She looks HWAT!!!!

But I miss Martha!

I agree, this should NOT be happening

Edited March 24, 200818 yr by Zendall Fan

Well no offense to Noelle, but I won't like her regardless. This all shouldn't be happening.

Well no offense to Noelle, but I won't like her regardless. This all shouldn't be happening.

Co-Sign

Either way you look at it the recast is going to fail. I don't know who this actress is but the show is stupid to replace Martha Byrne's character. No one is going to accept it.

Lily shouldn't be recast, but keep in mind guys, the recast could've been A LOT WORSE.

Lily shouldn't be recast, but keep in mind guys, the recast could've been A LOT WORSE.

True....I heard other names...shudders.... I actually wanted Heather Rattray back but oh well.

I love Noelle Beck and was a HUGE fan of hers on Loving. Hopefully ATWT and Martha fans will accept her.

I don't think all that many are going to accept her, not because of her, but because of how Martha was treated mostly. Seeing a recast is going to bring it home for alot of us on a daily basis

She looks like Christina Chambers. We all know how well HER recast of a popular character went.

I like Noelle Beck and all, but I'm kind of starting to smell another Susan Batten scenario here if the fans get crazy like they did last time with sending sh!tloads of cans to the ATWT studio. Now if GL viewers could do something like that to Ellen Wheeler, then I'd be one happy camper.

Edited March 25, 200818 yr by Noel

I like Noelle Beck and all, but I'm kind of starting to smell another Susan Batten scenario here if the fans get crazy like they did last time with sending sh!tloads of cans to the ATWT studio. Now if GL viewers could do something like that to Ellen Wheeler, then I'd be one happy camper.

Ok so we know that Martha loves ATWT and LILY and everyone there. As her fans we owe it to Martha to give Noelle a chance. Martha said in a response to Noelle's hiring that she's gonna have fun working with great people

So give Noelle a break

Martha will be back one day im sure but LILY needs to be on screen

Martha will be back, but she should have never had to leave in the first place.

Martha will be back, but she should have never had to leave in the first place.

I agree but it happened and according to ricky Paul Goldin from GL soon to be AMC he sees to think Martha has something already lined up

so YAY if true

Martha is the ONLY Lily. I hope that the show collapses like a souffle for letting royalty go without a fight.

Noelle will never have a chance, good actress or not.