I know, in watching for the first time in the past couple of years, the over-saturation of Cruz & Eden is what's kept me from returning to watch, among other creative decisions being made.
On paper, much like the hiring of Terry Lester as Mason, Eileen Davidson should have worked as Kelly Capwell. However, unlike Lester, she was miscast. But she did the best she could. Casting out Carrington Garland was a huge misstep for the return of the Dobson, and again proves my point: their choice of castings was always their biggest flaw for me, stemming back to the recasting of Santana Andrade. But they clearly wanted to "age" Kelly a bit, due to the absence of Marcy Walker's Eden, and the end result was... disappointing. Plus, their decision to pair Cruz with Kelly lended itself into the recast. Shame.