Melroser
Member
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: BTG: January 2026 Discussion Thread
Everything posted by Melroser
- Another World Discussion Thread
-
DAYS: June 2022 Discussion Thread ⌛
How can an episode where a soap kills off a legacy character be so damn boring? I tried to tune in to see what was going on and I can't keep watching. Ali/Chanel + snore. Tripp leaving town again....ok, whatever. Susan...I just can't sit through. What a horrible mix of scenes today when this ep should be going all out hyping up Abigail's death.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
I believe Sharon wanted off the show earlier than her contracted term because she was pregnant and found the abusive storyline between Peter and Brittany to be draining. She has said in interviews that the commute to Brooklyn didn't help. I think she wanted to focus on herself and her baby and the show let her out of her contract.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
I loved '86! Probably because imo Cecile was a Queen! Nancy Frangione was so underrated and Cecile was such a fun character. I do think the show was making another attempt to go after DAYS viewers (as it often did at times). From bringing on Denise Alexander who was once popular on DAYS, to making Reginald the Stefano, to the over-the-top Cecile as Queen, the "young love" Marley/Jake. I think these were all moves to go after DAYS viewers. I thought the show was on the right track until it got hit with the mass exodus in the fall. Marley/Jake/Vicky, Cecile/Cass/Kathleen, Donna, Brittany all gone after driving most of the story. The show definitely faltered.
-
Days 6/6/2022 Weekly Preview Promo
These promos are always all over the place. I wish they'd spend more time on 2 or 3 of the characters to show part of an actual storyline instead of seeing how many characters they can fit into the promo. Nothing about this makes me interested. or at least try something like this...
-
Another World Discussion Thread
MJ finding out she had HIV after the reveal of her prostitution past would have been a great story to delve into! It would have involved the McKinnons and the Corys because of Adam. Prostitution and a social story at the same time? I don't think the writers-or the network- would have made it as gritty as it should be to make it a powerful story.
-
Well Plotted Soap Stories
Who shot Jake on AW? From Marley's rape, Kathleen's return to visit him in the hospital, to the trial against Marley, then blackmailing Paulina when he remembered it was her. All led to great drama and fantastic performances from Tom Eplin, Anne Heche, Cali Timmins, Anna Stuart. Then, of course, led to Kathleen/Cass/Frankie.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
Vicky seemed to be dominant "younger" female lead. That's mainly why I could picture her as a rival for someone. She was featured in so many stories. Vicky/Marley would have been a great rivalry. They had plenty of reason to be because of Jamie and Jake. I enjoyed Marley holding Vicky hostage near the show's end- Ellen and Jensen, but then suddenly Marley was "well" again and it was dropped.
-
Characters that Stopped Getting Stories
At the end of AW, Donna had no story except to be a sounding board to Victoria. Wasn't Anna Stuart planning on leaving because of this? Then she stayed till the end.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
I always felt that AW lacked a long-term female adversarial relationship like a Viki/Dorian. The show had Rachel, Felicia, Donna, Iris, and Sharlene and neither combo was a viable adversary. Yes, they had issues at times, but they always seemed to make up. Vicky/Marley and Vicky/Paulina are two other examples that had long-term potential but ended. Vicky/Amanda. Amanda/Olivia. I wish Lila/Vicky and Lila/Anne-Frankie would have had more time. Who do you think should have been the show's Viki/Dorian?
-
FIRE!
Melrose! this is really more of an explosion, I guess. Melrose loved those. This, Jake's boat when he was presumed dead, the ending with Peter and Amanda.
-
FIRE!
More AW: Northwoods Inn fire... There's also the time that Grant staged his shooting and the place caught on fire while Amanda (Christine Tucci) was upstairs. Evan (Eric Scott Woods) rushed in and saved her.
-
Most Iconic Characters from The Short Lived Soaps
I just recently watched the entire original run of Dynasty and have finished the first season of the Colbys. I'm not a big Sable fan. I found her hard to root for. Not sure why because I loved Alexis, but I never felt sorry for Sable like I did Alexis most of the time.
-
Most Iconic Characters from The Short Lived Soaps
Carrie on Central Park West Heather on Titans. Peyton on Savannah. 10 years seems like a long run for a soap. Even Dynasty and Melrose went under 10 and they are pretty iconic on their own.
-
Looking back...Primetime Ratings from the 80's
Knots Landing? I don't see it on the list for '84-'85. Was it below 63rd?
-
SON plan to save Days!!
I agree with most of what everyone here has said. Stop all the corny plots. I also wouldn't kill anyone for at least a year and then only if it were in a dramatic/permanent way. Deaths now on the show have zero impact because everyone knows the character is just coming back later. Trim the cast to at least half of what it is. I'd trim Brady, Chloe, Rafe, Gabi, Jake, Ava (tho I love Tamara), Kristen, Leo, Craig, Nancy, Bonnie, Gwen, Xander, Sarah (she's ruined with this Renee crap), Jack, Jennifer, Ben, Ciara, Roman, Clyde, T.R.. Maybe bring on Stephanie, Joey, and Paul (if Christopher Sean). Keep Eric. I'm okay with Sami coming and going, but just don't feature her in a story so that her absence makes no sense. I wouldn't completely abandoned "public places" but doing them a lot more infrequently would help. Just when it is done, a couple of extras are a must. I would keep a focus on the hospital. Accidents, crime victims can filter through. Maybe even "temp roles" for a couple of weeks at at time with a new character mixing it up with Kayla, Tripp, and Mike Horton? A Mike/Kayla/Patch triangle? Someone really needs to address Marlena being allowed to be anyone else's psychologist. I'd focus on family and relationships. Bring back romance instead of bedhopping. Build up couples. (Brook Lynn/Chase on GH). Shocking dramatic plots can be done without a big budget. A character walking in on a spouse having an affair. Who's the daddy? Gaslighting someone. If Days is going to try and do corporate stories like Y&R then slow down. It seems like they are constantly trading out the CEOs of Dimera, Titan, et all every other month. There's no suspense or build up to someone being ousted and a rival taking control. I understand making scenes short for filming purposes and keeping costs down, but it loses all the dramatic possibilities. Can characters have knockdown drag-out verbal spars if they only get to say two sentences at a time? What's the drama in someone spitting out a line, cut, the other character spitting out a line, cut.... I hate it. Giving newbies shorter scenes is probably a good idea, but use your vets. John/Marlena, Patch/Kayla, Tony/Anna, Nicole vs. Sami. vs Kate, could do longer scenes I'm sure. Let them go! Like others said, longer scenes means less characters needed to fill the show.
-
Roles that Cannot be Recast
At the end of AW, Rachel should not have been recast if Victoria Wyndham left. I feel Linda Dano and Stephen Schnetzer's Felicia and Cass could not have been recasted. A Martinez and Marcy Walker as Cruz and Eden, SB Doug Davidson or Lauralee Bell as Paul and Christine on Y&R. Days has so many: Deidre Hall, Drake Hogestyn, Stephen Nichols, Mary Beth Evans, Thaao Penghlis, Leann Hunley, John Aniston, Doug and Susan Hayes, Suzanne Rogers. GH: Laura couldn't be recast now that Genie Francis has made the part hers. Same for Tony Geary's Luke if he doesn't want to be on. Finola Hughes, Tristan Rogers, Lynn Herring.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
The recent mentions of all the recasts during the mid-late 80's makes me wonder if AW suffered more than most soaps from constant recasts. Thoughts? For examples, over time: 3 Rachel Davis Cory 2 Mackenzie Cory 2 Steve Frame 5 Alice Matthews Frame (At least 10) Jamie Frame 6 Sally Frame 2 Sharlene Frame 3 Josie Watts Sinclair 3 (adult) Amanda Cory 3 (adult) Matthew Cory 2 Paulina Cory 2 Sandy Cory 2 Cecile Cory 2 Blaine Ewing 2 Iris Cory Wheeler 2 Donna Love 3 Nicole Love 3 Peter Love 4 Vicky Love 3 Marley Love 3 Vince McKinnon 2 MJ McKinnon 2 Grant Harrison
- Another World Discussion Thread
-
A Soap Opera Museum: What would you put in it?
Portrait of Barnabas that hung at the Collins estate. AW's Red Swan. Texas: the state flag.
-
B&B March 2022 Discussion Thread
Under next week's previews for B&B in SOD, it says: "a powerful bond is formed during a chilling near-death experience". Is this Finn related, or something else? As many of you, I hope that Finn sticks around.
-
B&B March 2022 Discussion Thread
I was thinking the same thing. Have these people not learned over the years to not confront Sheila by oneself? Travel in packs, people. Packs.
-
Y&R March 2022 Discussion Thread
I think the show should cut there losses with Rey and Chelsea and rid Genoa City of both of them. Along with Kevin, Chloe, and Michael. Keep Lauren though. As I've posted before, I'd love for a Jack/Lauren pairing to stir things up. This, in my opinion, would be a decent start of cleaning up the show. Though many others could go as well. Chance, Abby, Faith, Moses, Ashland. If the show needs to save money (and show doesn't?), that's 10 characters right there. Billy could kill Ashland and go away. That would make 11 (and no more damn podcasts!).
-
Y&R and B&B March 2022 spoilers
So Steffy and Finn would be brother and sister and have a kid together? I think even that would go too far for most of the audience. Finn being Deacon's kid? Not sure, but what if Hope turns out not to be Deacon's? If Bridget is coming back, it could be for this story. Brooke has been raked over the coals for sleeping with her daughter's husband and having his child. What if Hope isn't his, after all? If Hope turns out to be Ridge's kid, then that makes her and Thomas half-siblings. Weren't they a couple?
-
B&B March 2022 Discussion Thread
Maybe the montages regarding Finn/Steffy were meant because Steffy is going away and not Finn. It could be a setup to how much Finn cares for her instead of her for him. (Yes, it's technically the same, but can be seen from either side). Isn't Finn rather well received after all the Steffy/Liam/Hope drama for years? If they drag out that triangle again, it will be unfortunate. I finally find Liam less obnoxious now and that's saying something. lol. Does Quinn still not know that Sheila is around???