Jump to content

American Idol: Discussion Thread


Toups

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 138
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

My rankings. Mariah Carey night was surprisingly too me, a good thing, much better than the 2 Beatles nights, especially the 2nd one, and the Dolly Parton and inspirational song week.

(1) David Cook-----by far, the best. He's definitely the most talented. He'll make a great solo artist and/or lead of rock band, and a great record producer as well. He shocked me with his rock ballad version of "Always Be My Baby"

(2) Carly Smithson-----Again, Carly does awesomely well, and yet again that [!@#$%^&*] untalented prick Simon Cowell disses her. What the hell does he have against her? I guess he's afraid if he brags on her his little teen crush David Archuleta might get kicked out of being in the Final 2. She did great on "Without You", Paula's right, she made it her own.

(3) Syesha Mercado----Again, Simon's wrong. She did awesome on "Vanishing". One of her best performances.

(4) Kristy Lee Cook-----I'm shocking myself putting the once-hated-by-me Kristy Lee this high. I agree with Mariah, that I liked her "Forever" better than Mariah's and think that she'll make a good country singer.

My Bottom 3:

(5) Jason Castro----Thought his "I Don't Wanna Cry" was pretty good.

(6) David Archuleta----The little a$$hole did a very predictable song, "When You Believe", but sucked in comparison to Mariah & Whitney. I don't get why Simon & Randy keep licking his ass. They seem to be struck on him, moreso than Paula, especially Simon.

(7) Brooke White-----she was horrible on "Hero", no feeling, pitchy, whiney, not much of a tune to it. It's time for Brooke to go.

I predict though the Bottom 3 will end up Brooke, Jason & Carly .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I agree about David Cook. What did Mariah say about him? I missed that part. Carly was ok. I dont see why you love her so much Mulder. :P;) Mercado was good. Kristy Cook was good and surprised me. I think Simon didnt want to give her credit. What is with all the love with Castro? I dont think he is that great. He has a good voice but all his songs sound the same. He tries to win over the crowd with his eyes and facial expressions. I am getting tired of David A....his song wasnt that good. Did Brooke White sing ..Without You??? I thought it was a different song. :unsure:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Well Tuesdays show was pretty good. Brooke and David Archuleto were both pitchy and a bit breathy.I agree with u Mulder that the judges should not have kissed up to Archuleto. He was ok..but not great..they made him out to be GREAT. I thought Kristy was damn good..and what do u know..she got sent home!! Looks like Brooke or Syesha will be next.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Brooke really needs to go. This is the second time she freakin stopped and started over.

David A. totally butchered a classic song. HATED IT.

David C. totally blew the roof off. LOVED it.

Bottom Two:

Brooke

Jason

Predictions:

Brooke will go home, Jason has too many tweens voting for him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I don’t recall MSW having a toy line in the late 80’s or early 90’s like all those Saturday morning cartoons did LOL but thought this was cute when I saw it in a vintage toy store yesterday:   

      Please register in order to view this content

    • https://www.instagram.com/p/DJgLSQsJf8s/ 1995 Daytime Emmys, Oprah Winfrey presenting Best Show which goes to GH, their 3rd win, Wendy Riche, EP, accepting:  Thank you, members of the academy, for recognizing our hard work. I feel very privileged to accept this very prestigious award on behalf of the cast, crew & staff of General Hospital. It's been a long time coming & everyone here & in Los Angeles is very proud to be honored by you. When so many people come together without ego in collaboration while maintaining their own  personal integrity ... Teamwork is not just a word at General Hospital, it's a way of life & I'm very grateful to be working with all these people. This year was "BJ's Heart" & other winners included Rena Sofer for Best Supporting Actress & the Writing Team with Claire Labine accepting & JJ won for Younger Actor & it just so happened that it was Tony & Genie who were presenting. 
    • https://www.instagram.com/p/DJgLSQsJf8s/ 1995 Daytime Emmys, Oprah Winfrey presenting Best Show which goes to GH, their 3rd win, Wendy Riche, EP, accepting:  Thank you, members of the academy, for recognizing our hard work. I feel very privileged to accept this very prestigious award on behalf of the cast, crew & staff of General Hospital. It's been a long time coming & everyone here & in Los Angeles is very proud to be honored by you. When so many people come together without ego in collaboration while maintaining their own  personal integrity ... Teamwork is not just a word at General Hospital, it's a way of life & I'm very grateful to be working with all these people.
    • Copying and pasting pasting this here as to not to derail the KL thread lol Wow I forgot CBS actually did try multiple attempts to come up with a soapy replacement for Knots on Thursday nights in the 10/9 slots for the 93-94 season.   Angel Falls had promise but CBS didn’t give it a fair chance. Latham’s Second Chances got even worse ratings than Angel Falls and wasn’t given a second chance when the Northridge quake destroyed the show’s sets. One West Waikiki looked gorgeous but was a blink you missed it affair. Finally we got Hotel Malibu, a quasi follow-up to Second Chances that stayed as the summer replacement series it was. CBS switched gears and had Chicago Hope air in the slot…against ER. It made the Top 30 but obviously underperformed below expectations. CBS gave up, and gave us 48 Hours for years there. It wasn’t until the 2002-03 season when CBS finally produced a Top 20 show for that spot with Without A Trace against an aging ER.
    • Of course I join in on wishing that Peacock & Corday & Sony would all together come to the conclusion that NOW would be a fine time to put some of these gems in the archive on full display!!! But, at the same time I'd like to give kudos to the fact that behind the scenes they've been doing the great work of preservation by taking tapes, etc. & converting them to modern digital formats. Besides the important fact of preserving them it means they are ready to go!
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Bill and Hayley’s living room set should be redressed as their bedroom. We’ve not seen their gorgeous circular entry way set since the first week? Why not utilise that more and build them a living room off those double doors? The hotel room also doesn’t have a bed? Does only Dani have a bedroom?    
    • as posted upthread, this interview was on that channel's youtube   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YLraEMlqtTw
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy