Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

May 19-23, 2008

Featured Replies

  • Replies 180
  • Views 33.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member
God, this question alone makes me glad I'm giving up soaps. I watch AMC and I loved it last week but I know enough not to get attached. Eventually Frons will get his way and JnA will vanish (but hopefully DW and DM will get nice big paychecks in the process). I'm actually thinking of AMC like an "open ended" miniseries. It's just a matter of time before I have to walk away. And I'm actually okay with that. JnA were one of my first soap "loves." It's fitting that they be my last.

That is the way I view it too. There is never a long-term payoff watching an ABC soap. It's not like Pratt wrote for characters like J/A when he was at GH. I'm kind of surprised they the woman who plays Angie back. I think she had a pretty good career outside of daytime. It seems the gentleman who plays Jessie has had some success too.

  • Member
Congrats to OLTL. Good stuff is happening on that soap so it is good to see it reflected in the ratings. Last week with the wonderful wedding was stellar.

Don't what to say about Y&R. Wow. Told you'll that it could always get worse than it was under LML. LML just needed an experience c-headwriter to reign her in and Y&R would be flying.

B&B has been enjoyable of late. It is a good sign that B&B is holding its own as Y&R spirals downwards unlike ATWT which is a nightmare.

That's the same exact thing I said when LML was writing. They should have brought on another writer to work with her instead of getting rid of her altogether. Hopefully Hogan will balance Maria Bell out.

  • Member
That's the same exact thing I said when LML was writing. They should have brought on another writer to work with her instead of getting rid of her altogether. Hopefully Hogan will balance Maria Bell out.

I don't see how they could've brought anyone in to balance LML when they gave her all the power. She was also EP, I doubt it they demoted her, she'd stay to be paired up with someone else.

The last thing Y&R needs is another outsider (which we're getting yet again). The show needs some of the old writers and producers who made it what it used to be.

  • Member

Y&R doesn't need Lynn Latham, they need a good writer, period. Someone experienced who knows what Y&R fans want and can give it to them. LML or MAB with no experience or HS who hates vets aren't the answer. They need to go back to the old fold, accept that they ruined Y&R trying to rush [!@#$%^&*] and let Bill Bell's writers execute his vision. Just look at the fact that MAB hasn't even brought any characters back! They mention Dru every week, but VR hasn't even been contacted! The 35th anniversary was a [!@#$%^&*] piece of crap. No flashbacks, no returns, nothing. Now it's like every other soap, having one good episode or one good week, then falling back to garbage.

As for The Price is Right, I recall reading an article a while ago that it was up from Bob Barker. Look at how regularly they're giving Drew (successful) primetime specials. I can't see it tanking too much if they continue to do t hat.

  • Member
I'm convinced most people have lost their loyaty with Y&R, especially after the boredom that was the past two months and the past two years of nonsense that went on with the show. Y&R actually improved last week and was quite good this week. However, even if the quality went up, I seriously doubt the ratings will.

Though, I still wouldn't mind, you know, Griffith and Maria Bell BEING FIRED....

Who does one have to sleep with to give Natalie Minardi Slater a promotion and to bring David Shaughnessy back as EP?

I don't understand this drumbeat by some for Natalie Slater to be bumped up. Just because she survived the LML purges doesn't mean she has the talent to be a headwriter. She was Kay Alden's secretary in Chicago for many years, and Kay promoted her after Bill Bell stepped down. She's loyal to Kay to a fault. She's outlined and edited, but again, that in no way makes her headwriter material. The problem at Y&R and so many of the other soaps today is that there are no real storytellers left in daytime. Bill Bell was a storyteller. Agnes Nixon was (and still is) a storyteller. Douglas Marland and Harding Lemay were storytellers. Claire Labine was (and still is) a storyteller. There's a big difference between a storyteller and a headwritrer. People can be trained to be headwriters. It's a skill that can be learned. A true storyteller is born not trained. There's raw talent. I just don't see that in the current crop of headwriters. As for DS becoming EP, I'm all for it. I'm for anyone who has a history with the show coming back to plug this sinking ship. But I agree with an earlier poster. I think Y&R was the one soap viewers didn't feel betrayed by. Then came LML, and the damage was done. History was thrown out, long time writers and producers were tossed aside, and TPTB let it happen. Now they're making yet another flawed decision by bring ing HS. His track record is spotty. He had early success on ATWT, but then turned it into a mess. DAYS was a quick and dismal failure. Note to the network brass: go back to the formula that made Y&R so successful. Bring back the people who know the show and the audience. Get on your knees if you have to and bring back the old writers and EPs and directors. Watch your audience drift back to you. Otherwise, you're going to see more audfience erosion. That is a certainty.

  • Member
I don't understand this drumbeat by some for Natalie Slater to be bumped up. Just because she survived the LML purges doesn't mean she has the talent to be a headwriter. She was Kay Alden's secretary in Chicago for many years, and Kay promoted her after Bill Bell stepped down. She's loyal to Kay to a fault. She's outlined and edited, but again, that in no way makes her headwriter material. The problem at Y&R and so many of the other soaps today is that there are no real storytellers left in daytime. Bill Bell was a storyteller. Agnes Nixon was (and still is) a storyteller. Douglas Marland and Harding Lemay were storytellers. Claire Labine was (and still is) a storyteller. There's a big difference between a storyteller and a headwritrer. People can be trained to be headwriters. It's a skill that can be learned. A true storyteller is born not trained. There's raw talent. I just don't see that in the current crop of headwriters. As for DS becoming EP, I'm all for it. I'm for anyone who has a history with the show coming back to plug this sinking ship. But I agree with an earlier poster. I think Y&R was the one soap viewers didn't feel betrayed by. Then came LML, and the damage was done. History was thrown out, long time writers and producers were tossed aside, and TPTB let it happen. Now they're making yet another flawed decision by bring ing HS. His track record is spotty. He had early success on ATWT, but then turned it into a mess. DAYS was a quick and dismal failure. Note to the network brass: go back to the formula that made Y&R so successful. Bring back the people who know the show and the audience. Get on your knees if you have to and bring back the old writers and EPs and directors. Watch your audience drift back to you. Otherwise, you're going to see more audfience erosion. That is a certainty.

Oh, I looooove this post!!! :D I wrote about this whole Natalie S. suggestion in the puppet thread.

Addendum: next time, Y&RWorldTurner, DaytimeFan etc., listen carefully to what I have to say! B) So that we don't end up with an ex-secretary head-writing a soap. (I have nothing against secretaries per se.)

Edited by Sylph

  • Member

QUOTE (Chris B @ May 31 2008, 02:20 AM)
Y&R doesn't need Lynn Latham, they need a good writer, period. Someone experienced who knows what Y&R fans want and can give it to them. LML or MAB with no experience or HS who hates vets aren't the answer. They need to go back to the old fold, accept that they ruined Y&R trying to rush [!@#$%^&*] and let Bill Bell's writers execute his vision. Just look at the fact that MAB hasn't even brought any characters back! They mention Dru every week, but VR hasn't even been contacted! The 35th anniversary was a [!@#$%^&*] piece of crap. No flashbacks, no returns, nothing. Now it's like every other soap, having one good episode or one good week, then falling back to garbage.

As for The Price is Right, I recall reading an article a while ago that it was up from Bob Barker. Look at how regularly they're giving Drew (successful) primetime specials. I can't see it tanking too much if they continue to do t hat.

I don't think they need her back..but they shouldn't have let her go in the first place (at least if it was for writing reasons). She kept the ratings consistent and although people on the internet seemed to despise her, the ratings said otherwise.

They made the mistake of promoting her to EP and when she went on strike for both jobs that may have been what ultimately cost her her job.

And as much as people want to claim that MAB is better than LML the ratings tell another story. If there was a small drop that would be one thing. But ratings are down like .6 since Griffith and Bell took over and it seems every other week they are setting a new low and this isn't due to gradual audience erosion either. It's due to the fact that for the past month or so watching Y&R has been like watching paint dry. LML would at least have one or 2 stories with somewhat interesting plots. Griffith and Bell are just now starting to really get into the meat of some storylines this week.

I know a lot of people hated LML because they felt she disrespected characters history. But over at B&B, Bell Jr has always disrespected characters history and still is to this day and that show is much better than what's going on at Y&R. To be honest the only person that I felt had drastic and all of a sudden sharp change under LML was Nikki. People say that Phyllis and Jill changed, and became weaker women. But to be honest, what reason did Phyllis have to still be a scheming manipulative bitch like she was earlier. She's married and has what she wants and her life is totally different than it was when she was chasing Danny. Also with Jill I think the problem with her was moreso over lack of storyline than anything. Victor also changed but that was due to a disease which whether you liked the story or not at least it was explained.

Just wanted to add something about Phyllis, she still can be a manipulative person when she's trying to get something she wants, like when she blackmailed Brad last year.

Edited by PJA

  • Member

Can someone explain this?

Y&R

Monday: 3.3/4,503,000

Tuesday: 3.4/4,576,000

Wednesday: 3.4/4,726,000

Thursday: 3.6/4,733,000

Friday: 3.4/4,694,000

How does less than 7,000 viewers net you .2 more ratings points?

  • Member
Can someone explain this?

Y&R

Monday: 3.3/4,503,000

Tuesday: 3.4/4,576,000

Wednesday: 3.4/4,726,000

Thursday: 3.6/4,733,000

Friday: 3.4/4,694,000

How does less than 7,000 viewers net you .2 more ratings points?

Households and viewers are two different things. Pretend there are only 10 households. If one person in 8 of the 10 households is watching the show that week, then the household rating is 8/10, and the number of viewers is 8. Now suppose only people in 5 households are watching, but there are 2 viewers in the first house, 3 in the second, 2 in the third, and 1 in each of the other two. The household rating would dip to 5/10, but the viewers increase to 9. More viewers, but less households.

  • Member
Households and viewers are two different things. Pretend there are only 10 households. If one person in 8 of the 10 households is watching the show that week, then the household rating is 8/10, and the number of viewers is 8. Now suppose only people in 5 households are watching, but there are 2 viewers in the first house, 3 in the second, 2 in the third, and 1 in each of the other two. The household rating would dip to 5/10, but the viewers increase to 9. More viewers, but less households.

That is really a great explanation. Carolyn, one of the things I wondered is the household number. Is that based on a scale of 10?

  • Member
That is really a great explanation. Carolyn, one of the things I wondered is the household number. Is that based on a scale of 10?

The household rating is actually a percent. So a 2.2 rating means 2.2% of all US TV households watched a particular show. Since we know the total number of TV households in the US, 112.8 million, then 2.2% of that is about 2,480,000 households. (Not viewers, just households).

The number of US TV households increases every year, so the value of that ratings point goes up every year. Back in the late 70's, there were only 73 million TV households, so a 2.2 rating then would've been 2.2% of 73 million, or only 1,600,000 households.

  • Member
It's my understanding PIR's ratings are no where near what they were under Mr.Barker but not sure is that's a factor in Y&R's downfall. Could just be the simple fact that show is like watching paint dry?

Is there any chance of Y&R losing their #1 HH spot?

Y&R would lose their spot tomorrow if there were another standout soap that could take them. As it is right now, I don't see them losing it, just going south with the rest of daytime.

As for right now, B&B is Y&R's steepest compeition, but B&B still has the feel of a Y&R extension in many ways. It's still a half hour, and primarily comes on immediately after Y&R in MOST markets. That inhibits it from passing Y&R, although B&B is not falling as quickly as Y&R.

Honestly, IMO, it would take another strong soap on another network to dethrone Y&R. IF, IF, IF, AMC, GH, or Days gets it's act together, another soap could topple Y&R. There are just a few soaps that have the timeslot, fan base, and reputation to take a top spot. AMC, GH, and Days are the three that could pose a threat. GH has almost taken it in the past, AMC was in second place for a long time, and Days almost took the top slot in the mid to late 90's under JER's crazy tenure. If only one of those soaps had momentum, Y&R would have already been knocked off three months ago.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.