Jump to content

Lecy or Sarah?


juppiter

Which Becky was better  

18 members have voted

  1. 1. Which Becky from Roseanne is better?

    • Lecy Goranson
      12
    • Sarah Chalke
      6


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 25
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I don't think Sarah's Becky resembled any of the characters.

I always thought Becky was supposed to be a younger version of Jackie - the one that had all the potential in the world, but made stupid decisions that cost her a lot of what she could have had.

Darlene was definitely more of a younger Roseanne, but Darlene did accomplish a lot of what Roseanne wished she could have done (going to college and being a writer for example).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Lecy.

Was not bothered by Chalke during the run, but in hindsight, realized how much better was with Goranson in the role.

Chalke was best on Scrubs. I enjoyed Chalke on HIMYM too.

Towards the end of her initial run, Lecy-as-Becky got on my nerves. She was bratty and annoying. However she was a great foil for Gilbert's Darlene, who may not have realized her potential beyond child-actor-who-can-pull-off-some-great-lines to good actress without Lecy-as-Becky. (check out first-season Darlene) Darlene softened the edges for the audience.

I, too, think Roseanne is one of the best portrayals of working-class life I've seen, and certainly one of the best sitcoms ever. If not for the final two seasons, I think it would be at the top.

(But I appreciated the finale more than many, as well)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The seasons I like best, particularly #5, is actually without Becky, but if I had to choose I'd pick Lecy. I liked Sarah Chalke but the tenor of the character changed dramatically when she took over the role. Becky had always been smart and prim, but with Chalke in the role Becky was just a dumb blonde living in a trailer park.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

To me Roseanne was a show where even after it jumped the shark it never became TOTALLY unwatchable -- though there are some difficult episodes like the terrorists on a train episode or the Gilligan's Island episode. But yeah, Roseanne is such a better character in the earlier seasons. As she said in the finale, she walked a tight line between tradition and progress. In the early seasons Roseanne is snarky and a strong woman, but she definitely has a sweet side when necessary. In the later seasons she's more negative and just plain mean.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

There were a lot of weaker episodes in the last few seasons, but one in particular that I do like cements my love for Lecy's version of Becky even more--Season 8's "Becky Howser, M.D.", when it looks like Becky might leave the trailer park life with Mark and try to go to the University of Illinois to study medicine. I understand why she might have decided not to, but I think it would've been great to see her go back to school, particularly since they were never going to let Sarah's Becky try to do that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • BLQ is having second thoughts regarding putting her baby up for adoption. Chase is upset he can't tell Dante. So both are putting this on at lulus feet. Saying she is holding it over them. Lulu is doing none of this. 
    • Yes she absolutely was involved in that story which seems to have gone nowhere.  She didn't start to remove herself from the writing until 1973.
    • Y'all are bringing back great memories of AMC 2.0 for me.  I haven't thought about it and the new characters in so long, well since it aired, and I plan to go re-watch it now. When AMC ended, I finally came to peace with it and accepted that I will never watch an hour of a TV show daily in my life again... something that I had been doing since I was 6-7 years old. I was starting a new career, relationship, and chapter in life when AMC 2.0 came out.  I found a way to watch it, but things felt differently for me at the time and when it was so short-lived and gone, it became such a distant memory, sadly.
    • That's a great point. I wish the writing could find those nuances.
    • After all Lulu's been through with her coma and missing years I can get her being on the sensitive side especially when talking to her mother.  I was thinking it was more a culmination of everything than just this one particular problem. 
    • I see her moral dilemma, too, and I don't think Lulu was out of line. I just felt it was overboard for her to break down in tears over her dilemma.
    • I also think the fact Lulu chose abortion and Brook Lynn chose to give a baby up for adoption instead when they were in similar situations adds another layer to this.  The writing doesn't really state this, but I can see Lulu slightly spiraling about thinking she could have an adult child out there if she made a different choice.  Both woman made the right choices for themselves at the time, but I can see both making parallels to their decisions.
    • SO good!  I agree. Classic soap opera and it was a cliffhanger I've been craving for weeks now.  First time in a while that I can't wait for tomorrow's episode!
    • -- I was OK with the music. I think the first 5 minutes of the first episode spoiled us -- we really thought we were going to get "real music" a lot more often. Instead, we got some budget money for the opening scene, and that was it. -- I'd like music to be used more often, but I'll put that on production and not on the musicc supervisor. I think they've intentionally dialed down the music on this show. -- Editing? I still have major problems with it. This episode was SO good, but almost every fade to commercial was off or bad. I just don't get it. That, too, is intentional, but I have no idea what they're going for. It isn't working.
    • I’m up to Jan. 8, 1996 and into a new year! This NYE masquerade ball has been outstanding soap opera! The jig is up with Marian. Brent stages a dummy in a wig at his apartment, making Cleary think Marian is alone at home all night, but Brent is really dressed up at the ball and stalking Lucy and AM. Meanwhile, Frank is at the docks and finds a wrapped floating body (Nadine) and calls it in.  At the same time, unlucky for Brent, Susan just woke up from her coma and remembers Marian attacking her and tells Nick everything! Nick immediately calls Frank to tell him the news. Back at the party, Brent calls AM, pretending to be Marian, and lures him to her apartment just as Frank and Clearly storm in and they all find the dummy in a wig. Brent, now dressed as Zoro like AM was at the party, grabs Lucy, kisses her, she realizes it isn’t AM, and Brent attacks and drugs her unconscious!  I can’t wait to see how this turns out… except for… In this moment, in the middle of the ball, a new actor takes over for Brent. So the episode starts with Brent attacking Lucy, but you have the voiceover man say “Today, the role of Brent Lawrence will be played by…” - taking you out of the scene, wondering what in the world happened. I know what happened, but I’m sure if I were watching live in the 90s without internet, I would be gasping. I had no idea the switchover happened mid-ball where you have the entire cast dressed up, working long hours. I have to imagine the stress of it all made Frank Beaty have his mental break, but I wonder how the rest of the cast/crew dealt with it given it happened right in the middle of this ball that everyone was at for multiple episodes. Did they have to delay the filming schedule to find a new actor? The actor must have had zero time to prep for the role, although I’m assuming we won’t see Marian anymore now that she’s been known to be a fake. I want to know all the juicy BTS details haha. But now, Rick caught wind that the police are trying to find Marian at the party and he starts to put the pieces together, given that he’s the only one that knows Marian is really a man. He walks outside and tells AM, Buzz, Frank and the police that Marian is a man and chaos ensues. Also, Nick finally proposes to Susan in the hospital in a very sweet scene. I didn’t enjoy Susan or this pairing in the beginning, but they’ve really grown on me and I really like how tough Susan is. She was the only one who really caught onto Marian and stood up to her. Meanwhile, Amanda locks Blake in a bathroom and ends up pulling Roger into a kiss after midnight, which Blake sees after she finally escapes. The girls fight, slap each other, throw food and pies… what a fun time haha. Reva the diva is in full force and her sweet milkmaid Goshen personality went out the door for good. She makes Alan go to the ball with her, dressed in a sexy red dress, and makes quite a scene. She kisses Josh, they fight in front of the whole party, she breaks down, they scream at each other, poor Annie runs off crying and Reva leaves the party and tries to seduce Alan to make herself feel better. Reva’s performance in front of everyone was pure Reva and honestly the Reva I prefer.  I was so tired of Amish Reva for 7 months, so this is a breath of fresh air. I don’t think it all came together perfectly, and I don’t think Reva nor Josh have made good decisions, but at least the story is now moving forward and I have the old Reva back, for better or worse haha. I’m a little disappointed in Bridget. She’s very quick to crush on Hart again and she’s almost pining after him at this ball. Vanessa of course isn’t that happy with what she’s seeing. Matt tries to reassure her. Speaking of, Matt is looking really good at this ball - the mustache and hat really works for him (sorry, PJ haha).  Another point about Bridget that bothers me, which is the writers’ fault, but she’s been totally dropped from the Lucy/Brent storyline. They were basically best friends and she was involved in the beginning, but they completely replaced her friend role with Susan/Nick, which I get because she has HIV/AIDs and Bridget may not have worked as well when the story continued along that path.  But still, I wish we could see Bridget checking in on her or be worried for her (same with David). Finally, a little story is brewing with Griffin and Gilly’s mom, Vivian. She just confronted him and asks if he’s planning to do to her daughter what he did to her long ago.  Interesting…
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy