Roles that Had 3 or More Decent Portrayls

[Vee]

I think Brooke Newton was a potential stealth hit as Colby on AMC 2.0. She started out as a total vixen but revealed layers near the end of the run with Cassandra and Opal and caught on with the audience. I think she would've been big.

[cassadine1991]

Mindy Lewis - Krista, Kimberley and Barbara

[Chris B]

Ryan's Hope had to endure a lot of recasts, but I found the ones I saw mostly worked. 

Mary Ryan - Of course Kate Mulgrew was a star in the role, but I feel like had they stuck with Mary Carney, they would've been fine. I guess the pressure of recasting such an important character got to them which is what led to Kathleen Tolan who was dreadful and probably killed any interest in the character. Nicolette Goulet was fine, but I was over Mary at that point.

Siobhan Ryan - Sarah Felder was EXCELLENT and should've never been fired for such stupid reasons, but I loved Ann Gillespie in the role. Marg Helgenberger was loved in the role (although not a personal favorite). I also though the last Siobhan (Barbara Blackburn) was good she just needed more time.

Frank Ryan - This was probably their most successfully recast role. I always liked Frank regardless of who played him. Daniel Hugh Kelly was my favorite, but they were all good. I know the original gets mixed reviews, but I didn't mind him either.

The only Ryan kid they absolutely could not recast was Pat. None of the recasts felt like the same character to me. It wasn't that they were bad actors, but they weren't Pat. 

[Joseph]

Ironically Y&R's Phyllis And Diane!!!

Both Had three talented Actresses portraying them (Michelle, Sandra and Gina) & (Alex, Susan and Maura)

Patty Williams (Tammy Taylor, Lilibeth, Andrea and Stacy)

And Maybe Jill (Brenda, Deborah and Jess)

Viki Lord (Gillian, Erika and Christine Jones!)

Mindy Lewis (Krista, Kimberly, Barbara)

Dr. Laura Horton?

Abigail Devearaux (Hannah from PLL, MARCI AND Kate)

Billie Reed 

[Wendy]

Going way back:

Santa Barbara: Mason Capwell: Lane Davies, Terry Lester, Gordon Thomson

Days of Our Lives: Dr. Mike Horton: There were a ton of actors in the role, but Wesley Eure, Michael T. Weiss, and Roark Critchlow all seemed well regarded.

[BrendaB]

Do you have a link to that episode?  Sounds intriguing.

Slightly tangential to your topic, but did anyone else play Erica Kane as a temporary recast (like if Susan Lucci was pregnant or sick) and is there footage of it on Youtube?  It'd be cool to see a thread of iconic soap characters that had been played famously by a single actor get temporarily portrayed by someone else...

[Paul Raven]

La Lucci was irreplaceable. There was never a temp recast. When Susan took maternity leave, Erica was written out.

If Susan was ever unable to work, they must have written around it.

Edited April 4, 2023 by Paul Raven

[AMCHistory]

On AMC we had a some memorable Scott Chandlers. Shane McDermott played the geeky son of Stuart Chandler to "T." He was gawky, awkward around girls, and so handsome. He would have grown up into a leading hunk if they gave him a chance.

AMC was really focused on the "hunk factor" in the late 90's and we got Daniel Cosgrove. I remember all the ads they did with he, Michael Lowry, Tanner, and Pierce playing-up the hot guys of Pine Valley. Daniel was great in the role, if not unmemorable. I wish they let Daniel show his comedic side, which none of us knew he had.

Forbes March played Scott as the classic [!@#$%^&*] boy. The very handsome son of a wealthy family. Forbes was quintessential model turned actor. I may not remember him being particularly memorable, but I definitely remember dreaming about his chiseled face and body.

 

[Planet Soap]

Please register in order to view this content

Claire as Dorian, 1977

[BrendaB]

Thanks @ironlion.   LOL @ Mr. Fitch getting flustered by Dorian's question.  The actress looks like a combination of Susan Seaforth Hayes and Dixie Carter.

[Planet Soap]

Love that scene too lol!

[John]

Jason Kincaid who replaced Justin Deas in 1984 was not well recieved and replaced with Greg Marx

[Joseph]

Y&R's Eden Baldwin??? (Erin Sanders, Vanessa Marano, Jessica Heap)

[AMCHistory]

Not one of these actresses was decent. I don’t think there was any love she for this character. Everytime they recast I had hope, but Heap was especially bad. 

[Joseph]

i can't give much of an opinion as i never saw the original one, barely saw Vanessa in the Role and Saw Heap near the end of her run so MAYBE she got a bit better as time passed, i thought Both Marano and Heap were decent but again I'm not sure how valid my opinion is!