Jump to content

Downton Abbey: Discussion Thread


Sylph

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 180
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I've seen him in a handful of plays in London, playing totally dissimilar characters in each one. He certainly enjoys expanding his range; he is a very good actor and is only going to get better and better as he ages. I loved him as Dennis Watts, so it is a credit to him that I rarely think of that character when he is playing someone else. Downton was a shock, though.

Here, some fans feel very betrayed by what has happened to Anna. They feel this maybe the sloppery slope for Downton towards sensationalism and even ruin! Maybe I have been inured by years of US Daytime, but I could only admire the actress's very relatable and visceral acting, and the bewildered reaction of lovely Bates (who loves her so tenderly!) and helplessness of Mrs. Hughes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Thank you! This is why I was so confused because of course I know Dirty Den... :P The actor was very good in Guys and Dolls.

Cat--I read some of the reaction (although it looks like the BBC is somewhat blowing it all up--maybe out of jealousy--as apparently they only got a few dozen complaints, not a huge amount really.) I can see why some may call it sensationalistic, but really, as Fellowes said, they didn't show the actual attack and as far as rape on tv (the UK or N America) goes it was remarkably restrained. Frankly, while a part of me is not so keen on the story if only because I feel like it will be more about poor Mr Bates' reaction, Downton this season did need *some* drama and something intense--the first two episodes were so, well, happy--yes even with all the gloomy Matthew mourning. :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

It's not technically a BBC show -- it is on ITV. But yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if this was some free advertising for the network which, Downton apart, is suffering in the ratings. However, I have read in the Radio Times (i.e.: voice of TV-watching Middle England) that DA is akin to a pair of comfortable slippers and a warm mug of cocoa on a Sunday night (when it is screened) and this is an aberration to what DA represents. People were just not expecting it. Some had tuned in, as opera fans, to see Dame Kiri Te Kanawa who was billed as the episode's special guest star.

The Great British Public are having a hard time reconciling this show as a soap (which it is, pretty much). With shows like Coronation Street, EE going to the rape well every now and then, viewers see this as a Corrie-style plot point by DA. And it besmirches DA for them because soaps are getting an increasingly bad press here for 'plumbing new depths in sensationalism' (I am paraphrasing, of course).

I think the brouhaha raises a wider question about how desensitized we are now to seeing rape on TV, to the point where people now believe it should be banished to soaps and the odd police procedural without thinking too much of it. sad.png Maybe it is a class thing, too. Most of the UK soaps are more working-class based/targeted. DA is firmly middle-class in terms of its target audience. Maybe there is a feeling that rape has been confined to the "underclasses"? You may think I am exaggerating but sometimes here, these unquestioned class attitudes linger and even thrive.

Personally, I thought the acting was excellent, and the initial reactions right after the rape judged very well (no talk about getting the police involved -- that's how rape was viewed, especially regarding the downstairs servants. Not so long before that, it was the Master's perogative to deflower a female servant the night before her wedding day!).

I do think the reaction is more heightened than when Matthew Crawley was killed off. I think everybody recognizes what a coup that has been for the character of Lady Mary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Oh you mis-read me (or more to the point, I wasn't clear.) I'm well aware it's on ITV, and it does seem--especially after Upstairs/Downstairs flopped, BBC is jealous they don't have the show. So many people (and I'm not sure I agree) feel that BBC is reporting so heavily on the "controversy" and blowing it out of proportion to make it look worse than it is.

I agree with everything else you say so well. I dunno though--I think early on Downton was known for having *some* shocks--and I actually felt the first two episodes were TOO much like "wearing a warm pair of slippers." It was becoming fairly samey/mindless. And yeah--this was the show that "ruined Christmas" last year, so I still find the reaction odd.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 6 months later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Oakland Tribune, 14 July 1985   AW is another show with Schenkel at helm By Connie Passalacqua For the most part, dictators of South American banana republics enjoy better reputations than executive producers of daytime soap operas. Total authority is vested in these producers, who can kill off a character (thus firing an actor) with a stroke of a pen, or completely change life in his or her soap opera dominion (both in its fictional locale and backstage at the studio) on any kind of whim.  Most rule despotically, inspiring fear in their actors and writers. Which inevitably surfaces on the screen and subtracts from a show's quality. Then there's Stephen Schenkel who became executive producer of Another World last fall. He's been described by one of his actresses as "a teddy bear." He has noticeably improved the show, mostly because his natural warmth encourages backstage cohesiveness, and he believes in personally nurturing his staff and cast. 'I like to be supportive', he said.' I like to generate a certain amount of enthusiasm. I love actors and writers and technical people. And I like to laugh..  ' Schenkel said that most of the factors that have led to the shows improved ratings existed before he took over. There were well defined characters, outstanding writers and excellent production values, he explains. 'These things were in place but needed to be stimulated. There wasn't a lot of excitement. What really was missing was an adequate story. We added Gillian Spencer as a writer. (she also plays Daisy on All My Children), who's wonderful, and it just coalesced. The writers energy and commitment to the show began to give it an emotional intensity and some real passion within the characters." Schenkel, a former ABC programming executive who helped develop Ryan's Hope, is a strong believer in stressing romantic and comedy elements in soap operas. AW is also one of the only soaps with an established group of comic characters, including Wallingford (Brent Collins) and Lily Mason (Jackee , Harry). Schenkel raves about the talents of all his actors, and even has something good to say about the Brooklyn location of the shows studio, which most of his Manhattan-oriented staff loathe. I like the people here. I like to walk down the street and feel their energies, he said. He also violateda soap opera no-no, ' inviting actors and writers to the same party. "Everyone got to know one another, he said. And I didn't get any complaints about actors ' begging for story lines, he said. 
    • Since it's pride month.

      Please register in order to view this content

         
    • National City Star-News, 5 May 1977 TV topics by Peter Blazi Lear’s ‘All that Glitters’—doesn’t The best thing that can be said about Norman Lear’s newest soap opera“All That Glitters” is that it comes on so late at night most people will miss it. Role reversal is supposed to be the big draw, with women the breadwinners, mainly executives of a huge conglomerate. The men either fuss with the housework or fidget at the office as secretaries to their bawdy bosses. A female fantasyland? I doubt it. While the role reversal idea has some possibilities, the show pushes too hard for laughs and winds up with raucous females and effete males. A confident, independent woman is indeed a sight to behold and attract, but femininity need not be sacrificed. Unlike Lear’s “Mary Hartman, Mary Hartman,” "Glitters” doesn’t, but you’ve got to give him credit for trying. Today’s experimental comedy is what tomorrow’s hits are made of. Better luck next time, Norman. (“All That Glitters” can be seen weekday evenings at 11 p.m. on Channel 6.) .
    • Actually Kim Zimmer got six weeks off to test the waters for pilot season in L.A. - she said later she went on many auditions and got one offer for a sitcom, but she would one of many in an ensemble. She turned it down, because it wasn't worth leaving Guiding Light for a supporting role on a sitcom. 
    • I'm not even sure why Zoe would care, even if they know each other offcamera.  I can't see Jean going, but if she is - good riddance at this point.
    • I just found the commercial on YouTube, with several other GL'ers doing the same commercial - how fun!

      Please register in order to view this content

        She did the same for me once Ghost Reva arrived (the anxiety and paranoia) - which is when the storyline for Rick/Annie started, with their Chicago past and her alcoholism. But before all that, when she was new and tending to Josh's broken leg, she was just normal, sweet and very cute/flirty. 
    • I have to admit Annie exhausted me somewhat before she went nuts. So much anxiety. She and Robert were OK I guess. Didn't ever stick out much one way or the other.
    • I meant to ask in the May thread, but hey...it's not like it won't come up...   ...has our opinions of Jessica changed at this point? I know we debated at one point if she was sincere in her feelings for Ty or if she was in on his bullying. Now that a little more time has passed, what do we think? 
    • Which is why I said...and continue to say mind you...that the designer is still trying to figure out what works for which character...highlight my points with particular characters. And as I also agree with you, too many misses. She has not found a clear, firm rhythm for me. Yet.   I also agree that BTG does a much better job. But I'll give credit where it's due. 
    • I watch many episodes from the Vault, a secret source here on SON, because the quality is much better than YouTube. But, it has commercials that I have to skip through, although even these commercials give me serious nostalgia vibes. All that said, there is a consistent 1996 commercial for Excedrin with Frank Beatty!  He talks right into the camera about his feelings, and it's like Brent Lawrence never left. I wonder if GL fans back in the day ever saw this and had feelings about it. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy