

What is with this country's fascination with dumb country hicks? No wonder Jessica Simpson is so popular and Britney Spears still makes magazine covers. Whether we love 'em or hate 'em, people are interested in them. I *so* hope we don't crown Kellie the next Jessica Simpson to hit the music industry. It's like she's trying out for the next "Newlyweds" every week. This week, she didn't know what Simon was talking about when he made the analogy that "on paper, your song choice didn't look good". "On paper?" she asked. Oy. Ironically, Oprah Winfrey's topic on today's show was about highschool drop-outs and how kids aren't getting enough education. I think Kellie is a prime example of that.

Ace showed off some nice guns today when they showed footage of him meeting with Queen. He's got the right look and build, so go try out to be the next shirtless wonder on Passions. No talent required.

Paris is cute. I can't believe she's the only sista left. I wish she'd keep with her cute bob haircut instead of putting funky extensions in it every other week. Other than her ever-changing appearances, her voice is always solid.

Speaking of dumb hicks, Bucky once again mumbled something with his marble mouth that Ryan Gaycrest made a subtle joke at.

With or without statistics to prove anything, my guess at who would go tomorrow night would be Bucky or Elliot. But it looks like Ace will be signing off.

Shoot... I forgot about Katharine again. Ho-hum.

[R!ck]

It looks like your getting your wish

Chris's inability to sing anything other than "hard rock" is grating my nerves. He should have been on Rock Star instead of American Idol.

[KMan101]

It's definitely Bucky or Ace.

I'm not surprised Chris is getting less votes than before. He didn't do very well last night. He shouted, you couldn't understand him... He's still the best left but he blew last night. When you suck you don't get the votes. Look at Mandisa.

[RogerNewcomb]

I thought Ace and Katharine were the worst of the night by far. They should be the bottom two if there is any justice. If Katharine almost had a "moment" it was a bad moment. She was pitchy the entire song. I was holding my ears. Ace is the worst singer left.

Bucky picked the perfect song for his voice.

Chris sounded great, but I wanted him to pick a song I had heard before. It's all about singing well and he does.

Elliott was my favorite of the night, followed by Taylor.

[kelli_blue]

I was surprised by Chris last night....not a great song choice at all for him. I think he could have done much better! I thought Ace did a sucky job too.

I ended up voting for Katharine, Elliot and Taylor. I thought Kellie did pretty well too, but I just couldn't vote for her!

[DaysnPassionsFan]

I can hear them already too

[OneLife Fan]

Not a bad show last night!! There are 8 good singers left...so anyone can be in the bottom 3. Taylor was my fave of the night!! The man is BACK..and i loved it!! Kellie kind of shocked me with the whole outlook..loved Simon saying she looked like a zombie off of Night of THe Living Dead!! Ace was cheesy...Ellliot was good...Bucky was pretty good...Katherine was pretty good.....Taylor was awesome....Paris was cheesy....Kellie was ok...and Chris was great..but sang the same [!@#$%^&*]!! He needs to break away from that rock stuff!!

Bottom 3 tonight will be : Paris, Bucky, and Elliot.

[DaysnPassionsFan]

I can't wait for next week's theme...

songs from Rod Stewart's Great American Songbook. I'd rather have a pure Big Band/Standards night, but I'll take what we can get. It'll be great (aka funny) to see some of the Idols singing the standards

[OneLife Fan]

Rod Stewart? This should be interesting!!

[darraholic]

1. Paris (I enjoyed it. Best Vocals imo)

2. Elliot

GAP

3. Katharine

4. Chris

5. Kellie

6. Taylor

GAP

7. Bucky

8. Ace