This thread is already way out of hand. It isnt about Sheila anymore. Posters attacking other posters....btw..Kenny pass the popcorn.

LOL, I'm a participant, and I'm even enjoying it like y'all are!

Hogan/Marland

Just because I say I like the story how is that disrespecting your opinions - it's not.

I like Kimberlin Brown - still do. But I like this story too. You are right you are entitled to your opinions. And I and others are entitled to ours.

I love the story so far, and I love Michelle Stafford in it.

Just because Kimberlin is not there I am not going to condemn the story from the get go.

I was Hunt Block's biggest fan as Craig on ATWT, but I didn't prejudge Jeffrey Meek either and now I love Craig again and love Meek in the role.

I never thought I would like anyone other than Brian Bloom as Dusty, but I actually like Grayson McCouch. I liked him a lot better when Hogan was writing him. But even now I still love McCouch even though I miss Brian Bloom.

All that I or anyone else that likes the story asks is to allow us to enjoy it. We are giving it a chance. Sorry but right now I love Y&R the whole show, and think it is the best thing in daytime, but again that is just my opinion. The main thing I like about it is that Latham is taking chances that the other soaps are not taking. She is like many of the great dayimte writers and producers of the past who took chances.

I specifically am referring to Harding Lemay. He went against the grain many times and didn't play it safe. And he gave us the some stinkers but some real big winners too.

Edited January 5, 200718 yr by SteveFrame

Hogan/Marland

Just because I say I like the story how is that disrespecting your opinions - it's not.

I never accused YOU of being among the ones who were/are direspecting our feelings.

Is everyone just getting over their NYE hangovers or what?

I thought you were on our side, Kenny. Come on, think of all the favors ive given the Eileen camp. We need reinforcements so these people GET A FRICKIN CLUE.

fauxSheila must die!

This thread is already way out of hand. It isnt about Sheila anymore. Posters attacking other posters....btw..Kenny pass the popcorn.

I thought you were on our side, Kenny. Come on, think of all the favors ive given the Eileen camp. We need reinforcements so these people GET A FRICKIN CLUE.

fauxSheila must die!

AAAAAAMEN!!

SHEILA AND KRISTEN FOREVER!!!

Edited January 5, 200718 yr by HoganStaysAtDAYS1

I'm a fan of MS and KB. However, I hope this story fails because KB IS Sheila for me and LML trying to have MS play Sheila just to give her "dramatic" scenes without having to mess with her precious Phyliss and Nick reeks. It's too reminiscent of Guza and Maurice Bernard on GH. Also, it's lazy writing. What's next? Will MS play a returned Diane in disguise in more "riveting" scenes with PB? While she's playing Sheila, will she then morph into a young Latina and play Isabella too? Puhlease.

I wish LML to purgatory.

Exactly. And its pathetic. I don't think a head writer should show such blatent favoritisim as she does.

fauxSheila must die!

LMAO!!!!!!!!!!! I havent laughed this much in a long time.

I thought you were on our side, Kenny. Come on, think of all the favors ive given the Eileen camp. We need reinforcements so these people GET A FRICKIN CLUE.

fauxSheila must die!

Oh my God, please don't drag me into this! LoL

I've already said, it's a MISTAKE to create "Pheila." It's camp, totally unbelievable, and doesn't make sense. Why would she choose Phyllis, anyway? She would've chosen Lauren. This isn't up to regular Y&R standards.

However, that being said, Michelle Stafford IS doing a terrific job. No, she doesn't make a better Sheila than Kimberlin Brown. The writing for this whole thing is campy and contrived and the whole basis of it doesn't make sense. But I CAN appreciate that Michelle IS giving it her all. The writing blows -- Michelle doesn't. Kimberlin should be there instead, but only with a story worthy of her talents. Really, I mean that.

Please don't kill me.

Michelle Stafford is a pill these days. Her on screen presence has diminshed and I do not see the nuance in her Shiela portrayal. I'm simply bored. She's simply recreating the icy Phyllis who blew into town and now claps her hand as if she's really happy and wants to show it.

The story sucks and the delivery isn't convincing. That's my opinon; feel free to disagree.

Meanwhile... just sharing the Kristen love!

Exactly. And its pathetic. I don't think a head writer should show such blatent favoritisim as she does.

How does LML show favoritism, I am sorry by Y&R is one of the most balanced soaps out there, if you want to see a show based all on Favoritism check out ATWT, the head writer has 8 favorites and those are the only people we see everyday.

I'm seriously cracking the fluck up over here. When I left, this post had 3 responds. Now, it has 5 pages

Place me on team Kimberlin

To quote the fine ass Halle Berry as Storm, X-Men, "There's a war coming. Are you sure you're on the right side?"

Edited January 5, 200718 yr by DrewHamilton

I'm seriously cracking the fluck up over here. When I left, this post had 3 responds. Now, it has 5 pages

Place me on team Kimberlin

To quote the fine ass Halle Barry as Storm, X-Men, "There's a war coming. Are you sure you're on the right side?"

Holla!

Meanwhile... just sharing the Kristen love!

Oooh, and holla again!