Jump to content

All: Best and Worse Cancer Storylines?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 16
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

GH has totally botched Alexis' cancer. Not only is it not about her, it's about her family being destoryed and her daugther being taken from her by the evil soon to be ex-husband. It's sick.

Guza messed up badly. He had the chance to tell a real family/emotional/love story with the Lansing family at the heart of it all, and instead he went for cheap plot point crap. I hate him almost as much as AMC's MMT. He doesn't know a good thing when it bites him in the ass.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

ATWT's Lucinda was very well-played by Ms Hubbard.

Contrary to everybody, I think GL's Reva was not that bad. Myself, I have a cancer and can totally understand Reva's reaction.

I have never seen a bad cancer storyline (GH's Alexis was not bad, the only problem was the shift to Sam !)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Best: Lizzie's leukemia on Guiding Light. Heartbreaking; the little girl who played Lizzie was so precocious, cute, and talented!

Worst: Lucinda's breast cancer on ATWT. It started out strong but quickly fell apart. They don't even mention the fact that she had it anymore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Contrary to popular belief - yes they do mention Lucinda's breast cancer still. Not often but she and Luke just talked about it last week.

Here are my choices for the best:

1) Monica's breast cancer (GH) tied with Kate Rescott's cancer (Loving)

2) Lucinda's breast cancer (ATWT)

3) Lizzie's leukemia (GL)

4) Alexis's cancer because of the way that NLG has allowed herself to look sick (GH)

5) Reva's cancer (GL) - like the other poster I can understand Reva's reaction - even though I don't have cancer I have a life-altering disease and I can understand the reaction

6) Domique's Cancer (GH)

7) Felicia's cancer (B&B) - was great until the botched ending

8) Vicki's breat cancer (OLTL) - was so heartbroken and moved the day Vicki told Dorian about it

9) Bert's cancer (GL) - back in the 60's - one of the first ones for daytime, truly well done from the clips I have seen

10) Steve Kaslo's leukemia (SFT) - one of the best and one of the most heart-felt stories ever in daytime for me

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

EE (EastEnders) had the best cancer stories I've ever seen in a soap.First Peggy's breastcancer in the 1990s.Peggy is a very fiesty character and to be honest played by one of the worst actresses on the show (Barbara Windsor) but this story was very well done and it was Barbara's finest moment as Peggy and they didn't drop it afterwards it still gets mentioned from time to time.

Dot's cancer story a few years ago (2003-2004) was the best one I've ever seen.Dot is a very religious character and didn't want any treatment untill she realised how many people cared about her.The two hander episode with Dot and Den Watts where Dot came to realise this is one of my favourite episodes ever.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I would've loved to see all of Monica's storyline. I thought Alexis's cancer storyline was all about Jason/Sam/Ric, and not enough about Alexis herself.

Emily's breast cancer wasn't all that good either, I thought it was written poorly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Yes.

Molly Montgomery (daughter of Travis and Barbara) contracted leukemia. They couldn’t find a bone marrow match, so Travis (married to Erica) and Barbara (married to Tom) cheated on both their spouses so they could conceive a child that would be a bone marrow match. The child was Sean.

Mona Kane had lung cancer in the early '90s. The actress, Frances Heflin, also had it in real life. While the character's cancer went into remission, Heflin sadly died from it in June 1994.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I'd say Lizzie's leukemia on GL.

Lucinda's cancer story started out well, and was excellent when it focused on her. At some point, it became a plot point to Lily's never-ending love life (Lucinda blackmailing Keith to take her to Mexico so Luke could stow away and get lost...*groan*) WHICH SUCKED.

Felicia's cancer on B&B played well, until Bell relented and changed the ending. And while I don't remember much of it, I'll never forget Bert Bauer's, which mirrored Charita Bauer's real life.

Oops...forgot worst...

Recently, Johnny's illness on ATWT. And Kim Zimmer's scenery chewing on GL. Both seemed more like plot points.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I do think Ben should come back. I think Max Bowden is all wrong for Ben.
    • Thank you, been waiting so long for this, and I appreciate how much work it is typing this all out and creating the charts for us!

      Please register in order to view this content

    • FROM THE VAULT: WEEKLY DAYTIME NIELSEN RATINGS: WEEKS OF 1/15/73-1/19/73 & 1/22/73-1/26/73:

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Up to episode 340. Jason Vinley has been at the helm for just under around a month and has quickly whipped the show into shape. He has made many smart cuts to the show's large canvas including writing out Jason Prescott, Deena Greely, the Cummings family, and phasing out Carla Redlon. Carla and Gene's failing marriage is an interesting idea, but I'm not always overjoyed by the execution. Elain Graham comes back later and another actress plays the part for a bit. I'm not really sure the angle they are going here, but it's probably one of the only decisions I am not too thrilled with.  Vineley has narrowed the canvas into several stories and allowing events to spider out and impact a series of people. The stalking of Lori Martin has climaxed into the revelation that Blue Knowles, the Cinderella Rapist, has been follwoing Lori for weeks on end. The build to this with a group of different men being around Lori at the time of the incidents is very low key and allows the viewer to draw their own conclusion even though we can also see the man in the sun glasses. Lori's attack on her final night at the Monroe School is a compelling action sequence playing out parallel with a much smaller scale heist in the school by two of Lori's pupils. The end where Blue traps her in the classroom and Ben stumbles upon her lifeless body is wildly engaging for a show that has rarely been able to tell a story without having a deus ex machina style ending.  The fallout is equally compelling. Ben was stabbed in the hand in a fight with Blue which leaves the ability to use his hand in jeopardy. Peter, who was suppose to pick Lori up if Ben couldn't, feels guilty because he was out with older woman Vicki Lang at the Greenbriar and later back at her place where she attempted to coerce him into bed. Placing both Davidson children in sexually suggestive situationsthat the same time was an interesting choice. With the identity of the rapist unknown to the canvas, Gil Prescott suggests to his sister Marianne that her boyfriend Russ Weaver might be the rapist, which seems both logical and calculated on Gil's part.  Episode 340 is just very intense and high interest viewing from beginning to end as the story spirals in several directions for several characters. There is a really nice moment with Ione and Gene Redlon visiting Terry at the hospital that cements the ties between the two families. Gene later comments to his mother wondering how a man can become a monster. Later, Terry talks to a catatonic Lori that she is both relieved Scott isn't here and deeply missing his presence. Comparing this sequence of Lori in the hospital to the year prior when Lori was also in the hospital is night and day. The show is tight. The balance of religion and drama is perfectly balanced and comes off less as preachy and more as deeper characterization. When Gil attacks Marianne's faith after Lori's attempted rape, Marianne delves further into what trily turned Gil away from God, Corrine Prescott's painful demise at the hand of cigarette induced lung cancer.  In 341, the show has changed the opening and reflects the show's new era is a nice symbolic move. I appreciate that Vinley also maintains the rich canvas of side characters (offscreen) with references to Jill, Gary, and others who have come and gone while building up what is to come with references to Ronnie Washington and Hugo Lancelot. I am looking forward to the next year or so of episodes.  
    • FROM THE VAULT: WEEKLY DAYTIME NIELSEN RATINGS: WEEKS OF 1/1/73-1/5/73 & 1/8/73-1/12/73:

      Please register in order to view this content

    • It would have been great if CBS had worked things out with P&G and brought SFT back to the network in 1987 when they knew Capitol was going to be axed. Then hired good writers to do their thing to revitalize the show. No offense to the late great Bill Bell, but B&B has been a mess. 
    • Thanks. Wish those appearances were available.
    • FROM THE VAULT: WEEKLY DAYTIME NIELSEN RATINGS: WEEKS OF 1/14/74-1/18/74 & 1/21/74-1/25/74:

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Regarding the NBC years of SFT. Joanna Lee did a good job. She gave Jo a great story and ratings rised but Joanna left because she hated the pace of daytime. I remember seeing Joanna Lee’s great big red hair one day outside the studio. lol Her hair exited the studio before she did. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy