That's because Jackie was a very complex character when the Dobsons wrote her: selfish and immature when she married Justin (which is why he regretted breaking up with Sarah MacIntyre). But Justin was also an @sshat. She walked in on him with another woman.
Yeah, she was a horribly selfish person, giving Phillip away just to spite Justin, stalking Elizabeth so she could be close to Phillip, snapping up Alan the minute they go divorced so she could raise Phillip because she assumed Alan would have custody, keeping the secret that she was Phillip's mother even when he was practically dying from a genetic heart condition, contemplating leaving Alan when he lost custody and only staying because she got pregnant, which she did not plan.
I'm going to say it again: Marland didn't play the beats. When Elizabeth found out, did she tear Jackie's hair out over all this, as she had a total right to do? NO. She decided Justin and Jackie should get custody of Phillip! And even MORE ridiculous: ALAN, who was indirectly connected to a murder during the first custody fight for Phillip, eventually agrees to it! And Elizabeth, who was portrayed as loving her child as much or more than Alan even did, leaves him and is barely heard from again.
He instead turned Jackie and Justin into a couple of holier-than-thou types, totally taking away the complexity and nuances of the characters. For some reason, he potrayed them getting custody of Phillip as the right thing to do, when in fact, it had to be a major reason why Phillip was so completely f@cked up, because the two people he thought were his parents gave him away for no discernable reason.
It didn't really become convoluted until Marland took over the story, having all the characters behave in ways that were really inexplicabe.
By
DeeVee ·
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.