Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

ALL: What Characters Have Been Ruined That They Should Never Return

Featured Replies

  • Member

I know in recent months there have been talks in several threads about characters that you would want to return to your show, and there has been some talk of some who you wouldn't want to see back. I just wanted to do a thread of characters you never want to see return to your show because you think they have been ruined by the current regime or one in the past. Please remember everyone that this is a matter of opinion, and not all answers are going to be popular ones.

AMC:

Janet Dillon: I think that MMT ruined her this go around. All that the Robin Mattson years were able to create for the chance to return to that. Having her murder Trevor whatever the reason was went way too far. Shame that Kate Collins is such a wonderful performer, but she should never come back as Janet.

ATWT:

James Stenbeck: The last few times he has come back were so badly done. It is time for a new generation of Stenbecks and I think that is being done very well with Paul. I just wish James' other son would come back and give Paul a run for his money. And Craig is a wonderful villian with a broader range of folks to mess with. Craig has a reason still to mess with so many in town, and James doesn't.

Days:

Stefano & Tony DiMera: I know many want both of them back, but the cartoon villian years exist, and can't be wiped away. They are put of what the character is and was. To bring them back and write them differently will not erase them. You would have to wipe away years of storytelling by saying that it wasn't them who did such things, and that would rank up there with Dallas' dream season. To me it is best to move on with a new generation of DiMera's and return the DiMera family to the original form it was - thus reestablishing the family's reputation.

Jan Spears: I know many are excited about the possibility of her return too. But I hated her last return. She was way to over the top. She was lots better before. But that last return ruined the character for me.

GH:

Rick Webber: which he can't because they killed him off. But his short stint back on the show with this new created history ruined one of my favorite characters of all time.

Holly Sutton Scorpio: another rewrite of the history of a character for a plot stunt. Holly reformed herself and became a wonderful heroine during her run on the show. Then 2 short stints erases all of what she became and turned her back into a cold heartless woman.

Heather Webber: again a new story and past were created for her. I love Robin Mattson but the character of Heather should stay gone forever

OLTL:

Victor Lord: Please don't bring him back and create more unknown history for this overused character. He is an original character to the show but I think has had more to do with the show after his death than before.

Mitch Lawrence: This is a great character but he needs to stay gone forever.

Carlo Hesser: Same as the above 2. He has been ruined for plot reasons with this current regime. He should just stay gone.

  • Replies 24
  • Views 753
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member

Y&R

SHEILA

  • Member

OLTL: John McBain. Just fumigate already!

And now I go off to the Michael Easton website to tell him how much I hate him and how his presence has destroyed OLTL.

It's an internet evening constiutional. ;)

  • Member
Jan Spears: I know many are excited about the possibility of her return too. But I hated her last return. She was way to over the top. She was lots better before. But that last return ruined the character for me.

Hm...I kind of agree and kind of don't. I have never hated anything that Jan has done. I absolutely love the character, one of the best in daytime IMO (that's why I have a site for her). Although I was entertained by the Cage story and impressed with Heather Lindell, it was also kind of a let-down. I loved the evolution that Jan had when Heather Olson was playing her-- she went from snob to helpless victim to conniving [!@#$%^&*] to obsessed stalker. When Heather Lindell took over she all of a sudden went 100% bonkers. When Jan was stalking Shawn and Belle when she returned in 2003, I was so excited because I thought she would be a key player with the killings and Nicole...and she was at first. But then they ruined it with that cage thing and made it VERY hard to redeem the character. That being said, no matter what JAn does, I will ALWAYS want her back at days!

  • Member

the evolution of Jan ... LMFAO!! Did she ever stop being Waste of Space girl? She was especially pathetic being Belle's nemesis for Shawn. Even Kristen Storms deserved better than that poodle-haired twit!

  • Member
the evolution of Jan ... LMFAO!! Did she ever stop being Waste of Space girl? She was especially pathetic being Belle's nemesis for Shawn. Even Kristen Storms deserved better than that poodle-haired twit!

To each his own I guess. I never found Jan to be a waste of space. In fact, I stopped watching in 2005 when she went into a coma and only recently started up again a few months ago.

  • Member

Jan Spears was a comlete joke, more than the DiMeras. She should've never been brought back in 03 as a major character. When they sent her off in 02 after graduation, that should've been the end of the line for the character. The rape/miscarriage/reunion with her mother finally redeemed the character from her obnoxious days in Salem High and the character was done. But of course, JER has to always bring back the worthless characters and make them into complete psychos. She wasn't even a good psycho. She was a one-note, Shawn obsessed, Belle hating [!@#$%^&*] and I'm so glad JER's gone and we don't have to go through Jan Spears Part 2 with her being the gloved hand.

  • Member

OLTL: I wouldn't want to see anybody return under this current regime - not even Colin MacIver, but I do think that Carlo could be saved under another production -- and was left alive. As much mayhem as Mitch could stir up, he's better left dead, as is Victor Lord. There's only so many times one can bring back a dead character.

After having watched DeVry for a few minutes on B & B, it'd be difficult to write MC back in, but he'd certainly stir up trouble with brother Zach, daughter Miranda and mom Bianca, hence the whole Kane/Montgomery clans. It'd be far better soap than AMC currently. Madden however should NEVER come back.

  • Member
Jan Spears was a comlete joke, more than the DiMeras. She should've never been brought back in 03 as a major character. When they sent her off in 02 after graduation, that should've been the end of the line for the character. The rape/miscarriage/reunion with her mother finally redeemed the character from her obnoxious days in Salem High and the character was done. But of course, JER has to always bring back the worthless characters and make them into complete psychos. She wasn't even a good psycho. She was a one-note, Shawn obsessed, Belle hating [!@#$%^&*] and I'm so glad JER's gone and we don't have to go through Jan Spears Part 2 with her being the gloved hand.

*sigh* Fine, fine. I get it. You hate Jan :(

  • Member

Well someone who is ruined, but should have NEVER returned is Dixie on AMC, worst return ever IMO.

  • Member
Well someone who is ruined, but should have NEVER returned is Dixie on AMC, worst return ever IMO.

You are DEFINATELY right about that. I think they should've kept Di as the real Dixie. That would've made for a better character IMO.

  • Member
After having watched DeVry for a few minutes on B & B, it'd be difficult to write MC back in, but he'd certainly stir up trouble with brother Zach, daughter Miranda and mom Bianca, hence the whole Kane/Montgomery clans. It'd be far better soap than AMC currently. Madden however should NEVER come back.

I'd have loved it, if they could have found a way to get William DeVry back on AMC. Even as a lookalike cousin or something. I so love the Cambias family, moreso than the Lavery's and Carey's. The Cambias family had so much potential but McTrash blew it of course.

You are DEFINATELY right about that. I think they should've kept Di as the real Dixie. That would've made for a better character IMO.

I would have loved that! I love Di as she is though, they should have just left Dixie dead.

  • Member

Whats with all the Jan hate? I disagree, Jan should by all means return, she is one of my favorite characters of Days ever, and I loved her with BOTH actresses in the role and don't care which one plays her, I just want the woman back! She was one of the few good things JER ever did.

Now anyways....

Days:

Andre Dimera: Even though I brought him back in my blog, I don't want him back on the real show, if they ever make Tony Andre again, don't have Andre be on screen. He had potential... but he was pretty much ruined.

Mimi Lockhart: Know she is not gone yet, but she is exiting in Feburary, she was ruined when she came into the Shawn/Belle/Philip thing, I mean I have just gotten sick of her, she is annoying and along with bad acting it is just a flat out bad character. Once she is gone I hope she is gone for GOOD!

  • Member
Whats with all the Jan hate? I disagree, Jan should by all means return, she is one of my favorite characters of Days ever, and I loved her with BOTH actresses in the role and don't care which one plays her, I just want the woman back! She was one of the few good things JER ever did.

If you say so.

  • Member
Whats with all the Jan hate? I disagree, Jan should by all means return, she is one of my favorite characters of Days ever, and I loved her with BOTH actresses in the role and don't care which one plays her, I just want the woman back! She was one of the few good things JER ever did.

YAY! I knew you'd stick up for her! lol

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.