Jump to content

Big Brother 17: Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Members

Gag to the hickey on Liz's neck... Liz/Julia/Austin needed to be split up...

 

Vanessa's whining is like nails on a chalkboard...Time to go...yesterday

 

John's Bobcat Goldthwait impression is very annoying...Oh wait, it's just his voice...Yikes!! Imagine having him talking like that during a dental visit...

He threw the veto, and look what it got him.  Why did they not get rid of "I'm so lonely" Vanessa....UGH!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 116
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • 3 weeks later...
  • Members

I'm just glad James won America's Favorite.

I'm kinda with you Cheap, I do believe if she had won the final HOH or w/e she would have won. But sometimes I gotta think like... you based your whole game on "honesty."  I'm not going to love that because I love some of the more unapologetic players of BB past that have won the show.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Vanessa was a train wreck but she deserved to win. Naturally the awful Ian clone won. Steve was such a mess. I never liked him as much as some seemed to. I'm usually all for quirky and weird but he was just a bit much for me and the game was too much for him. I never knew where he was or what he was doing. Ehh. Could have been worse I guess.

 

I didn't participate much at all in the discussion of the show or the live feeds but, for the most part, I really did like this season. It was better than 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 for me. Honestly. It was. The cast was entertaining, there was strategy ... I think had Battle of the Block not been there, it could have played out even better. I'd also like to see Audrey, Da'Vonne, Jason, Shelli, James, Johnny Mac (maybe), Vanessa and even Meg all play again. So that says something. I think the casting, while still falling into old patterns, at least gave us some personalities.

 

It was a good season, despite the Liz/Julia/Austin/Vanessa/Steve ugh-yuck alliance managing to take back over the endgame and dominate. I mean, good for them. I just hated losing so many interesting players so early on. I also think James fell asleep for a few weeks there after the Clay/Shelli ousters, and he got too comfortable with Austwins.

 

And even those players I didn't "love" I didn't HATE like in past years and never want to see again. I mean, I'd take Liz, Austin and Steve again over GinaMarie, Spencer and Andy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I think he was cast to be Ian but I don't think he ever was. He wasn't as likeable, but he also didn't just comp whore - he had to depend on others to help him stay, more game relationships, and so on. It's one of the reasons I was fine with him winning, because they had their chance and they kept him around.

 

Vanessa was the best player of the three, but her social game was so poor that she had to save herself through competitions. She wasn't able to get people who would take her to the end. If she'd been as good as the hype, then she would have managed it. I have to admit seeing her get third after so many had assumed she'd win made me laugh, as did her voting for Liz for girl power, even though Liz would have and repeatedly did dump her for Austin many times. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • @Ryanc2 Welcome -you've got a lot of catching up to do! We talk about Derek/Ashley, but how much do we really know about Naomi/Jacob apart from they have a bedroom set to make out in? Maybe more time needed to be spent in the first months establishing them better-(give them a proper set for a start) as well as the Bill/Ted dynamic and other familial relationships and ditch Hayley/Derek altogether or make them supporting/talk to for Jacob/Naomi.   
    • I’m glad we’ve spent enough time with the character to know how shed Brooke Logan her way through this.
    • Felicia becomes more layered/balanced in the early 90s (circa 1991/1992/1993).   She leans more into the more down to earth element that you like, while still being Felicia of the 80s.  The process starts in 1989.. but doesn't really become apparent until the early 90s.   Iris was the rare connector character with her having a role at the hospital (I think she's on the board), working at Cory Publishing, and having romantic flirtations/connections with a lot of the male characters between 1988 and 1994.  Which resulted in her having interactions with the other female contemporaries (Donna, Felicia, Rachel) even if the three didn't always interact with one another. Writing her off in the fall of 1994 severed one of the main connections/bridges with the different orbits.  Irony that the show didn't see her value.
    • Which is why I feel that when they do introduce that family it will more than likely be Jacob's family. Otherwise why establish them slowly but surely?
    • ROFL.  priceless.   There are also countless mentions how wonderful Claire is, but I could not stomach watching a compilation of that!
    • The air...is looooooooooong gone.  
    • From what I remeber reading, it seemed as if it all completely falls apart post-Labine and Mayer around a year later when Ben is sent to prison around June 1976. Ben's departure undoes one of the major story threads that had carried the show for many months. Without a catalyst of Ben's ilk in the wings, there wasn't much to carry either story for the two women (Betsy and Arlene). Arlene was briefly paired in a one-sided attraction with Ray before becoming involved with Ian Russell. I believe the Schneiders introduced Ian as a suave businessman interested in Arlene who was also considering a dalliance with Meg. That would have been delightful but Upton arrives and quickly shifts the narrative to Arlene as a kept woman / prostitute (though I only think she was sleeping with Ian, but maybe I'm wrong).  I think it is Upton who transitioned Ben from complicated heel with a romantic appeal to a tortured, brooding romantic lead with a complicated past. I'm not sure that was the smartest move. Upton must have believed that Ben's near rape was his redemption arc, but I don't think it was enough. There is something deliciously wicked about Ben becoming involved with Mia after the death of Mia's stepson Jim Marriott, who had confessed his love for Mia before racing off on his motorbike and being hit by Ben's car. I could see the appeal, but I don't think it completely worked.  There should have been an angle involving Betsy (who had been a reporter I think when she first appeared) investigating Jim Marriott's accident, possibly with Jamie Rolins who was I believe district attorney. Betsy and Ben growing closer as Betsy grows closer to the truth. Ben confiding in Mia as Andrew continues to make Ben his surrogate son setting in motion the same dramatic situation with Andew's second wife being in love with his son/surrogate son.  I think Betsy and Jamie Rollins were together while Ben was in prison, but I don't think they had much to do. I may be wrong. Meg should have gone after custody making it seem like Jamie and/or Betsy were unfit leading to a case with social services which would have brought Diana Lamont back into the mix causing emotional angst for Diana as she works with Jamie to provide him the child she couldn't.  The Felicia / Eddie / Charles stuff seems rather generic once you get to Charles' paralysis and sexual dysfunction. Felicia's pregnancy and her death seemed to bring an end to a story that really wasn't strong enough to be frontburner. The Lynn Henderson stuff always seems rather movie of the week rather than developed for an ongoing story.  In the past, I agreed that it might have been possible that the story had become so disjointed that they needed to freshen up and add new story elements as Upton did but others have suggested that the elements themselves should have just been considered.   For example, I'm not a huge proponent of Rick and Cal as a couple, but I do think there was some mileage of actually reintroducing Barbara into the mix trying to reconnect with Hank, carrying a torch for Rick, causing conflict in the Sterlings marriage with Bruce and Van taking sides over Barbara vs. Cal, and Barbara maneuvering her way into the Beaver Ridge Complex making her business partners with Rick and Meg, which would give her a new rival.  When Ben returned, there should have been a question of how true his redemption was rather than just jumping in head first to a new role.  I think the Schneiders might have been script writers for Ann Marcus on "Search for Tomorrow," but I may be wrong on that.  Upton introduced the Marriotts in Janaury, 1977. Christian Marlowe's Andy Marriott seemed to be in the mold of Ben. I don't know if the story was any good, but I think Upton towards the end hinted an Andrew / Meg / Andy storyline which I thought would have been interesting. I think Upton had some interesting concepts, but from my understand, the execution was awful. 
    • Is there a new drinking game I don't know about?
    • But... the air of mystery and intrigue as they say it...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy