Paul Raven

The Dobsons created the Justin/Sara relationship but then never did much with it. Having Sara marry Dean was a poor choice for the character. I don't know why writers always persist in marrying characters? Sara could have been in a relationship with Dean w/o getting married. it lead nowhere and just gave Sara a poor marital history. They could also have played a renewed Sara/Justin romance as an obstacle to Justin/Jackie remarrying. Re Fran Myers I wonder if she would have been open to occasional appearances? Especially if they decided to SORAS Billy as the new young lead. We need a GL tell all book . Enough actors are still around from that era to spill the tea.

Chancellor Estate is identical to before from what I've seen. They need to get rid of that bulky cheap looking sofa and chair. It makes the tiny set look even more cramped. Something much more elegant is needed. And here's Mariah in the same motel set we've seen over and over. Her storyline would have to rank as the most poorly paced, poorly motivated plots on the show. And from the folks that brought us Dumas, AI and Mitch/Matt that is no small achievement!

JWS had some time off in 83 I think. What happened with Mike and Jennifer? No onscreen chemistry? Geraldine Court was a Marland favorite, so I am surprised that romance was halted. Pure speculation but maybe Don Stewart wasn't happy with the pairing and spoke out. Allen Potter sided with Don. Part of the growing tension b/w Marland and Potter. Agree that Hope and Alan were married too soon and given a dud ceremony. They could have got more out the relationship before a wedding. God knows, Alan had enough baggage to make Hope have some second thoughts before committing.

I just read that Michael J Stark tested for Andy Norris, but lost to Ted LePlat. He got Joe Bradley instead which I believe was recurring at first but Marland liked him and he got a contract. Maybe that's why Andy was written out- Marland liked Stark/Joe better as Springfields next villain. As for Peggy, she was unjustly forgotten. I don't know if Fran Myers didn't want to return, but it would have been nice if she came back to Springfield upon leaning of Roger's death and was allowed to play Peggy's reaction to that. Of course if her son Billy was already in town, living with Bert and involved with Morgan...

Looking at Nov 80 synopses there is mention of Joe Bradley making romantic headway with Holly. The same month she left town. Interesting. Maybe Marland was just using that as a motivation for Holly to leave-she was still hooked on Ed and couldn't deal with the complications of another man taking an interest? Or he was testing the chemistry in case Maureen renewed her contract? How much say would Marland have in such matters? If Allen Potter or P&G/CBS wanted to keep Maureen would Doug have to go along with it, even if not that interested in writing for her? Headwriters have a certain amount of autonomy but there must be many instances where they have to write for actors/characters they are not that invested in.

I always read that Andrew Robinson was not well received because viewers identified him as a villain due to appearances in movies like Dirty Harry and Charley Varrick. Yes, Frank was not supposed to survive that fall down the stairs. But ABC intervened and the show was stuck with an actor originally intended for a few flashback scenes.

So soapy that Ted's original venue was unavailable so all 4 end up at the CC. Kat got around today-Orphy's, her mom's office and Martin's. As usual not much work being done- Martin, Smitty and the kids all at home -what time of the day was it supposed to be? It was only at the police station that they actually at least talked about work. Jacob noticing Marcel's shirt and how expensive it was? Guess the Vanessa and Kial meet up was to give her a POV about him to Nicole? Not Kat's biggest fan bit I can see her side of it as Eva has been pretty nasty at times. And there's no story in them becoming besties. Things are humming along nicely...

I wonder if the retirement of long time producer Lucy Ferri Rittenburg had an impact going forward in that she may have had more respect and knowledge of GL history, having been there for decades. Allen Potter and the Dobsons were new to the show in 75 and the Dobsons showed they weren't overly familiar with the past eg when they were asked if Emmett and Jackie Scott were connected to Peggy and they admitted they didn't know Peggy's maiden name was Scott. Now that's not a sin I guess, but maybe someone like Rittenburg might have pointed that out and they could have changed the name, or connected the new Scott's to Peggy's family or at least referenced it. When Bill came back was there reference to Meta and Trudy discovering their brother was alive? I'm sure viewers of 10 years or more (and cwere a lot of them) would have been hoping for/ expecting a mention.

Really the minute SFT was cancelled GL should have snapped up Mary Stuart to play Meta. For 35 years you followed her tragedies and triumphs as Jo (stills or clips) Now Mary Stuart returns to daytime television as Meta Bauer. (Clip of Meta embracing Ed and Rick) Mary addresses the camera. "Looking forward to seeing you again on Guiding Light. Join me weekdays on CBS"

Remember that TGL was only 15 min in length until 1968 so there was only so much room for various characters. By the late 50's, Meta had been through a lot. Agnes had taken over as headwriter and probably wanted to write for new characters who were a blank slate. Even then they wanted younger characters to carry the storyline. So Meta was given her happy ending and moved to the back burner. I don't think we saw Bruce much, the actors were recurring. Meta left in 66? but did return for visits I think until finally in 74 she was written out officially. Was this because Did Ellen Demming chose to retire? Otherwise it would have been nice to see Meta when Bill returned, at various Bauer weddings/funerals etc.

Lori March?

I like those ideas. Steve could become the Papa Bauer type figure advising not only Rick and Ed bit also various doctors and nurses. And if Meta returned , there could be a sweet older romance to offset the shenanigans of the older set. OK today's homework- who could have played Meta in 1985?

You're probably right re Marland. I think there was a problem with those older characters on GL as they were no longer connected to anyone. Barbara's whole family was written out, Steve was just a doctor at the hospital and Adam had lost Roger. So newer viewers wouldn't have had much of a connection to those characters, not knowing their histories. And of course, being vets, they would have been on good money that could be spent elsewhere. It would have been nice if they stayed on recurring so they were seen from time to time, just to keep continuity. Barbara Berger had to wait till 85 to get another gig, but it was a good one-10 years on AW as Bridget. Robert Milli got Lars Bogard on AMC and Stephan Schnabel got a short gig on EON.

Another interesting show in 81/82 was NBC's Chicago Story. It was 90 mins in length and difficult to place on the schedule. Don't know what NBC were thinking. It had played as a 2 hr movie the previous season and done well. The cast and concept was interesting. Dennis Franz, Daniel Hugh Kelly, Maud Adams, Vincent Bagetta, Craig T Nelson. It's original timeslot was 8.30 pm Friday, following the Mickey Rooney sitcom. I guess the idea was that viewers would stick around after Mickey through to 10pm. and steal viewers away from Dukes of Hazard and Dallas. It seemed misguided at best. Then that plan was dropped and Chicago Story became a back up show. It finally aired on Saturday in Wk 22 of the season following One of the Boys (the Mickey Rooney sitcom with Nathan Lane and Dana Carvey) One of the Boys was #63 and Chicago #61. Meanwhile a 2 hr Love Boat was #11. Things only got worse as the show moved to Friday and flamed out. Don't know what NBC was thinking ordering a 90 min series with no suitable timeslot.

Fascinating discussions here. Thank @Reverend Ruthledge for detailing the Helene/Marie relationship. As for Gentry, do you think that it would have been a good idea to bring him on in 82 as Ed? I have always thought Marland was OK with Hulswit but it was production that wanted him replaced because of backstage issues and wanting a more youthful Ed. Hulswit was balding and had gained weight at that point. They dropped Barbara, Steve and Adam which Marland expressed displeasure about, although that may have been just to make himself look good with the fans.

The whole story is the usual Y&R mess, crafted to fill actor guarantees and perceived popularity. For the story to have any kind of real drama and resonance, the scale and budget would have to be much grander. But Josh continues to churn out these stories with limited characters and sets. Even the dreaded business stories might be more watchable if we had offices and extra staff.

But there will still 20 or so episodes that will need to be covered. So there will have to be repeats scattered throughout. Why don't they just order another few weeks worth of new episodes?

Lynn was at one point married to Colby Chester, best known to soap viewers as Michael Crawford on Y&R.

Helene Benedict was the next snobby society matron who disapproved of her daughter Anne getting involved with Paul Fletcher. And like the Grants, Henry was much the much more tolerant father. Agnes always liked that meddling mother type-Pheobe, Enid,although did OLTL have one?

Thanks @DRW50 'There's nothing really wrong with Kathy except for mental and physical exhaustion'. Meta, that's a lot actually. The Roberts need to invest in a 3 seater sofa -it was kinda squashy. Not sure what was going on in the Grant's living room set. Were those curtains and a bamboo blind, or some sort of wall feature? @Reverend Ruthledge Would love to read the 50's stuff. Enjoyed your summaries of TGL in the radio thread.

Well, the Hastings brothers had been in the business since the radio days. I wonder how close Bob and Don were as they were on opposite coasts for decades.

They could have done the 'Penny's mother befriends Afton with the intent of stealing the baby, seeing it as the grandchild she never had. Losing your daughter due to an illegal abortion might be enough to tip her over the edge. JR double crossed so many people that there was a huge pool of victims wanting revenge. Imagine if 3 or 4 of them hooked up and devised an elaborate scheme to divest JR of all his assets. And of course because JR has to ultimately win, they could turn against each other.

Looking back at the one and done episodes in the early days, Garrison (Ellie's brother) came to my attention. He was killed off. But later I think it would have been interesting for a son/daughter to appear. Better than Jack/Jamie Ewing? Any other early plots that could have been utilised later on?

There is so much rubbish on Facebook about all the soaps eg 'Peter Bergman's heartbreaking decision to leave Y&R' etc so I'm inclined not to believe it.