Um...not sure:

I know:

Lisa - 1st Singer

Kellie: 2nd Singer

Ace: 3rd Singer

Lisa- Do not EVER try to sing a Kelly Clarkson song that was THAT big of a hit. She might be gone...

Kellie- She doesn't have the greatest vocals, and I agree with the judges, she could have chosen a better song than that..but I still love her.

Ace- Ok..I guess I'm the only one, I really liked him. I absolutely LOVE Drops of Jupiter so I enjoyed it. And I guess I'm also the only one who thinks he's actually cute...

Taylor- LOVE my Taylor. He was good tonight, and I agree with Paula, as much as I love the silly, fucked-up-dancing Taylor, I like to just see him stand behind the mic and just SING a song. He's great.

Mandisa- I love that song, but she wasn't AMAZING. She's good.

Chris- I don't like that song..like AT all...and he could have picked a MUCH better one..I still love him, but tonight's def. wasn't my favorite performance of his..or best vocals.

Katharine- I LOVE Kat. She is an amazing singer, and I loved her performance, she looked beautiful also.

Paris- Oh. My. God. What the hell. She totally gets on my last nerve. Quit the nasty ass ass-shakin and [!@#$%^&*]. I mean damn...

Bucky- Holy [!@#$%^&*]. He's disgusting..and to sing THAT song? Tim McGraw is so [!@#$%^&*] sexy, HE has the right to sing that song..but not Bucky. Sorry, but he just can't make anything sexy...because he's just ..not. And he really wasn't that good vocally either...

Elliot- I love my man Elliot. He's always good, and he has a great voice. I liked that he didn't sing that song exactly like Gavin does.

I agree KR. That is why I have liked Simon the last two years. The last 2 years Randy and Paula have become so annoying and contradictory. Paula looks like she is drunk or high half the time (and that comment to Ace tonight showed her favoritism towards male contestants) and Randy doesn't know how to talk and doesn't even know what he says half the time. Simon at least tells it like it is and never contradicts himself. The truth hurts and Simon is usually always right, especially when picking the winner of the show at the beginning. He knows what he is talking about. The other two can go so we can get two new people in there that can give quality advice and critque rather then a load of crap.

Kellie annoys the hell out of me.

What did she do this time?

My personal rankings

1. Elloitt

2. Taylor

3. Katharine

4. Ace

5. Mandisa

6. Paris

7. Kellie

8. Lisa

9. Chris

10. Bucky

Bottom Three

Bucky, Lisa and I have a hunch there's gonna be a shocker (Katharine/Chris/Paris/Kellie)

Lisa goes bye bye

I agree KR. That is why I have liked Simon the last two years. The last 2 years Randy and Paula have become so annoying and contradictory. Paula looks like she is drunk or high half the time (and that comment to Ace tonight showed her favoritism towards male contestants) and Randy doesn't know how to talk and doesn't even know what he says half the time. Simon at least tells it like it is and never contradicts himself. The truth hurts and Simon is usually always right, especially when picking the winner of the show at the beginning. He knows what he is talking about. The other two can go so we can get two new people in there that can give quality advice and critque rather then a load of crap.

ITA with every word. Get those two people out of here!

What did she do this time?

Can you honestly say you do not see where the people who say Kellie is annoying is coming from? And if so, um, HOW?

I applaud Lisa's efforts. If that worked out, it definitely could have kept her going for a few weeks, IMO. But it didn't.

I'm just curious as to how you know this? I'm not doubting your word, I just wanted to know how you found out.

Well, you never really know if these things are true, but on the radio which I listen to every morning, the day after Idol they always discuss what went on, and they were saying that they heard that they met at an Idol backstage party and started talking and so on and so forth..but who knows. It's just a rumor..and you know what they usually say about those...

ITA with every word. Get those two people out of here!

Can you honestly say you do not see where the people who say Kellie is annoying is coming from? And if so, um, HOW?

Um, because I was asking how she annoyed that person TONIGHT. She did absolutely nothing tonight but sing her song. What is so wrong with that? I say, nothing.

Because she is annoying. The way she talks. What she says. Her whole act is tiresome.

Because she is annoying. The way she talks. What she says. Her whole act is tiresome.

Oh I see, she spoke tonight, said "I'm sorry" a few times..and man, that accent just makes you hate her right? I don't see an act. I honestly think she is just a dumbass. Which I find amusing. And that's why I like her.

Oh I see, she spoke tonight, said "I'm sorry" a few times..and man, that accent just makes you hate her right?

Honestly. Yeah. It does. I'm not trying to be a wise guy, but she really is just annoying to me. The whole package.

I don't see an act. I honestly think she is just a dumbass.

I don't think her being a dumbass is an act, but her accentuating it and exaggerating it is an act.

Or have you considered that maybe that is just how she actually is? Just because she may exaggerate everything she does, doesn't mean she's putting on an act. She could possibly always be like that. We will never know..but let's just agree to disagree..lol

All we have are our opinions and assumptions...so both of us could be wrong.

Yeah. We'll have to agree to disagree on Pickler.

I used to love "I Don't Wanna Be" when the only times I heard it was watching One Tree Hill. But then I stopped watching OTH, and then Gavid DeGraw took off and the songs was everywhere... Now I am annoyed by it

Pretty bad night, no one was at their best. The painful ones to hear were Kellie, Ace, ad Lisa. Ace was particularly hard to watch when he almost undressed and then his quivering innocent look at the end. Chris is definitely getting old. I am easily getting tired of his voice

God the Idols sucked tonight!

Katherine totally ruined Christina's song for me...

Elliot totally ruined Gavin's song for me....

Mandisa and Paris were prob. the best - most everyone else either sucked or were just so-so.

It really irritated me that the judges kept saying that Kellie was "better" than the Sara Evans song! "Suds In the Bucket" is a great song, Sara Evans certainly sings the heck out of it. Kellie started late or something too, like the music started and she seemed behind it the whole song.

I think Kellie is a nice girl, and I really don't think it's an act but I do think she was trying to be funny with the ballsy comment and it obviously didn't work.

And since when is Creed hard core?