American Idol

[KMan101]

I seriously started jumping up and down! I felt bad to see Kellie go, cause at times she is adorable, but she was the least abled singer left.

Paris will go next week, no doubt about that. I would be STUNNED to see her last further, although I do like her.

And no it wasn't the first time they did the top two crap. They did it last year with Carrie and Bo and by that point I knew one of them would win it.

It reminds me of last season's final six when Constacrap was voted off. It was him, Vonzell and Anthony in the bottom three and then Vonzell was safe leaving him and Anthony and then BAM. Constacrap was gone!

Final six on American Idol has always been good.

S1: Christina Christian booted

S2: Carmen Rasumussen booted

S3: John Stevens booted

S4: Constacrap Maroulis booted

S5: Kellie Hackler booted

Hallaleujah!

And come on Mike... give Katharine her props! Why do you dislike her so much? She's far from the worst we've seen.

[Gray Bunny]

Gotta agree with King Reilly... Katherine is very blah to me. I just don't get excited about her performances and to me there isn't anything unique or special about the sound of her voice.

Thank God Kellie's gone! There was a two-week period back before it was the top 12 that I liked her and then I quickly grew annoyed by her. I'm glad to see America got it right and voted her off instead of Paris first. It looks like my highschool friend's website, VotefortheWorst.com didn't pull through enough for Kellie cuz she outta here!

Whoo hoo! Chris is one of the top 2! I bet that's one of the reasons why there was a record number of votes this week... People who saw Chris in the bottom 3 last week came out in full force and voted for him.

[KMan101]

Everyone's entitled to their opinion but Katharine blah and boring? Please.

And I wasn't surprised at all by Katharine and Chris getting the top two. Obviously there's something about Katharine that is getting people to vote her. With Katharine getting UNFAIRLY bashed by Simon and Randy (Simon NEVER apologizes), I bet that prompted people to really vote hard for her and same for Chris after seeing him so damn close to going last week.

One of them's gonna win, I really do believe that and I bet it is Chris. I've been saying CHris since the beginning. Elliot could pull out a surprise win (which I would LOVE LOVE LOVE cause he is spectacular). I don't see Taylor winning, though I guess he could. Paris has no shot.

[King]

She does have a good voice. A great voice. But she's not outstanding. I don't know why everyone goes on about her like she's the best thing since sliced bread slash Kelly C. She's not.

1. I think she's just so phony and fake. Her fake smiles all the time? *Vom.* I know that's just speculation, but that's my gut, and it's my opinion, and I'm entitled. So, HA!

2. She doesn't have the IT factor or the X-Factor.

3. She's not unique to me, at all.

4. I think she's overrated.

Also, Ryan never told us who the middle group, and highest group were. We're assuming that Chris and Kat were the top two. And we're probably right, but we could be wrong. Especially, with all of the records being broken last night, Elliot fans could have come out in spades to save him. He could have been in the top two. Lord knows he deserved it!

[R!ck]

And DialIdol was right once again...

Taylor Hicks - safe

Chris Daughtry - safe

Katharine McPhee - Possible B3

Elliott Yamin - Possible B3

Kellie Pickler - Predicted to be booted

Paris Bennett - Predicted to be booted

[PhoenixRising05]

Actually KR he did say. When Kellie/Paris and Chris/Kat were standing next to him he said one of them is the top group and one is the bottom and then when Kat/Chris were sent back he said they were the top group.

Kat is not unique but it is a singing competition and she has really the best vocals other then Elliot. Elliot just won't get there though-the fanbase isn't there for him or Paris. Taylor is the only threat to a Chris/Kat final which would be almost like last year's final with a rocker and a female pop singer (well Carrie was country but whatever). Chris should win but if its down to him and Kat I can totally see a repeat of last year and one of those good old AI tearful moments where she gives an emotional performance to end the night and wins it. I do think its Chris's to lose.

I see why you dislike her KR. She isn't the best (nowhere close to Carrie and Kelly) but the vocals and look are there. She is born to perform and sing and she does have some sort of factor that is likable. I just can't see her not being up there with Chris. I have felt that way all along that it should be those two at the end and once Mandisa left I felt secure about that. It seems like what happened to Carrie is happening to Kat. She has great vocals but there are many that don't like her and we all know how that ended up last year .

[alwaysAMC]

I couldn't watch tonight, but i hear Kellie got kicked off - YES! she butchered her song last night. So happy to hear this - wish i could have seen them cut her off.

[OneLife Fan]

Bye bye to Kellie. I liked her...she was ok..but not a great singer. I sure the hell didnt want her to win Idol..but i do like her. She actually held it together tonight. No crying for her.

[kentville]

Thank God Kellie's gone!! I also think Katherine's a good singer, but I don't really care for her. I don't think she's all that. I'm hoping the top two are either Taylor and Chris, or Taylor and Elliot.

[Bree]

There is a God!

Fake country bumpkin is GONE!!! America finally woke up and got rid of that phony hillbilly. Good riddance!

[JERSoapsFan]

-->

Katherine was excellent last night, I'm so glad Simon and Randy apologized! I just hope she doesn't go home. Now that Chris is finally singing instead of screaming those Heavy Metal songs, I'm starting to like him. He was great this week. Paris I know has a decent voice, but I think she oversings everything and is very annoying. I don't like her at all. Unpopular I think. Kellie is just painfully bad, but I could see her being a big success based on her looks and the fact that she CAN sing well enough to put out a good pop album.

OMG, I hate my life! I missed it! I slept right through the results show and woke up just in time for teh 9 'oclock news to find out that Kellie got booted!

Someone PLEASE tell me where I can find a transcript or YouTube video of last night's show. I'm dying to see Simon and Randy's apology to Katherine, Kellie's "Bad Day" montage and her final bow!!! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE.>>??

[MzHuggable]

for a hundred bucks i'll send you the dvd

[KMan101]

JSF, go here: http://television.aol.com/franchise/top5.adp

Kellie's elimination should be on there. That's all I could find but I didn't search MyTube.

I TiVo'd that [!@#$%^&*] last night and watched over and over again Kellie getting eliminated. I know that's mean, but LOL, I was just all convinced Paris would go.

[OneLife Fan]

Chris or Taylor has to win!!

[tina m]

I was crossing my fingers that Paris would go, obviously Kellie didn't do very well, but still. I AM glad to know that Chris and Kat got the 2 highest votes.