1 hour ago, DRW50 said:

I think the biggest problems with Rick started in the late '90s/early '00s, which was also when MEK fell off (to be honest I am not a huge MEK fan anyway, although to his credit he has looked much healthier in recent years so more power to him).

I can't see Susan in that part at all.

I never really watched AMC that much, but have in recent years started going back at looking at it. MEK is one of those actors that was always being buzzed about in the soap press back in the day and I thought he may have worked as a stronger Rick. 

I don't really see Susan in any part.....LOL. Bless her though. She became a household name  playing Erica. I remember a woman telling me years ago that she refused to watch one minute of her and said she finally got a " Pity Emmy"

17 minutes ago, SoapDope said:

I don't really see Susan in any part.....LOL. Bless her though. She became a household name  playing Erica. I remember a woman telling me years ago that she refused to watch one minute of her and said she finally got a " Pity Emmy"

I can see why people would feel that way. Her work was genuinely good and she finally chose a good reel for herself, but the optics weren't great.

Sorry, I know this is way off topic now so I'll stop.

Edited August 13, 20241 yr by DRW50

12 minutes ago, DRW50 said:

I can see why people would feel that way. Her work was genuinely good and she finally chose a good reel for herself, but the optics weren't great.

Sorry, I know this is way off topic now so I'll stop.

OMG, the AMC writing team, every single year devoted one story to an Emmy reel for her. If you're saying what I think you're saying, you think 18 of them were flops & only one was a keeper. And, indeed, what the heck am I doing talking about All My Children here in Springfield?! I'll stop, too. 

Robin Christopher as Blake perhaps? 

Brenda Epperson or Karen Witer as Mindy after Kimberly Simms departure?

Edited August 13, 20241 yr by MichaelGL

31 minutes ago, MichaelGL said:

Robin Christopher as Blake perhaps? 

Brenda Epperson or Karen Witer as Mindy after Kimberly Simms departure?

What about Teri Ann Linn from B&B as Mindy ?

 Krista Tesreau should have tested for Patty on Y&R. 

2 hours ago, MichaelGL said:

Robin Christopher as Blake perhaps? 

Brenda Epperson or Karen Witer as Mindy after Kimberly Simms departure?

Robin Christopher would make a stronger Blake.

And after seeing her in the Santa Barbara reunion... Carrington Garland would make a fine Mindy or Morgan Richards.

17 hours ago, DRW50 said:

A Martinez turned down a role, I think.

A Martinez was on L.A. Law from 1992 to 1994, so JFP must have approached him sometime after L.A. Law ended. Perhaps he was JFP choice for Detective Cutter.

I don't think the problem with Blake was Liz Keifer. Admittedly, she wasn't Sherri Stringfield, but those come few and far between. (We're not talking about a drop off similar to Melina Kanakaredes and Jennifer Rozelle, IMO) GL stopped writing rounded characters. Roger departed, so she wasn't daddy's little girl, she wasn't working (that I recall, other than the stupid romance writer) and she suddenly had three kids. 

And they completely lost interest in her after Ross's death. Didn't she spend a year in a coma? 

I agree that the writing did not do Liz Keifer any favors. I actually like Dennehy over Keifer's Blake. IT was a huge mistake to recast her at such a crucial part of the Ross/Blake/Maureen story. It ruined most if not all of the momentum. I understand it's a nightmare if people want to leave, but most of the problems were ones JFP created. 

re: Susan Lucci. If I remembering correctly, didn't her husband pick her reels? Her reels were often so terrible with a lovesick Erica acting as if she were a teenager. She has a few good reels leading up to her win (the drug storyline/the kidnapping of the baby). I really wish Erica has been written as an adult (wasn't Erica becoming a showgirl when Lucci was in her sixties?!?!)

8 hours ago, chrisml said:

re: Susan Lucci. If I remembering correctly, didn't her husband pick her reels? Her reels were often so terrible with a lovesick Erica acting as if she were a teenager. She has a few good reels leading up to her win (the drug storyline/the kidnapping of the baby). I really wish Erica has been written as an adult (wasn't Erica becoming a showgirl when Lucci was in her sixties?!?!)

🤣......I read when Kendall was introduced they tried to play like Erica was still in her early 30's. 

The summer of 1992 was a tough year for Guiding Light with so many incredible actresses leaving the show. For me, the one that hit the hardest was Beverlee McKinsey. What a powerhouse. She was very much missed!

I agree that the Ross/Blake/Roger/Holly storyline lost a bit of steam when Sherry Stringfield left. I also think the character of Blake changed a lot once Stringfield left. However, I think Jerry verDorn and Elizabeth Keifer shared a nice chemistry together. Also, I loved the mother/daughter chemistry between Maureen Garrett and Keifer. I thought it worked very nicely, especially once the two characters patched their relationship up. 

Recasts are tough. I certainly can't imagine the challenge an actor must face when coming into a role that the audience identifies with another actor. I think recast parts almost always seem to also change the character too. I guess that's to be expected as the new actor puts his or her spin on things.

Annette

 

 

Edited August 14, 20241 yr by GL Oldtimer

4 hours ago, GL Oldtimer said:

The summer of 1992 was a tough year for Guiding Light with so many incredible actresses leaving the show.

Kimberley Simms, Sherry Stringfield, Beverlee McKinsey all left w/in weeks of each other. While Fall 1992 wasn't bad, their departures left a huge void in the canvas.

I actually thought the timing for recasting Blake worked. Both as a soft reset for the character and a fitting end for Stringfield. Sherri deserved to play that climax after all her hard work. And honestly, I'm not sure I could've ever believed her falling in love with Ross knowing she set it up to hurt Holly.

I like Liz Keifer as an actress, but I don't think she was right for Blake. There was a through line between Dennehy and Stringfield, but Keifer felt like a completely different character. Blake lost so much verve.  It reminded me of Barbara Crampton taking over as Mindy. She's a fantastic actress, but she was not right for Mindy. 

53 minutes ago, P.J. said:

I actually thought the timing for recasting Blake worked. Both as a soft reset for the character and a fitting end for Stringfield. Sherri deserved to play that climax after all her hard work. And honestly, I'm not sure I could've ever believed her falling in love with Ross knowing she set it up to hurt Holly.

I think Sherry had already believably played Blake falling in love with Ross, but I would agree what they did with the character afterward wouldn't have suited her.