Jump to content

Y&R: Potpourri Thread 3


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 557
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Y&R was never particulary my cup of tea, mostly because I enjoyed the humor and the lighter, more contemporary, and uplifting feeling of the Nixon shows. But in hindsight, I've come to appreciate the show a lot. I thought the time that LML was writing with Alden and Smith was pure soap nirvana. I liked some of the LML solo stuff too, as I've admitted in the past. Her solo stories were ok, but there was a sharp focus and energy to the show that's really missing.

Oh yeah, I've always thought B&B was a horrible show. The writing and the acting (with the exception of a few like Flannery) have never measured up to Y&R for the most part. Pretty much every time I try to watch it, I feel like I'm watching a bad Y&R parody, or even worse a Saturday Night Live parody of soaps. The thing is that it used to be a joke in the industry. I remember years ago Marcy Walker had been approached about joining the show either before she went to GL or before she returned to AMC, forgot which one. She made some comment to the press implying that B&B was a subpar show and that she wouldn't be caught dead on it, and that was probably the consensus years ago. I gather it's come into its own in recent years and is now more or less well-regarded, which probably goes to show you how far the other soaps have fallen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I'm dragging the casting discussion over here so we don't give Toups a nervous breakdown. I think casting has sucked as of late, but there's been a few winners. Casting is a HARD HARD thing. Bill Bell even screwed that up on many occasions. I could bring up Erica Hope, Bond Gideon, SHARI SHATTUCK, Sarah Aldrich, Cam Gigandet (that might have been Alden). And who WAS it that said they thought Marnie was doing well as DOOL because she didn't cast someone like Frank Mentier? I LOVE him! Of course, I could just be blinded by his beauty. But look what COMPANY he keeps!

NENflOOSbFHGRT_1_5.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The problem goes beyond casting and into poor writing and direction. The soap press does not stop hyping Billy Miller and Liz Hendrickson, but even they have been dragged down severely by the schizophrenic focus on their characters.

It's a combination of casting awful people who have no business being onscreen, casting green people who are not given the opportunities to get better, and casting decent actors who then fall apart because the show offers nothing to help sustain them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Im not sure. When did Bill move to LA? Wasn't it 80/81? I know that all of the original cast of 12 was cast by Bill. Dickson, Cooper, Julianna McCarthy have all said they were cast by the man himself. I know that Heather Tom also said she was cast by Bill as well as Rowell. From what I read in old soap mags, I get the feeling that Bill Bell cast all the contract players in the early days, and the secondary characters were left to Conboy, with Bill's approval. but whoever cast Wing Hauser as Greg Foster should have had their head examined. He's got to have been the ugliest actor on television. I'd almost sooner look at Ernest Borgnine and William Conrad in a love scene!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

That would be me the character Jed Stark was absolutely horrid and in my opinion was made worse than Mentier's acting or whatever he was trying to do.

Many of the 90s failures like the multiple Sharons and Shari Shattuck could be attributed to Jill W. Newton. Of course another problem is that Y&R will often hire somebody's family member. While the most famous example of this is obviously Lauralee, Camryn Grimes, Laura Bryan Birn, Marrissa Arena, Shattuck, Asia Ray Smith, Linden Ashby and David Tom all were related to someone who worked on a Bell show whether it be spouse, child, sibling etc. Goes to show the problems of nepotism.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Oh man! Yes, he was -- shall we say -- rough hewn. But he actually worked as the quick-fuse Greg who had to deal with Nikki's shenanigans. She ran in fear of his reactions to her prostitution caper...and it was believable with him in the role.

You all hate on Shattuck, but I actually thought she was a breath of fresh air. Compared to the bland portrayal of Epperson, I liked that her Ashley had some bite again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Has Ashley ever had bite as a character? Everything I've ever seen of Davidson has been withdrawn, aside from the occasional snapping at people.

Shattuck was very in your face, and I adjusted to her over time, but she struggled to have chemistry with her love interests, and she seemed very emotionally cut off from most of the people around her. I also remember her being overly invested in Jack's love life, whereas most of the time, Ashley doesn't give a fudge about her relatives.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy