Jump to content

Y&R May 2018 Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 306
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

 

But they didn't have their main/connected characters doing those things. Others would be brought on to do it. I can't imagine Adam Newnan causing the death of a baby and burning the fetus in 1991. Or him intentionally murdering a man without going to jail. 

 

I also didn't say Sharon wasn't the only one that was complicit. But just because others were doesn't absolve her. Knowing and continuing to lie and hide it makes Sharon a kidnapper. Being forgiven doesn't mean Sharon should be rewarded for being wrong. 

 

But don't worry. They'll make victor the villain to ensure viewers embrace the idea. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Michael Baldwin went to jail for his crimes. But that is neither here nor there. Attitudes about rape and consent in romance were very different in the 80's and early 90's than they are now. Romance writers whose past work has been reissued in more modern times  have to update their novels. We all know that. However, I don't recall a time where baby killing and baby kidnapping was ever the thing to do. And at least back then I expected people who committed those crimes to go to jail. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

I know that Michael Baldwin served time for his crimes but it still stretched belief that he'd become such good friends with his victim and the man who nearly had to kill him to save her.

 

It's that same belief that has been stretched in order for Y&R to try to make baby killers leading men on the show.

 

To me, it's the same mechanism that soap writers have used to try to make leading and supporting men out of rapists.  It's the thing I've liked least from the genre. I wish the writers would think before they write.

 

But I guess they think it's all acceptable under the guise of escapism and viewers have allowed them to get away with it (except for viewers who have turned off the shows) for decades.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Luke Spencer is definitely one of the more egregious examples. 

 

Roger Thorpe, OTOH, took YEARS for them to redeem, but I see your point.  

 

 

Adam Newman, as written by MAB, was probably one of the most profoundly disturbed characters ever written.  Besides what you mentioned (which was horrible enough), he seduced Rafe and disfigured himself with that needle to the eye.  I tend to agree with you - don't know if a legacy character would have been written like this back in the day.

 

Sharon should have never kept that baby or hid him from his true father.  Her justifications for doing so were weak and yes, she is complicit.  This coming from a Sharon fan.

 

Now on to discussion about today's show...

 

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

I agree. Never liked Michael around Christine. 

 

I see what you mean about it being the same mechanism. I agree to an extent. I cabt wholly agree though. There was a time in the not so distant past where a man couldn't  be said to rape his own wife. But he sure wasn't immune to being said to have murdered her or his children.  My point being murder and rape were viewed through different lenses by which sentiment permeated literature and film in different ways. 

 

I can't recall a time where a main character connected to core killed anyone (unborn or living) that wasn't in self defense during my early years of soap viewing. But I can recall many "ambiguous" rape situations. 

 

Well, I can't lie, I loved Hilary's pregnancy reveal to Devon. They've been really sweet lately. However, only reason this baby is lab made is so the show has the option of playing a sperm switch/WTD later. *Sigh*

 

Jack is such a sad sack. I get why he's upset. If someone told me my daddy wasn't my daddy at this point in my life, I'd be sick too. But, John's gone. He's got all the memories and none tainted with this revelation. So, meh. 

 

Did the show forget that HWG owns Mergeron already.  Why not let Jack run that division? I am curious as to where he ends up. 

 

Why in the world is Nick leaving town?! I'm getting shades of Adam/Victor here. I don't want to see a custody battle over Christian. His parents are gone and Nick's the legal father.  The show should leave it alone. However, I did think Nick and Victor's argument was an interesting/clever way to have the truth come out.  

 

Arturo and Abby have chemistry. I like them. Surprisingly. But he will still be gone in 6 months

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

I bet Shauna is already pregnant like Gwen was. They might as well make an absent Reed the daddy since he's gone. Let Shauna keep it a secret until after her baby "dies". Then bring a recast Reed back while she's mourning. Vikki is old enough to be a grandmother. 

 

I must say, I did enjoy that story on ATWT despite disliking singing Gwen Norbeck with a passion. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

I love Traci. I enjoyed her scenes with Jack and wish she was around more often. I also understood why Jack was upset with Kyle and didn't want much to do with him. 

I saw someone speculate on another site that maybe Jack ends up teaming up with Victoria and starting a new cosmetics company. Maybe Ashley might even join them . I think it would be interesting if that happened and it would annoy Victor.

 

Also, I wonder where the Charlie/Shauna storyline is going. At first I thought Shauna was partially going to be used to usher in her brother who would interact with Devon/Hilary. I haven't learned what her brother's age is, I was thinking maybe he is older and closer to Devon/Hilary's age. I thought we may have seen a storyline where he was trying to get his life together and then ended up working at Hamilton-Winters. During the meantime they could also have Charlie/Shauna and their teen romance. But now we learn that the brother and Shauna's parents have moved to Colorado. So I guess that's not happening. I now think that Shauna  might end up living with Hilary ( and eventually Devon). I wonder if Lily/Cane might even take her into their home, but I think that's less likely. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Kelly was a horribly-written character overall. Just think, two Emmy-winning actresses (including Cynthia Watros, Nina, GH, and Annie, GL) couldn't make it work. Pamela is campy, but so are Dani, Vanessa, Leslie, and Joey. And, I don't want to be too judgy because my love for camp changes depending on the show. OLTL, DAYS, and some eras of GH had me rolling with the camp. However, Passions was overkill and I hated it. And, here, I can take it or leave it. It's ok in small doses (note to RC). I see this show as more of a serious drama.
    • I think one of the reasons that pilot didn't get picked up was because Vicki L was associated more with being Thelma Harper and playing older then she was playing her own age.  It was a blessing it didn't get picked up, or we would have been deprived of the syndicated era of Mama's Family.   Also, worth noting a Pre Night Court Marsha Warfield and pre Perfect Strangers Rebecca Arthur in the cast.  All talented women, but stuck with a bad script. And the other pilot had a pre Fran Fine.. Fran Drescher as the best friend.  I think that pilot might have been picked up if Karen Valentine and Fran Drescher switched roles.
    • So, on rewatch....did Rick and Mindy never have sex? 
    • Cady had a fairly posh accent or manner as Rosanna - the character was a 180 from Dixie when she went to ATWT, and it was a huge success initially. As someone mostly only familiar with the nagging, miserable or clueless Dixie of the mid-late '90s and early 2000s it was what convinced me Cady could act. I thought she was incredible in her first run. Later, in future stints, her hair and story and performances were all over the place but a lot of that was down to the show for me. She brought some of Rosanna back with her to Dixie in her ill-fated return and a lot of people didn't like it, which I understood but I did think the character needed some change. I think she's had a little bit of the same persona and arch performance in every role she's played since, including Jennifer Horton at DAYS or Kelly at Y&R, who later became a maniac and was easily the worst work I've ever seen Cady do. It has kind of infected her overall mannerisms, I'll allow that, but I do think she brought Dixie back together as herself while still evolving the character when she returned to AMC again in 2012-13. Nonetheless, for me the upshot is that this is a character where Cady's kookier recent performance style suits the role. But I can understand it grating for people.
    • Yeah, Loretta Swit's passing stings. My late dad LOVED the show (he died last November) and watched it religiously. In first run and repeats.  And I was literally born the day after the show's premiere, so I grew up with it! I know many loved later, softer Margaret, but I loved Early Hot Lips. In real life, I'm all for less misogyny, but to me, the early years of M*A*S*H were just funnier. May Loretta Swit rest in peace. Thanks for all the memories connected to my dad!
    • FROM THE VAULT: WEEKLY DAYTIME NIELSEN RATINGS: WEEKS OF 10/29/73-11/2/73 & 11/5/73-11/9/73:  

      Please register in order to view this content

    • I agree that she isn't Dixie or Rosanna and shouldn't be acting like either. I just found it strange that she had a naive Southern character and a wealthy urbane character in the past and didn't experiment with accents before (unless I missed it, correct me if I'm wrong). She used to do improv characters on YouTube. She's probably doing something similar here.

      Please register in order to view this content

       
    • And here I thought I'd never think about Lauren Tewes again after her brief appearance in Twin Peaks Season 3.
    • I may be the single person who does not mind Transatlantic Campy Pamela. I think it perfectly suits this sort of Absolutely Fabulous-esque supporting character she's playing much more than it did when Cady tried weird and often broad stuff at AMC* or Y&R, or later stints at ATWT. She's not Dixie and she's not trying to be. I will freely admit some of the other chances she took at other shows often came off stiff, hammy or downright mortifying (Kelly Andrews, come on down). (* - and I say that as one of the few who was somewhat into Cady trying to make Dixie more cosmopolitan in the Rosanna Cabot mold in mid-2000s AMC, just to liven the character up again)
    • There’s absolutely nothing exciting happening storyline wise but I’m always happy to see the vets on my screen so I’ll take what I can get. It’s also just nice to see them all dressed up in the same room, it always gives classic Y&R vibes. The best part? No Phyllis. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy