American Idol

[kelli_blue]

Oye! This really has been a hit or miss season, hasn't it?

Elliot didn't do so hot on either song last night.

Paris either....I just wasn't *feeling* her last night.

Chris, I thought, did a great job on both songs.

Kat was a bit pitchy with the first, but blew me away with the second.

And Taylor, well, I just don't know about him. He is a good singer, but sometimes his antics onstage take away from that. His second song was better than the first.

I am thinking Paris and Elliot are the bottom 2 tonight.

[RogerNewcomb]

Katharine's first song was the worst of the night. She did well in her second, but that first song rivaled Pickler in the bad department. I wouldn't be shocked if she's out tonight. It will probably be Kat or Paris.

[Angela]

I hope Kat stays. She stunk up the first song, but she was spectacular with the second - top 3 performances of the night. It's a relatively good top 5, there's been many seasons where I didn't even think the top 3 was as good as this top 5.

[alwaysAMC]

Ok they each had a good song and an ok song.

I liked Paris last night though - she's just fun and spunky.

Katherine is awesome - I loved the 2nd song she sang - that song they always play on VH1 right now...haha

Chris ROCKED that first song.

Elliot is ok - but I just don't think he has stage presence and needs to go home.

[KMan101]

After seeing DialIdol's numbers, we could get a Paris/Katharine bottom two. I think Paris will go but I'm worried about Katharine too...

Sigh.

Paris was really good last night. Damn why doesn't she have a fanbase? LOL.

[kentville]

I loved Taylor, Elliot was good, Paris was good. I'd vote Chris and Katherine in the bottom 2. Chris is really starting to get on my nerves, and he basically sings one style of song. Katherine has a nice voice, but it sounds like she sings off key a lot of the time.

[tina m]

I'm hoping Paris goes for Katharine's stake.

[MzHuggable]

For this week, Eliott or Paris should go home, but i wouldn't be hurt or disappointed if Katherine left. She's a good singer and all, but she just has this snobbish air of arrogance about her that turns me off... and like someone said, it wouldn't surprise me if they rigged it for Kat to leave to ensure a male wins. Season 3 was soooo rigged (LaToya should've won), so why not this one

[Sweet_VeeVee24]

First off, I love your banner.....

Okay, now about Miss Katharine.....I'm not at all a fan of hers....I just don't like how snooty she is; and she's beyond snobbish when either the judges or Ryan give her a compliment....She's not humble or even thankful to me.

I too think that it will be either Paris that goes home; simply because she's been in the bottom for so long now, so it's pretty much a possibility.

[KMan101]

It was really sad to see Paris go but I LOVE this final four! Anyone of them can win it (maybe ... lol).

I still say we'll have a Taylor/Chris finale.

[alwaysAMC]

Sad to see Paris go!

Elliot needs to be next.

[King]

Sad about Paris! I'll miss her. She and family didn't seem surprised and seemed at peace with it. That's good. I am sure she has *SOME* future out there in music.

Kat still makes me want to vomit in my mouth.

I'm rooting for Elliot and Chris...in that order.

[PhoenixRising05]

Sad about Paris-it always seem like people get kicked off in the wrong week. Elliot should have gone but he will go next week.

I like Taylor but unless he wows me in the next two weeks vocally he should not be in the finale. His dancing and erratic performing can only go so far. This is a singing competition and the finale should be Kat/Chris whether people like it or not and, given who we have left, if we get any other combo it would be wrong.

I did like the group song tonight and to Paris and the microphone.

[R!ck]

I agree

[kentville]

Sorry to see Paris go, I still think Katherine should have gone first. I'm still rooting for a Taylor/Elliot final. Katherine just doesn't have the personality to be the AI. She has a snobbish air around her that I just don't like. Chris is good but he sings the same type song over and over again.