Jump to content

Y&R: December 2013 Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 827
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I call it minimal because the scenes are never very long...yet she has minutes upon minutes with Jack and Jill. Hilary rarely interacts with cane and lily. Last week they saw her across the room...this week, lily said two syllables in passing. Yet beforehand, Hilary spent 95% of her airtime at the Abbot mansion. Just like today, she spent most if her airtime in the club with Jack watching Victor and Kyle across the room.

As for her scenes with Jack...All she does is whine about how lonely she is. There is no fire or personality shown in his presence. No spark at all. She only has fire with Jill or when she is getting smart with Devon or Mason. I like the Jack and Hilary relationship because it gives us a chance to see another side of her. It gives her a chance to explain where her head is...but Jack is a sap and he is turning her into a sap as well. JMO.

Of course Devon counts as a winters...he is a winters. However, my point is that she doesn't spend that much Time with him. So this notion that he, and cane and lily, are making her boring just doesn't hold water.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

If they have a story together then doesn't that kinda make the scenes necessary. I mean really, isn't it an oxymoron to say scenes are unnecessary when they move a story forward. I only categorize scenes as unnecessary when they are a rehash of the same thing over and over again...characters discussing the same thing over and over. I.e., Chelsea and Chloe on Adam. They do that every other day. And it doesn't pertain to any story at all. Just random fluff talking. We get get. Chloe hates Adam. But hey, that's just my definition.

I agree that her scenes with Devon, albeit mostly short, are very important. They are building a romance after all *smug smile* But the point was that you said that Hilary spent too much time with the boring winters clan which in turn makes her boring. Untrue. She has little airtime with them...little being synonymous with minimal. If you are finding her boring to watch overall. I don't think those 30 seconds of airtime is the problem. How could it be when she had 10 minutes with Jack any given day she is on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

They should write Victoria out completely. She's coasted on that inane relationship for years. This character has no personality of her own, and Amelia Heinle cannot elevate the material.

If they recast down the line fine, but I think this character needs some time away for them to properly rebuild her.

With David Tom coming back as Billy and Billy/Victoria looking as good as dead, do they have any interest in Victoria as she's currently portrayed and written? I have doubts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members
Thank goodness for that, b/c that was beyond ridiculous how they were shown on Wednesday all in the same scene, yet there was no real story. It literally felt like the show was just filling a quota. I agree there's more work that needs to be done regarding storytelling, but things really are better than when MAB was at the helm. It was literally the Adam and Phyllis show. I'm hoping we'll start seeing a better balance amongst the cast.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I'm beyond glad Villy is being dismantled. I don't care to go another year seeing Billy screwing up, Victoria forgiving him, rinse and repeat. Besides, with DT arriving in little over a month, its best to take Billy in a new direction. Looks like Victoria might get Stitch so its not the end of the world for her.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I agree. I actually believe she'll turnout to be Delia's Hit and Run driver. There's definitely something shady about her. I also question if she really lost a child. That kiss between her and Billy seemed like something she's been eager to do. I don't trust her.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

This is so true. Because very little has been done with Devon over the years, thats why its so easy for so many to write him off as Dull and "Boring". All it takes is to finally give him a real story. Now I just hope they continue with building up his character.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I really liked Hilary when she first came on. She was different and she had some fire. She is being white washed and I am finding her rather boring lately. Anything with that twerp Devon is boring.

I think AH has got to go too. She is such a weak actress, she is like a big wet noodle. No screen presence at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I think she is decent but as someone else pointed out Victoria is NO character anymore as the writing has been terrible for 8 years and only an actress with extraordinary charisma and acting chops could make this travesty work. Victoria is nothing but a Billy annex anymore. They stripped her of everything else.That said, Amelia Heinle did some good work this year in thr afternath of that crappy hit and run story.

Speaking of crappy stories: just watching the Dec 23 show and they are arresting Fenmore one day prior to Xmas? Serously!? And the directing is sooo bad on this show. Even the location shoot in Malibu looked amateurish compared to what B&B is delivering on a daily basis. I also hate that either one of the producers or directors has told the woman on this show recently that the crying look is now the key for great acting: Melody THomas Scott and Tracey Bregman are overacting like never before in their careers... WTF is going on there - I could get why they find the material hammy but this is painful to watch.

The rest is very good and watchable, though. I expected much worse from this writing team. So far so good. E.g. I hated that fluff with Jill's music box originally but now I want this to last forever as it kinda corny but engaging - at least for me. LOL

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I think that kind of thinking gives the writers a free pass. OK let's have Fred murder someone but not face any real consequences because Mary loves him. Maybe she'll be angry for a few weeks and Bill will swear to avenge the death but that will blow  over then we can just go on. The idea that a bit of self loathing and rejection is punishment enough is ridiculous. Especially when these type of characters never reform. It allows the writers to go for shock value over and over.instead of crafting storylines that really delve into a dark/ villianous character. Not many people IRL can get away with multiple crimes and still be apart of a community.
    • I guess Wayne felt it was now or never. He'd made a splash at Days and probably hoped that would lead to a primetime series. If he signed for another 3 years at Days then the momentum would be lost and he's probably have to stay in soaps like so many others. And in the back of his mind there was the knowledge he could probably get a role on SB or GH if he didn't luck out in primetime or Days didn't want him back. As it turned out he returned to Dynasty and got a couple of primetime gigs before agreeing to go back to Days.
    • Please register in order to view this content

      I got to agree. The show was a mess.  The stories that are not working were the ones featured in today's episode. That was a red flag indicating how bad the episode was going to be.
    • Thanks as always @alwaysAMC The remote was panned in the soap press at the time, especially Philip wandering around in the costume as well as some of the comedy.  I have to admit it didn't bother me, even though I knew how ludicrous the idea was of the Spauldings having a wedding at a theme park. I thought there were some fun moments and I did like the scene where Lucy got to cry and grieve over what Brent had done to her.  I think I was just glad to get away from the stories in Springfield, which were bad and getting worse.  There are a number of attempts at revamping the opening music in 1996. I'll be interested in what you think of them. I remember being glad they updated the photos but also noticing how cheap they looked. The show did need a new opening. Sadly, Rauch would instead just not even have an opening for over 5 years.
    • BTG: - Shelley Curtis first listed as Director on May 19   Another FOJulie director. 
    • It’s been awhile since I’ve seen a good soap cat fight so this was highly satisfying. Loved the Drew/Curtis scenes. Drew may not end up murdered but someone is going to try and kill him and it feels like it’s going to be much sooner than later. Who thought Dante ranting and raving for weeks on end would be good writing just to create angst between him and Gio. I really don’t think you needed to make Dante this fuc.king annoying.
    • I get what you're saying, in that this is what allows you to accept what you are watching, and that works for you. But for me, changing the traits of a character that much with a recast and new writing, then they are no longer the same character.  I am unable to accept that a villain is now just a nice dude because the show wants me to, I just cannot.  If they want a grey character, then they should write off the villain and *create* a new character who is grey.  I'll never accept that Sonny Corinthos is a nice guy, despite what GH wants me to think.  Same goes for the villains on DAYS. It's frustrating for me, and not enjoyable.  It occurs to me that I watch soaps to be entertained, and the current show is just making me angry and irritated. It's not fun for me.  I want to honor Drake to see John's story conclude, but there isn't much of interest to me anymore at all, so I'll probably stop following the show in a few weeks.
    • The wikipedia article doesn't explain much. I watched the Party of Five reboot, it was on Freeform in 2020.  It was five years ago, but I'll tell you what I remember: In the original Party of Five series , the parents died, and the five sibling orphans worked together to raise themselves with the older ones looking out for the younger, while managing the family restaurant.  The oldest child wants to have fun but ends up assuming the responsibility. In the 2020 reboot: The family were Mexican, the parents were undocumented, and the oldest child is an adult who could stay in the US for DACA.  In the reboot, instead of the parents dying -- in the first episode the parents were arrested by ICE and sent back to Mexico.   The five children were left in the U.S. to raise themselves with the older ones looking out for the younger, while managing the family restaurant.  The oldest child wants to have fun but ends up assuming the responsibility.  The teens go through teen stuff and the older ones explore careers.  The child daughter feels sad without her parents, and there is also a baby.  But the children were able to have periodic phonecalls with their parents in Mexico, which were very emotional.  The children hire an attorney to try to get their parents returned to the U.S.  The dad phones them to check on the management of the restaurant.  The younger children crave talking to the mom on the phone. The viewers also see how the parents are coping with the strain in Mexico:  the mom works as a nanny and the dad gets odd jobs-- they almost divorce, and the mom wants to stay in Mexico.  I think a few of the children got to take the bus to Mexico to visit their parents. The youngest child was a baby and the next-youngest missed the parents very much.  In the season one finale, it was decided that the youngest two would remain Mexico and live with their parents.  The older children remained in the USA and were following their dreams.  Season One finished airing just as the COVID epidemic began and everything shut down. The show was not renewed for Season Two.   That's all I remember.  It was good but very different from the original. Edit to add: Amazing how the world has changed in five years.  The reboot was filmed in 2019 during the first Tr*mp presidency, and aired in 2020.  The immigration situation was tense then, and that was explored in the series.  But it seems carefree in comparison to the real world today in 2025. Edit to add more thoughts.  I have no idea what would have happened in future seasons, since the five siblings were no longer a "party of five" at the end of Season One.   Supposedly the cancellation wasn't even announced until after the Season One finale aired.  But the season one finale was 90 minutes and wrapped up some lose ends, so maybe the producers anticipated a cancellation, and did that just in case? Perhaps if it there had been future seasons, the younger children would age and then return to the USA and the five would reunite? I don't know.
    • Probably not. Then again, if any character defined the final 25 years of GL it was Reva.
    • Please register in order to view this content

      The roles of Martin and Kat will now be played by Andre and Eva
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy