Jump to content

Y&R: Week of June 8, 2009


Recommended Posts

  • Members

I think it's pretty obvious now that Mary Jane is Patty Williams (not a spoiler, just from watching). However, if you were a non-online viewer do you think it would be quite that obvious?

In other news, where is everyone seeing all this character propping, plot driven, and agenda driven writing? The only time I notice that is with Tyra/slightly Fishers, but the Winters are rarely on as it is. Is it because you don't like the character or story, that there must be some crazy agenda from TPTB behind it?

Other than that, overall good week. Minus the silly art stuff, and I can't see MAB making it reliquary since she HATED everything LML did (plus it was acknowledged on the show). Standouts this week for me were Elizabeth Hendrickson and Stacy Haiduk.

I hope the discussions for next week here are less depressing tho, or else I'm pulling a brimike and checking out too (not making a big thing out of it, just saying).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 785
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

With Lily, I am talking about the writing not the acting. Lily is written as someone with a good heart & good intentions. If CK fails to bring that to the screen, that's a different story. Also, during the days of the Billy/Lily/Cane triangle, we always knew that Lily's heart belonged to Cane. With Sharon/Nick/Phyllis, who the hell knows? It changes every second. Fidelity of the heart is even more important than physical fidelity in a romantic story. This is romance basics 101 -- and it's been this way since the first romantic stories were crafted and song/told by the first storytellers. People forgave Isolde for cheating on Mark because her true heart belonged to Tristan. Y&R's writing team's need to be "sophisticated" means the show is just a daytime version of Melrose place -- Fickle Lovers and Crazy Crazies. The fans and the legacy of Bill Bell deserve better than that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Except that this is really a bad comparison. True, Melrose had tons of couples and triangles and quadrangles and what not. But the writers made you buy it all and you believed pretty much every pairing. Amanda was first in love with Man No. 1 - you believed it, Man No. 2 - you believed that, too... And so on.

Here... Atrocious "storytelling" and romances. Atrocious. Completely shallow and artificial.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Well, MP was... Fun. When it was good, it was gooood, when it was bad, it was baaad. It had tons of problems on its own, but couples and love intrigue was one of the better aspects of it.

Anyway, what I fail to grasp is: 1. Are these writers aware of how much these stories suck? Can someone be that blind or in that much denial? 2. If they are, and by they I mean Maria actually, why doesn't she get professional help? There's a vast universe of talented writers who would accept the job and make her life easier. Why is it so difficult to admit Hey, I'm wrong, This isn't going well and try to rectify things... Apparently, one of the reasons might be that some fans are happy with the show. But given certain Maria's and Hogan's and Scott's tendencies, one just has to be realistic and ask: how much longer before this train plummets even further? This whole it's good for two months and bad in the next four roller coaster ride is terribly annoying and will eventually become too frustrating leading to tune outs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

She has to be in serious denial to think any storyline involving art would be interesting to viewers....

And people rationalizing this storyline because Deacon, a character that only has ties to Amber and is such a B&B character, might come on this show? :lol:

Why do I care about Deacon when longtime vets are being asked to take paycuts and might be written off?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members
Which fans are happy outside of Nelson Branco and the 5 or 6 suck-ups at Daytime Confidential? Nearly every Y&R board has been fairly down the show. The ratings after trending up are now trending down. And I'm one of the fans who can find some bright spots on the show. Y&R is good compared to other soaps but it's certainly not the show it can or should be.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • @DeeVee Claire is a perfect example. So many women came to Springfield as competent, smart, and talented professionals. Then they’d attract a so-called “good guy,” get dumped, and spiral into complete chaos. What always strikes me is how clearly it plays like a male fantasy—yet it was written and sold to a female audience.
    • I just watched some parts of an episode of GL where Roger has just been shot by Holly. Rita then admits to Hillary that Roger raped her. Kasdorf is such a fantastic actress. I wish there were more of her work available. 
    • -- Alex Alegria has almost a full sleeve tattoo on one arm and a large tatt on one pec. I see no indication that the show is covering up his ink,
    • Didn't Carrie2 even seduce a minor? Ick. Oh, yeah, and she even tried to seduce Alan, but this was his post-prison era when he was trying to prove to everyone he had changed. It's funny that of all people he didn't go for it. Wait. Josh had an affair with Vanessa? Or she just thought he did? I know people always say "it's just a soap" but the way mental illness is portrayed on soaps (and that goes for pretty much all of them) has always been not great, especially PPD. They practically turned Claire into The Joker. She also was trying to seduce men. (I notice that now Mary Ryan Munisteri is listed as co HW with Ryder in the 1986 episodes, Claire has calmed down a lot. Never thought her GL career was very good but seems like she tried to course correct that a bit).
    • sss Ms. Tunie is a goddess. I feel all the anger, pride, sadness, arrogance, dignity, fear, love, and other emotions in everything she does as Anita.
    • You're right. People like me who stuck with her, did so because of her history. The show just skated her along with no story,  no goal, no aim. Right again! This is who I forgot before. When you describe her, it makes me appreciate her more. Thinking back I loved Mandy.
    • Maybe Guza is becoming Y&R Head writer and Jilly will be named EP! Remember CBS installed Latham as consultant and later Mal Young, both of whom took over the show. Of course, they each got credit during the consulting days.
    • Don't forget Carrie, who as Carrie2 was screwing everything in pants, and PPD Reva, who to either get back at Josh for his supposed affair with Vanessa (or just to prove she's more desirable than Van) tries to screw half the male population.
    • Post-production isn't exactly akin to sweeping the floors, but it makes more sense given her CV.  And, it would invalidate any concerns that she has an undo influence on the creative process, as opposed to visual and sound design of the show.  In fact, given her interests, it makes sense that she would want to consult and see the impact of newer technology in a post-production facility.  I could only imagine how much has changed in sound technology since she worked on SB, and that might be intriguing to utilize. As well as their impending move (not as soon as B&B, but we all know it will happen) and helping set up post-production at the new facility. 
    • The last five or so episodes of season 8 after the Jean Hackney story ended were pretty strong with the Laura/Val friendship breakdown, Ben's PTSD with Val trying to help him, and the start of Jill realizing that Val was as much of a threat to her happiness with Gary as Abby was. I always thought that the Jean Hackney story should have ended at mid season at the latest... and then deal with the fall-out because seeing Ben/Val switch roles with Ben in mental decline instead of Val would have been interesting to explore.  And seeing Val and Laura's friendship suffer also was interesting and should have been explored especially with Karen caught in the middle and Abby both intrigued and amused at the conflict that she didn't cause. However, season 8 was the only Latham run season where Val was well written.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy