Uh, I hate the Brenda breakdown story!  I think the quieter moments were okay and there is a decent scene at Lily's grave that I think she submitted for the emmy, but the OTT actual breakdown ruined it all for me.   I don't think her getting over the breakdown was handled well either.  How did she get better?  Jax's support?  Having a one sided conversation with Lily's gravestone?  HATED IT.

VM was better in the Stone AIDS/Sonny wire break up stuff and her 2002 return stuff.  There wasn't a chance in hell she would win that emmy in 1998 on the strength of material.  I think every actor she was against had better work that year.   There was a possibility she could have won on popularity alone, but I never thought she was a favorite.

@BetterForgotten Julia Barr was the winner.  The nominees were Julia, Amy Carlson, Amy Ecklund, Vanessa, and Victoria Rowell that year. 

At least she got her Popularity Emmy in 2002 so I am sure Vanessa is fine with that. 

1 hour ago, carolineg said:

At least she got her Popularity Emmy in 2002 so I am sure Vanessa is fine with that. 

She did have some good material, but Robin Christopher should have won. 

10 minutes ago, amybrickwallace said:

She did have some good material, but Robin Christopher should have won. 

Yeah, I am pretty sure that's the general consensus.  Robin was very good that year with the Jax divorce and falling off the wagon.  I never was a big RC/Skye fan, but that's why I said VM won for being VM.  I am not sure her material in 2002-2003 stood up to the other nominees, but more of an overall thanks for her popularity.  This was probably Vanessa's best work.  It's a shame RC never got another chance for an Emmy because she really was a good actress.

3 minutes ago, carolineg said:

It's a shame RC never got another chance for an Emmy because she really was a good actress.

Yes, she was. She was often understated, which I think was often lost on Emmy voters. RC wasn't flashy like VM.

1 minute ago, amybrickwallace said:

Yes, she was. She was often understated, which I think was often lost on Emmy voters. RC wasn't flashy like VM.

To me, RC is very cold as an actress.  Very old Hollywood.  I never really connected with her as Skye.  And while I liked Jax/Skye and thought they had good chemistry, the whole romance felt super rushed so they could be married before Brenda came back.   On the other hand, the Brenda/Jax/Skye stuff really gave RC some of her best material on GH and some of her best scenes are with VM.  The scene where Brenda hands a drunk Skye a drink is one my favorites.  It was a brutal and bitchy take by Vanessa, but Robin was excellent. 

8 minutes ago, carolineg said:

To me, RC is very cold as an actress.  Very old Hollywood.  I never really connected with her as Skye.  And while I liked Jax/Skye and thought they had good chemistry, the whole romance felt super rushed so they could be married before Brenda came back.   On the other hand, the Brenda/Jax/Skye stuff really gave RC some of her best material on GH and some of her best scenes are with VM.  The scene where Brenda hands a drunk Skye a drink is one my favorites.  It was a brutal and bitchy take by Vanessa, but Robin was excellent. 

RC never originated a soap role, to my knowledge. She was the second (but not last) Skye on AMC and had the unenviable task of filling Alicia Coppola as Lorna on AW. It would have been nice to see her take on a brand-new character.

48 minutes ago, carolineg said:

To me, RC is very cold as an actress.  Very old Hollywood.  I never really connected with her as Skye.  And while I liked Jax/Skye and thought they had good chemistry, the whole romance felt super rushed so they could be married before Brenda came back.

I always felt it was rushed too. But everything to establish Skye on GH was heavily rushed, by JFP and Megan, and Robin is so arch and old Hollywood, as you said, that it always annoyed me, especially as an OLTL fan who'd seen them supercharge what they did to that show at GH. I've always liked RC regardless, but I never accepted Skye as a Quartermaine calling Edward "Grandfather" within weeks of her arrival, supposedly having instant connections and rivalries with people like Sonny and Ned within days or weeks, and I never will. I was very glad when she was de-Qed by Guza who clearly held all of that in contempt. Ingo and Robin did have chemistry, but I watched their romance in real time and I never bought its evolution.

The Skye character only worked on the show, IMO, during her short-term stints in later years after RC went off-contract. She would come in, mix it up and leave. That I'm fine with and it suits her; there's a proud tradition of that with characters like Tracy, Marco Dane, etc. She should still be doing that tbh. But on contract as an 'honorary Quartermaine' or with Luke - please God, no.

2 minutes ago, Vee said:

She would come in, mix it up and leave. That I'm fine with and it suits her; there's a proud tradition of that with characters like Tracy, Marco Dane, etc. She should still be doing that tbh. But on contract as an 'honorary Quartermaine' or with Luke - please God, no.

She'd be a much of a beloved character as them if that had happened.

I never liked the shoe-horning in of Skye, as much as I love Robin Christopher and Skye. I didn't mind her on the show but yeah it was all so rushed and forced.

 

I did like the idea of Alan having a daughter but it was all wasted on Skye, and then un-done.

Edited October 9, 20214 yr by KMan101

10 minutes ago, Vee said:

I always felt it was rushed too. But everything to establish Skye on GH was heavily rushed, by JFP and Megan, and Robin is so arch and old Hollywood, as you said, that it always annoyed me, especially as an OLTL fan who'd seen them supercharge what they did to that show at GH. I've always liked RC regardless, but I never accepted Skye as a Quartermaine calling Edward "Grandfather" within weeks of her arrival, supposedly having instant connections and rivalries with people like Sonny and Ned within days or weeks, and I never will. I was very glad when she was de-Qed by Guza who clearly held all of that in contempt. Ingo and Robin did have chemistry, but I watched their romance in real time and I never bought its evolution.

The Skye character only worked on the show, IMO, during her short-term stints in later years after RC went off-contract. She would come in, mix it up and leave. That I'm fine with and it suits her; there's a proud tradition of that with characters like Tracy, Marco Dane, etc. She should still be doing that tbh. But on contract as an 'honorary Quartermaine' or with Luke - please God, no.

I didn't love her as an insta-Q and it did feel like she was immediately part of the family knowing none of the history.   I did like her relationship with AJ.  I was actually annoyed they de-Qed her, not because I had investment in that, but because they did it to pair her with NED.   Skye was just an odd fit for OLTL and GH and Guza never knew what to do with her.  Skye was everywhere and in the strangest pairings.

Anyhow, the potential of Jax/Skye was there but it moved so fast and everyone knew it stood no chance against a Brenda return.  I may have broke Jax/Skye up before Brenda and given Jax/Brenda other obstacles (non-third party) and saved Skye for post-Brenda Jax. 

I'd be fine with Skye popping in now and then and bringing Lila Rae on canvas now as well.

1 hour ago, carolineg said:

To me, RC is very cold as an actress.  Very old Hollywood.  I never really connected with her as Skye.  And while I liked Jax/Skye and thought they had good chemistry, the whole romance felt super rushed so they could be married before Brenda came back.   On the other hand, the Brenda/Jax/Skye stuff really gave RC some of her best material on GH and some of her best scenes are with VM.  The scene where Brenda hands a drunk Skye a drink is one my favorites.  It was a brutal and bitchy take by Vanessa, but Robin was excellent. 

I love this scene.

14 minutes ago, Faulkner said:

I love this scene.

Haha!  I always crack when Skye calls her a manipulative, lying, man stealing, illness faking whore.  It's a good scene.  I always forget that Jax/Skye lived at Alexis's house before it was Alexis's.  RC plays a good drunk.

29 minutes ago, carolineg said:

I always crack when Skye calls her a manipulative, lying, man stealing, illness faking whore.  

Same here. 😂😂😂😂😂

55 minutes ago, Faulkner said:

I love this scene.

The show was so good for those few months!

36 minutes ago, titan1978 said:

The show was so good for those few months!

It was so good!  Must see tv at the time.  It's not a surprise the ratings reflected that. Almost every story was decent too except for the Lucky/Luke/Summer stuff.  It did begin to drag during the Luis trial, but I do think Guza was going to ramp things back up with Brenda/Sonny/Jason after that if VM didn't leave.