1 hour ago, Mitch64 said:

The worst part of Lucy is that she was not only a terrible character, she brought other characters down with her.  First were the young characters played by better actors  like  Bridget and Kat who got their airtime gobbled up by this non-entity, then there was AM, who had really great chemistry with Gilly, but they had to regress him to be in love with Lucy. Then there was the overload of Buzz and the Coopers and that they were trying to replace Harley with Lucy. Then they can't decide on what she was..first she came on as the "spunky" Harley lite, then she is the damsel in distress. They even threw the old soap trope, raping her, to make her a victim and somehow earn the audience's sympathy, (which ruined another great character/actor Brent Lawrence who could have been Roger's mini-me but instead became a psycho named Marion. 

So, what you're saying in a nutshell is that Megan McTavish happened to GL, right?

7 minutes ago, Tonksadora said:

So, what you're saying in a nutshell is that Megan McTavish happened to GL, right?

Nope...JFP happened first..she brought Lucy on and put her in the spotlight and force her into AM and poor saps at home, apparently desperate for a super couple to root for (never got that) were cheering on LAM (E). Buzz was eating up the show on Jill's watch, Kat left during Jill, she put Gilly with Sid Dickerson instead of AM and then McTavish came on board and just, continued the same...(though she upped Jill by making poor Gilly fall in love with her own bio-dad!!) 

9 hours ago, Vee said:

Actually, a lot of people at OLTL openly disliked Kale Browne. Hillary B. Smith and Mark Derwin both all but diss him by name in the OLTL oral history as well, but they weren't the only ones.

You miss my point. I'm sure I didn't get it across well enough. I was attempting to tell you what kind of man he was *before* he became an FOJ, since I know what people thought of him after.

Oh, okay. I had it in my head that there was a gap between one #SoapKIller, JFP, and another #SoapKiller McT. My error, entirely. What you had was like a tumbler of poison with a chaser of e coli.

Edited May 5, 20223 yr by Tonksadora
The second part was in reply to Mitch.

GH: Sam took Courtney's place in the show eating quad. Why did they decide to kill Courtney off? Did they loose interest in her once they had the charachter and Jason split?

But kinda in a good way

Edited May 4, 20223 yr by divinemotion

Eileen Davidson ate Days between her various characters for a year or two. Most of it was good, but even that began to be too much by the time Thomas was introduced.

4 hours ago, divinemotion said:

But kinda in a good way

Brooke's stories were pretty entertaining.

6 hours ago, ironlion said:

GH: Sam took Courtney's place in the show eating quad. Why did they decide to kill Courtney off? Did they loose interest in her once they had the charachter and Jason split?

I think it was due to an EP change? I recall Bob Guza was basically forced to write for her.

3 hours ago, Titus Andronicus said:

Eileen Davidson ate Days between her various characters for a year or two. Most of it was good, but even that began to be too much by the time Thomas was introduced.

Oh, now, surely not, how could a few - count them FIVE - take up precious airspace. Kristen, Susan, Sister Mary Moira, Penelope & Tomas, I loved that story, but it was like a whole new family had been introduced & were gobbling up all available bandwidth! I do love that ED did it to herself though. They were going to hire someone to play Susan & she just tossed off, "Why don't you let me do that?" It remains my only favorite JER storyline.

40 minutes ago, Darn said:

I think it was due to an EP change? I recall Bob Guza was basically forced to write for her.

I thought it was Frons that loved Courtney, but then moved on to KeMo and that gave Guza the room to get rid of Courtney.  I do remember he (supposedly) hated her.  Courtney still had that story with Jax and Nik after.  Wasn't JFP the EP the entire time?

I think @Vee said recently that Pratt was fond of Courtney/ALW as well.

15 hours ago, Mitch64 said:

15 hours ago, MichaelGL said:

DAYS: Daniel Jonas and Melanie 😣 What a horrible period that was. 

GL: Of course Reva, but I'd throw in Cassie, Richard/Jeffrey, and Edmund too. 

GH: At this current point; Carly under the current regime. 

 

Expand  

Yea, to all of those on GL...God, who thought those island people were interesting??? Reva ate up the show during Long's

AW had San Cristobal and GL had San Cristobel, if I just assigned them the right one but it was never as bad at AW as GL where it was officially a second location and for way too long. If not for Olivia & Jonathan it wouldn't have been worth it if you ask me. But, for DOOL as much as I love Crystal Chappell, her first tenure at DOOL was as Dr. Carly Manning who was gobbling up all real estate. Besides her being a doctor along with Tom & Marcus, they did a - granted lovely, well done - retcon to make her Jennifer Rose's roomie when they were in Switzerland Boarding School.

3 minutes ago, carolineg said:

I do remember he (supposedly) hated her.

IMO, it just never made sense for Kung Fu Barbie to be Sonny's long-lost half-sister.

1 hour ago, carolineg said:

I thought it was Frons that loved Courtney, but then moved on to KeMo and that gave Guza the room to get rid of Courtney.  I do remember he (supposedly) hated her.  Courtney still had that story with Jax and Nik after.  Wasn't JFP the EP the entire time?

If I remember correctly JFP was at GH for an amazing 12 years! I think so. And, by far the longest she was made welcome. Her pattern is to be popular with the Honchos & half the actors for a few years & then they can't get rid of her fast enough.

22 minutes ago, Khan said:

IMO, it just never made sense for Kung Fu Barbie to be Sonny's long-lost half-sister.

Of course not!  And then they gave Sonny a brother like a year later.  I have to say I could deal with Skipper being Sonny's sister if I didn't have to deal with Jason/Courtney as well.  She was good with AJ.  That era of the 4 of them Carly/Sonny/Jason/Courtney was absolutely dreadful and the pinnacle (IMO) of all the characters airtime.

Edited May 5, 20223 yr by carolineg