Like cct, I accepted Robin Mattson and Alicia Minshew right off the bat. I was excited/intrigued by their characters' returns, and they both looked the part (yes, I know RM was in bandages).

I can't really think of any recasts I *never accepted * per se, but I have had problems reconciling the fact that two different actors were playing the same part. Like the case of the two Laurels on AMC, the two Irises on AW... Melody Anderson and Sabine Singh, these two I had to constantly do the mental math reminding myself of who they were "supposed to be".

Edited November 14, 201213 yr by SFK

I never accepted Minshew and I never excepted that high school student almost they hired to play Liza. I guess I should say "Liza" because that Luner person was not Liza Colby. Liza Colby was not 15 years youger than Tad Martin and Jesse, and she didn't look and behave like she was a Melrose Place reject.

Edited November 14, 201213 yr by quartermainefan

More on Days for me-

I instantly accepted JKJ back as philip, Heather Lindell as Jan, Brandon Bemmer as Shawn, Kate Mansi as Abby, Lauren Koslow as Kate - of course.

I accepted Martha Madison as Belle after years, but only sort of. Id love Belle to return recasted.

I never accepted Krista Allen as Billie.

Over at B&B i hated the first bridget recast after JF left, but i loved Ashley as bridget.

I instantly accepted JMW as Stefy.

I never accepted JT as Rick or KL for that matter.

I still dont accept the thomas recast.

I think at one time the show or fans also claimed it was because Sierra left him (during Bryce's 93-94 return) or cheated on him, but that was never fleshed out and not enough justification for Craig to, among other things, emotionally cripple his children and murder several people in cold blood.

If people enjoyed Block's Craig, I got that. We all enjoy different things. It was the, "This is the true him, this is all he was supposed to be," stuff that annoyed me. It was a big slap in the face to Bryce and Doug Marland, among others.

I loved HB's Craig. Though, I had no previous connection to the show let alone the character of Craig.

I prefer Judith Chapman instanstly over Joan Van Ark as Gloria

as well as the current new Billy

It took me a few months to get into Michael Muhney's version of Adam.

I have yet to get used to Ameila as Victoria. Heather Tom is the only Victoria for me.

Never Accepted

1. Shari Shattuck as Ashley Abbott

2. Tammin Sursok as Colleen Carlton

3. Maura West as Diane Jenkins

4. Jennifer landon & Eden Riegel as Heather Stevens

5. Darius McCrary as Malcolm Winters

6. Adam Lazarre-White as Nathan Hastings

On Y&R, I wouldn't say I've accepted Muhney as Adam so much as I've resigned myself to the fact that he's here to stay.

On Y&R, I wouldn't say I've accepted Muhney as Adam so much as I've resigned myself to the fact that he's here to stay.

That's how I feel about Amelia Heinle as FauxVictoria.

Never Accepted:

Josh Taylor (Roman)

Forgot about him. The worst.

Y&R's NuMalcolm as played by Eddie Winslow was just bad too.

Y&R's NuMalcolm as played by Eddie Winslow was just bad too.

But he made Maria cry!!!

Forgot about him. The worst.

Y&R's NuMalcolm as played by Eddie Winslow was just bad too.

I still don't know why they hired Superhead's ex

Like cct, I accepted Robin Mattson and Alicia Minshew right off the bat. I was excited/intrigued by their characters' returns, and they both looked the part (yes, I know RM was in bandages).

I can't really think of any recasts I *never accepted * per se, but I have had problems reconciling the fact that two different actors were playing the same part. Like the case of the two Laurels on AMC, the two Irises on AW... Melody Anderson and Sabine Singh, these two I had to constantly do the mental math reminding myself of who they were "supposed to be".

YES! Cannot believe I forgot about Melody Anderson as Natalie. I also had to do the mental math. It pains me when I think of her reaching for the Christmas star atop the tree when she could finally see.

It pains me when I think of her reaching for the Christmas star atop the tree when she could finally see.

Oh God, don't get me to crying... I was at school that day and my mom described that scene to me and she was tearing up!

I miss All My Children. Particularly, *that* AMC, those kinds of moments.

I primarily watched AMC growing up, I didn't begin to really follow other soaps until the '90s, so I knew a lot of recasts of famous performers first. I knew Beverlee McKinsey's reputation before I knew her work. I loved this Marj Dusay person and I thought it was such a cool coincidence when I discovered that she replaced Beverlee McKinsey AND Carolyn Jones. So after a little tape trade, I learned that I loved BM's Alex and I got all the hype, both ladies were great in their own ways. (Same goes for Marj and Carolyn). Joan Collins is Joan Collins, you are tuning in to get that *Joan thang* unless she's doing something like Decadence, which is why she was dubbed Alexisandra on message boards. I loved her as I loved Joan in anything else, but I didn't enjoy her Alex more than Marj or Beverlee.

The sad part is for some time I actually thought it was Kate in that scene.

Her eyes were bandaged still, right? Half her face was covered, so you get a pass. I missed much of Melody's run, must have been during the school year. I remember her very first day, and I remember the day she got in the accident... wasn't she harassed in her blindness in a Loving crossover story?

Well, I had not seen a lot of KC at that point, so I thought that was her. It's one of my main memories of Melody, along with that letter someone wrote to SPW very politely blasting them for their article which had belittled KC's Natalie as an ice queen and said Melody was much better because she was so sweet.

Edited November 15, 201213 yr by CarlD2

SPW thought Melody Anderson was better than Kate Collins as Natalie?