Jump to content

All: Who was the best and worst writer on your soap?


Recommended Posts

  • Members

You aren't alone Gio when it comes to Culliton. He was such a breath of fresh air after those dark days of Jean Passanate. I was actually quite disappointed when Frons fired him in favour of that god awful juvenile Gordon Rayfield.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 46
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Administrator

Since 1993......

DAYS

Best:

1. Reilly

2. Brash and Cwikly

Worst:

1. Higley

2. Langan

3. SSM

If Sheffer/Kelly were fired today they would be #3 on the worst list. Since they're still Head Writers, they have time to improve and maybe jump into the Best list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

All My Children

Best: Agnes Nixon, Wisner Washam, and Lorraine Broderick

Worst: Jean Passanante, Megan McTavish (I even think her 92-95 stint was totally overrated and coasted on the great Nixon/Washam/Broderick material from 90-92), Gordon Rayfield

One Life to Live

Best: Gordon Russell, Sam Hall, Peggy O'Shea

Worst: Pam Long, Claire Labine, Megan McTavish, the Corringtons

Guiding Light

Best: Pam Long, Doug Marland, the Dobsons, Nancy Curlee/Steven Demorest/James Reilly/Lorraine Broderick era

Worst: Mary Ryan Munisteri, Claire Labine, Douglas Anderson, Megan McTavish

Ryan's Hope

Best: Claire Labine, Paul Avila Mayer

Worst: Pat Falken Smith

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Y&R

Best: William J. Bell, Kay Alden, Jack Smith, Trent Jones (yes, he was co-head writer for a while)

Worst: Lynn Marie Latham

B&B

Best: William J. Bell, Bradley Bell

Worst: Bradley Bell

GL

Best: Irna Philips, Agnes Nixon, The Dobsons, Douglas Marland, Pamela K Long, Nancy Curlee/Steven Demorest/James Reilly/Lorraine Broderick

Worst: Ellen Weston, Claire Labine, B&E, Megan McTavish, Pat Falken Smith

ATWT

Best: Irna Philips, The Dobsons, Douglas Marland, Lorraine Broderick

Worst: Jean Passanante, Stern and Black, Jessica Klein

AMC

Best: Agnes Nixon, Wisner Washam, and Lorraine Broderick

Worst: Megan McTavish, Jean Passanante, Gordon Rayfield

OLTL

Best: Peggy O'Shea, Gordon Russell, Sam Hall

Worst: Pamela K Long, Claire Labine, Megan McTavish, Dena Higley, Michael Malone stint #2 (hell, I never got what so was good about his original stint anyway, it was way too inconsistent)

GH

Best: Claire Labine, Douglas Marland, Pat Falken Smith, Karen Harris and Richard Culliton

Worst: Megan McTavish, Gene Palumbo, Ann Marcus, Janet Iacobuzio & Christopher Whitesell, Norma Monty, Maralyn Thomas, Bill Levinson

Days

Best: William J. Bell, Pat Falken Smith, Brash & Cwickly

Worst: James E. Reilly, Tom Lagan, Dena Higley

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

ATWT...

Best...Doug Marland, Lorraine Broderick and undoubtably Irna Phillips (though that was really before my time)

Worst...whoever wrote in the early 80's and tried to make it into General Hospital with Mr. Big, and Barb's drugged dream state that had her reliving some past life where she and Gunnar where lovers. Stern and Black, Leah Laiman's brief six months, JPiss, and the last two years of Hogan's repetitive crap.

GL

Best...Doug Marland, Pam Long, whoever wrote from 90-94, Millee Taggert

Worst...Ellen Weston. Honest to God, the Maryanne Carruthers Mystery should be the basis to have her disbarred, or whatever they do to lowly scum hack writers. OH....and the horrific year of Megan McTavish, that reduced Nola Reardon Chamberlain to tossing Buzz in the basement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Y&R

Best: William Bell / Kay Alden

Worst: Lynn Marie Latham

AMC

Best: Agnes Nixon

Worst: Megan McTavish

I know most people already wrote this, but I posted my opinion too... I'm glad most of my "worst" writers are done with, but Lynn is still there. :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

AMC:

Best: Agnes Nixon

Worst: Megan McTavish

ATWT:

Best: Douglas Marland

Worst: Jessica Klein

BB:

Best: William J. Bell

Worst: Bradley Bell

DAYS:

Best: Leah Laiman

Worst: James E. Reilly

GH:

Best: Gene Palumbo

Worst: Robert Guza Jr

GL:

Best: Pamela K. Long

Worst: Ellen Weston

OLTL:

Best: S. Michael Schnessel

Worst: Josh Griffith

PASS:

Worst: James E. Reilly (he always sucks)

YR:

Best: William J. Bell

Worst: Lynn Marie Latham

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Guiding Light

Best: Douglas Marland-Marland and the oldest soap opera were a PERFECT fit. He honored history, made GL one heck of a drama on CBS.

Pamela K. Long & Richard Culliton-I think things truly went downhill after Culliton left. Long established some monumental characters like Reva Shayne and Alexandra Spaulding.

Nancy Curlee, Stephen Demorest, James E. Reilly, and Lorraine Broderick-Curlee wrote with such grace and admiration for the show. She understood the characters and not once did she make the show into a cartoon like it is now. Her excellent team were only a small part of her success IMO.

Millee Taggart and Carolyn Culliton-The two tried to restore GL back to the show it once was from 2002-2003. They made the show into a intreguing, character driven drama.

Between: Lloyd Gold-I liked and disliked some of his stories. The rejuvenation of Spaulding Enterprises vs. Lewis was great stuff. He did good stuff for the ratings in 2001. I just hated how he messed up with that awful storyline involving Reva and time travel. He also reunited Josh and Reva for me.

Worst:

Any writer who wrote for the show between Long's two tenures in the 80s. This goes for Sheri Anderson, Jeff Ryder, Mary Ryan Munisteri, and a few more. Just a bad fit for the show.

Pat Falken Smith-She really didn't understand the show.

Douglas Anderson

Megan McTavish-She made a complete mess of the show.

Claire Labine-I didn't really like how the mob was taking over the show under her. Creating Tony Santos, big mistake IMO.

Ellen Weston-Destoryed the show for me.

David Kreizman-When Lorraine Broderick left the writing team and when they started writing their stories before they did the casting (cough:Ed Bauer:cough), things went downhill. Broderick should have stayed on and should have been given more power. She would have been a great teacher for him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

You are not alone I liked Richard Culliton. The successors were Anna Theresa Cascio and Gordon Rayfield. Their work got good from April-June of 2003 but I feel if it wasn't for Cascio, it would have tanked. Rayfield was a bad head writer and him working solo would have been a disaster

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • When Robert Calhoun became EP I thought GL was finally hitting its stride after some pretty rough years. Unfortunately the ratings during Robert Calhoun's run did not reflect the quality of the show.
    • There was a five week break between the last Friday episode and the Thursday episodes which were the final four episodes. I have a feeling the final four episodes were refilmed to wrap up the storylines. 
    • Yes, I forgot there was a gap between his exit from GL and his start at ATWT. This almost makes me want to cry. He really turned ATWT around (and good for them). It would have been great if someone had done the same for GL. Can't imagine who. The Dobsons were doing Santa Barbara at this point. I mainly blame Kobe. She may not have been the worst EP they ever had, but she almost totally destroyed the Bauers and decimated much of the rest of the cast, sometimes for egotistical reasons. That was a huge mistake and made it that much harder for the show to recover.
    • Douglas Marland began at As the World Turns in September 1985 but it took about a year for his run to show growth in the ratings. 1986 As the World Turns becomes CBS's #2 daytime drama after Y&R.
    • This is not at all surprising. Watching the recently uploaded episodes, the uneveness is SO apparent. Characters are changing at the drop of a hat. The stories are close to incoherent. It's a mess, and we're only up to May. What a fall from grace. An Emmy-winning show with good ratings and within a few short years hitting possible cancelation territory.  I'm surprised CBS and/or P&G didn't try to do SOMETHING to restore its former glory. Was Marland still at ATWT at this point? 
    • I think she did, yes. The only part of that return I remember appreciating was the ripoff they did of Earrings of Madame De, where a secretly broke India sold a trinket and Ross or Alan (I think it was Ross) then bought it for her, not knowing it was hers.
    • 6-4   Getting around to the rewatching and I guess Dani/Bill/Hayley as A story is coming around better to me. I hope that means that I will feel different about Friday's episode which first time around I felt was more of a Wednesday/Thursday episode. Anita's story and Dani/Bill/Hayley (with Kat vs SilkPress being a solid B plot to keep the SilkPress storyline alive, but NOT A story) have been the focus for this past week. So I'm worried I'll feel a way when I get back to Friday's episode. I guess I'm about to find out.   I know I have issues with Dani/Bill/Hayley coming back into focus since the much better paced SilkPress storyline is truly where it's at with so much aftermath/new direction to explore. However, I'm finding that...just like with the story of Martin's secret being slowly woven back into the story narrative...I care a little bit more for it since it's been background since Week 3, Month 1. IMHO the characters...outside of Hayley...have been developed in other plots. The past week and a half has had Dani and Andre growing closer and they have gotten to the 'third month what are we?' talk that I expect in all relationships in real life. And I liked how the writers have slowly had friction between them to see what they are made of? Is it still just a booty call or can it be more? Meanwhile, Bill has been hiding his physical issues for months. Too busy messing with other people's marriages.

      Please register in order to view this content

          So now that they have some more POV to them, it was good to see an organic...and yes, it was organic...reason for them to be in the same room. In this case...the hospital room. Lord, Karla and Timon have such great chemistry. And Dani and Bill were so acting like exes. No wonder Hayley feels threatened. Oh, well. lol. Bonus...the drama with Bill has Hayley and Naomi back in each other's orbit. They don't have enough scenes together.    You all know I was waiting for Anita's story. So how am I feeling? Pretty good. TT has been playing it to the hilt. And I was not expecting the story of a fourth member who killed themselves after being pushed out. And it's had a build. First through Tracy. And now with Sharon...who is swiftly being established as a piece of work. A Have-Not (if not Has-Been) who is not above scheming. Okay. lol. I liked the conversation between Anita and Vernon where she told him the truth, and he tried to hold her up. Whether she deserved it or not, it was good to see. I'm sure all of the secrets are not out yet so I look forward to more. Cuz we know they are not cancelling the reunion. Which fingers crossed...will be at the police fundraiser.     Honestly, I continued to be impressed with how the writers have kept Silk Press Sheila out of jail, but still playing the beats of it all. She's definitely in covering her tracks mode, and it's great to watch. It's also great to see her mixing it up with different characters. I was happy to get the long-awaited showdown between her and Nosy Nurse and Nosy Nurse READ...HER...DOWN. I was just disappointed Nosy Nurse spilled some tea. And that led to SilkPress's scene with Andre. And then Andre...lord...talked too much.   C plot this episode has been Chelesa's love life. I was wondering where it was going to go after her talk with Vernon. Enter...Mystery Woman. I wonder what her secret would be that would get in her way with Chels. Related to an enemy of the Duprees? Married? I am intrigued. And I do like Chelesa getting the spotlight because daytime does not really do it like how they are doing it with her.    Can Kat and Jacob get a spinoff? lol. 
    • 1986 began with the EP change from Gail Kobe to Joe Willmore and the HW change from Pamela Long to Jeff Ryder. Over the course of 1986 there was turnover in the HW ranks: Jeff Ryder, Jeff Ryder and Mary Ryan Munisteri as co-HWs, Mary Ryan Munisteri and Ellen Barrett as co-HWs, Joseph Manetta, Joseph Manetta and Sheri Anderson as co-HWs. The 1986 ratings reflected the quality of the show. GL was saved from cancel territory in 1986 because Capitol was still CBS's lowest-rated daytime drama.
    • As Michael should be...DARK.   I'm just getting through my first few scenes of Rory as Michael. And I'm already picking up chemistry with LW, EMcCoy, and SMattson from the jump. I liked Rory as Noah on Y&R, but felt it was wasted potential. So far...he's proving me right. 
    • Oh, lord. Those rumors are true, aren't they?
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy