Jump to content

The Originals and the Imitators


Paul Raven

Recommended Posts

  • Members

Networks are well known for jumping on the bandwagon when a show hits big with their own version/variation.

What are some shows you can think of that appeared after a similar show or theme had shown that viewers were interested?

One obvious example was I Dream of Jeannie NBC arriving on the heels of Bewitched ABC which was a smash finishing at #2 for the season.

Jeannie was never as popular but hung around for 5 seasons. i would have to be Team Bewitched.

Looking forward to your contributions and some good discussions!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 64
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Members

The Cosby Show and Growing Pains

Both shows were set in New York.

Both shows had a doctor father that worked from an office that was a part of their home.

Both shows had a teenage son that struggled academically.

 

Edited by kalbir
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Laugh In revolutionized TV comedy with it's fast pace and edgire humor and was a smash for NBC.

They quickly commissioned Soul, a black version from the same producers which aired as a pilot, but wasn't picked up.

And ABC aired the infamous 'Turn On' which lasted one episode (and on some stations, not even that as local managers took it off the air during the show)

ABC also aired "What's It All About World?' which had Laugh In influence but was short lived.

CBS went a more traditional route with Hee Haw, a rural knock off which was a success.

MV5BMjlkMzU3NTMtMmNiMy00ODRkLWE2Y2YtMzll

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Revenge got a lot of buzz in the 2011-12 season. Next season NBC premiered the show Deception, about a woman working to infiltrate her best friends rich family after she dies of a suspicious overdose to get to the bottom of what happened and get... revenge.

Recently, we saw a lot of This Is Us-inspired shows - A Million Little Things being the obvious one, but then also Council of Dads and The Village to cash in on that 30-something drama trend. Oh, and of course ABC ordered a reboot of said thirtysomething that never made it to the air.

Edited by te.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

One of the oldest examples I immediately thought of was I Married Joan, NBC’s answer to I Love Lucy.

While not as memorable as Lucy, and the opening line about Joan Davis being “America’s Queen of Comedy” suspect, I found the show to be good fun and several episodes are downright hilarious thanks to Joan Davis’ own slapstick abilities. Unfortunately I recall Davis had to quit due to poor health, and died a few years later. Her daughter, who played the sister on the show also died a few years later. Jim Backus, who played Davis’ husband later gained bigger fame as the Millionaire in Gilligan’s Island. 
 

In the early 90’s ABC and CBS tried hard to get their own Simpsons like shows going especially with CBS and Family Dog but the attempts were all DOA.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

TV Censored Bloopers NBC begat Foul Ups Bleeps and Blunders ABC

Knight Rider NBC 1982 Michael Long recovers from a fatal gunshot wound in the face. With a new look, he assumes a fresh identity as Michael Knight and wages a war against criminals with his indestructible supercar, KITT.

Street Hawk ABC 1984  Jesse Mach, a former motorcycle cop who was injured in the line of duty, is recruited for a top-secret government mission to ride Street Hawk -- a combat motorbike designed to fight crime.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The laziest were often from NBC themselves. They never got that Friends was a success because of the cast (and I didn't even like most of the cast).

Remember ABC's Townies, which was also meant to be a comeback for Molly Ringwald?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Oh, dear, lol.

Speaking of ABC, remember when "Lost" became this gigantic, out-of-the-box hit and so every network including The Weather Channel and Playboy TV tried to cash in with their own versions?

Edited by Khan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Diff'rent Strokes NBC/Webster ABC. Cute black orphan taken in by benevolent white family.

The Fugitive ABC. 1963/Run For Your Life NBC 1965

Although the premise for each show was different The Fugitive had a man on the run from the law, and Run For Your Life had a man given a death sentence through illness, the similarity was that they moved all over the country encountering new people in new situations.

The lead actors David Janssen and Ben Gazzara were similar laconic personality types.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Great pairing that seemed to come out of the blue! Around that time, it felt like Sheffer/Goutman didn’t really know what to do with Emily or Hal. And KM and BH had surprisingly great chemistry. It was good for Emily especially because she was coming off those unsympathetic years with the Tom affair and then running the Intruder and essentially just being a busybody.
    • I think the issue with Lulu is less the character (which was the issue in the Julie Berman days under Guza II) and more the lack of nuance. The current GH team rarely writes nuance for any character or at least can't sustain it for long, or they reserve it for a favored few. I also think the rooting interest at GH BTS often remains on preferred characters or actors - BLQ/Setton - vs. Laura's kids. So it's easy to make Lulu the heavy if you think Brook Lynn and Chase are the money on this show. I don't, but I think FV does. And that's not to say I think Amanda Setton is bad in the role, or that I would get rid of BLQ. I don't trend towards either (though I do think that if Setton's personal beliefs keep getting in the way of material I would reluctantly recast). I think Brook Lynn is essential to use as a lead presently. But I don't think it needs to be the black and white dichotomy of suffering young matriarch BLQ and aggressor Lulu. While it's good that unlike in the Guza years they can recognize that Lulu can be obnoxious and rash, can be her own worst enemy and that that is part of the character, it can be toned down or given more layers than it has of late. There's nothing wrong there the writing can't fix.
    • 1999: I just watched it. It felt so primetime. La Lucci is making history. Aretha's daydreaming segment. @Contessa Donatella Thank you, my love. So helpful and informative as always. adding them to my queue.
    • I know this isn’t a usual or anywhere near universal take, but I loved the relatively brief Hal/Emily relationship/marriage more than I ever thought I would have with KMH/BH.
    • In my field (not that) I've written my share of dreck when it's what people wanted vs. something good. In the end what matters is the check. These pilots may not be great, but whether or not those writers intended otherwise they got paid.
    • I think there is plenty to critique and/or roast about the show, but I think there's also good bones and a lot of progressive improvement. It's the Bell/B&B formula and house style that is hardest for it to shake and the most necessary IMO, as well as some dead weight actors or characters, but that formula also apparently works for a lot of general viewers and I suspect CBS. OTOH it's also very modern in certain ways (sometimes overly hip dialogue, and some story) that still make it feel like a show that's bouncing between distant past staples of soap opera fundamentals and the present moment. And the old fashioned product placement is fun but also so goofy, while material like June is hysterical. Imagine leading with 'the underpass is where I live, and I like it there!' It's an unusual show in that way, because its identity and tone is still not fully formed. You don't know what it'll be. But that's normal at this juncture. The closest thing to a glimpse of the future foundation, I think (besides the obvious core family setup that's been there since Day 1), is the rivalry and future familial bond - and likely love/hate relationship - between Kat and Eva. A la many central sisters or siblings throughout soap history.
    • I loved Kelley Menighan! She was an MVP, especially during the show’s last few years. I always looked forward to anything she did with MM, BH, CZ, MW,  and the two grownup Alisons. Wasn’t a big fan of her with RH’s Paul. I always admired how she balanced being a vixen and being neurotic.
    • LLC can be a lot (lady definitely doesn’t phone it in), but her scenes with Rena made me wish they played actual sisters on a better platform.  Aside from JE, who is a legend so it’s no surprise when she’s excellent, Amanda Setton is my MVP of this story and she hasn’t always been great in this role. You see so much happening in her face as she’s navigating the shifts and layers of this story. She’s fully locked in. Glad Rory Gibson is getting his due on GH. I knew he had more to give than what Y&R was giving him. The writing will be a factor here as well because the character of Michael hasn’t been written well in ages (if ever, arguably). GH just can’t sustain the good stuff for more than a few weeks. Alexa Havins is a very good actress and was widely embraced as Lulu initially, but the character’s one-note abrasiveness has a lot of folks wishing she was gone at this point. 
    • It's pilots like "Hurricane Sam" and "Anything for Love" that makes me so afraid to write professionally, because, my God, what if I actually tried and came up with something just as awful, if not worse (if that's even possible)?
    • JANUARY 1974 SPECIALS ADDED... Here are the January 1974 specials which have been added to the yearly list on page 76:

      Please register in order to view this content

       
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy