Everything posted by P.J.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I'm not sure I agree that she was fired to pay for him either, but in some way, I think Buzz's personality was formed in response to the focus group mentality. They didn't have to make Buzz an obnoxious con man who ran out on his kids because he couldn't stand his blue collar existence and his responsibilities. And they later softened that by giving him Lucy, who thought he was a great dad.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
For me, it's not even close. Deas, by a mile. I found Nick annoying, but Irizarry at least had a history with the show before Jill was involved, and Nick never seemed to eat the show. Deas is the male equivalent of Kim Zimmer. A little went a long way, and he seemed to get these "moral center of the universe" moments that just left you scratching your head. I actually liked Marj Dusay, much more than others here do. Not being Beverlee McKinsey isn't a crime. Marj was a respected character actress long before her soap days. Marcy Walker was screwed over by Jill. While the character of Tangie was bad, it's not really a reflection on her.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I do think part of the allure of Deas was critical darling status. Especially in those first couple of years when Kim was still gone. I mean, he's probably a great guy and he was doing what was asked of him. The Coopers were an established family, and he and Jenna were a popular pairing. But like Reva, Buzz wore on me. Honestly, Buzz never should've really been completely reconciled with Harley and Frank. He wasn't "a family guy"...but somehow wound up as Mr. Springfield. (well, except for sending Rocky off to Jenna's nonexistent family, or wherever those kids went for years and Rocky never came back from...)
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
Good Lord....it sounds vaguely familiar. Olivia certainly inherited the Golden HooHa badge from Reva. She got more Dick than a convention of Richards. I just generally loathed the character and hated her stories, period. I don't get people's liking of Crystal Chappel. Olivia was another character who wore out her welcome long before the end of the show.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
Oh, and honestly, if Beth Ehlers hadn't returned, GL might've finally been forced to dump Deas. There is no doubting Deas' talent, but Buzz had run amok. Frank had never been a character strong enough to really generate story, and it was clear TPTB had no interest in him and Eleni anymore. Buzz doesn't really do anything for that last decade other than run around in an apron at the diner. The regrettable Maryanne Carruthers story notwithstanding.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
Imagine my surprise on watching the German episodes. I'd read that Van's exit was day x, and day x's episode is one long Van/Reva talk at the airport, where Van is suddenly all buddy buddy with Reva again, after months of sniping over their places in Alan's life. And Van is just all concerned about opening ol'Reve's eyes to the fact that Reva is falling for Alan. And I'm just ROLLING MY EYES, thinking WTF is Van giving one flip about Reva's stupidity? On watching the German episodes, I realized Vanessa spends nearly the entire week packing up her life and saying goodbye. Her last episode is actually the day after the talk with Reva, where she says goodbye to Dinah, A-M, HB and Henry, Alex and Phillip, and Ross. Alan shows up, but they don't' speak. Maybe it was just that she'd been so heavily in story that year that she got that buildup to leaving. And while maybe not a "happy" ending, at least a purposeful one. Considering Long seemed so blase about Van for so long (maybe that's the wrong word...but often didn't know what to do with her outside of being Billy's supportive wife) it had some effort put in to it. It's even kind of a lynchpin in the story of Phillip and Alex's plot to oust Alan, as Van's leaving kind of cements Henry's support for them.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I don't think they were good in general at goodbyes. Probably a consequence of so many regimes and no consistency. There are some meaningful goodbyes (Vanessa in '88, Josh in '91) and some tragic deaths (Lujack, Reva and the bridge, even ***** and **** as I don't want to spoil you), Roger's '80 exit stands out. But otherwise it's some random deaths, (Jackie, Hillary, Leslie Ann, Maeve) and people randomly picking up and leaving town (Katie, Tony and Annabelle who go on summer vacation and leave off screen, Quint and Nola decide to leave together, but I think only say goodbye to Henry onscreen. Johnny comes back from visiting Roxy and breaks up with Chelsea, ouch.) There aren't a lot that seem to happily send people off to the next chapter of their lives, that we just don't get to see. Harley and Mallet get married, Phillip, Beth & baby Lizzie go to Arizona for their community service, and Phillip does at least stick around through Sam's surgery.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
In '88, I think Ross was mostly involved in a drug case. I think the character's name was Nicky, and he was Cam's father's supplier. Mindy gets mixed up in it via Rusty, Ross is semi-dating a cop played by Mary Ellen Stuart, and (as was normal for Ross) he's probably riding herd on Phillip somewhat. Towards the end, he's defending Josh for the attempted murder of Will. Nadine doesn't come to town until Jan/February '89. Whatever they have going on kind of stalls when Vanessa comes back, and Ross is more interested in Holly than Nadine.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
LOL...as I've never seen a scene of Carter and Lainie together, the entire romance might've been off-screen. Don't forget the jack-of-all trades William, who worked at The Blue Orchid, The Blue Moon and The Towers, not to mention WSPR (if not The Journal back when Maeve was alive, but I'm not positive on that.) And there's another problem--he couldn't have even gone by his last name (Fletcher) like others might (or what the hell ever Mallet came up with Mallet), because of Fletcher. So, middle name "X" would be okay. There must've been more children at least referenced during the '70's. But it doesn't seem like GL made an effort to give characters families. There's Billy, Emily (who'd never heard of before posting) Tim Werner, Rick, Christina and Phillip. Hope, of course, but she must've been older than Billy at the time. I can think of a lot more ATWT children--Betsy, Emily, Frannie, Andy, Paul, Teddy (who becomes Ryder in the '90's), Chuckie (although I'm not sure how old he was when he died) LOL...ironically, its the same amount.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I know what Vanessa said (honestly, I wouldn't trust Holly or Blakes's assessment of the man). But this is the same man who still in '96-ish was coercing a dying woman for a secret to topple the Spauldings. Vanessa was not perfect. But she surely knew the mayhem Roger caused in the name of loving someone.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
Upon reflection, RJ must've been born before Hart died. I think Cassie gave birth with Dinah's assistance? It started before Marland. Although I think Alan-Michael is clever. Some poor schmuck almost doomed Rick as Freddy/Frederick. The only kids who escaped fate were those given up for adoption. Dinah, Dylan, Daisy/Susan.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I didn't need to see Roger dote on his grandchildren. It would've ended up just like his kids--either his excuse to run rampant trying to build a "legacy" for them or a way for him to manipulate people. He could declare his love for his kids/grandkids all day long and twice on Sunday---he wasn't capable of love. And speaking of, the fact Cassie named her kid with Hart Roger Joshua is just stupid. Hart hated his father. (To be honest, I'm assuming it was born after Hart died, but I'm not sure.) If they wanted to have a kid with going by "RJ", she could've named it for Rusty (Russell), her brother.) I don't think Nola's presence hurt Bridget. I think Bridget literally outlasted everyone she interacted with from the time she arrived in town. They were either fired, left, or in the process of leaving. And the IIC failed to move her into other stories with other characters. Literally, from the time Bridget arrived, Maureen and Nadine died, Hart was recast at least three times, Julie, Kat and David left (and that recast was unsuccessful), Ed and Vanessa are floating in and out of town, Dylan (the only guy who really dug her) left, Michelle was recast, and Roger was recast and then left town. The failure to relaunch Nola certainly didn't help (and **** and J certainly wasn't strong enough characters to help anchor the Reardons in town again). But there should've been story for Bridget for eons. The Vanessa/Bridget/Roger angle alone should've been a gold mine. And imagine Bridget and Dinah going hammer and tongs not over Hart, but for Vanessa's approval. That Bridget never got a serious love interest (uhm, Dylan isn't exactly a chem machine) is a travesty.