Jump to content

OLTL: Marty/John/Natalie


Recommended Posts

  • Members

'Honey.'

'You're.'

In this case, my definition would be over forty. I count Maggie, Kate, Stefano, Bo, Vivian, Victor, Caroline, Hope, and maybe Carly. Are they over forty? Yes. But with the exception of Bope and Carly what do these characters do anymore except orbit the young people and their problems?

Of course they live there, there's nowhere else for them to go and no one else for them to talk to. And of course she does some things, there's no one else left on the show in her range to do that kind of scut work. Being the only game in town really opens your options but it's a false choice.

Please explain to me DAYS' longterm plans for anyone or anything. I love Suzanne Rogers and Alison Sweeney and I don't even dislike any of the actors you mentioned, but comparing Molly Burnett or Sweeney to Susan Haskell is laughable. And Crystal Chappell? When she is not embarrassing herself offscreen her current performances are the definition of "screensaver."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 36
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Interesting topic of discussion.

Marty is a difficult character. The character started out much too harsh and they never were able to get the character on a good footing after the rape storyline. The preface to the rape story (bonding her with the Buchanans, showing her softer side through that, giving her better back story), and the rape story were amazing. The show truly has never been able to define this character, at least with this actress, outside of the rape storyline. What was amazing in that is not a comfortable fit outside of that. She's not an entertaining good girl (hapless heroine), IMO, yet bad girl no longer feels right on any level. I think this particular issue tends to happen to characters after rape storylines, and this was a hardcore serious rape storyline (one that OLTL won't let die: Powell the rapist, etc).

I don't know if it was wise to add grand-ma ontop of the writing issues with the character.

I have always thought Kevin/Buchanans was the character of Marty's best hope.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I am not really sure why they are keeping Marty on the show when it is obvious they have nothing for her to do except be the spoiler in John and Natalie's reunion, it seems once RC couldn't get away with the rapist/victim romance he didn't want to write for her, that's a problem with soaps they have all these useless characters they do nothing with, how about a story for Viki, Bo and Nora, I would prefer that over another Marty story

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I LOVE Marty and Susan Haskell. The woman can emote the crap out of any line written for her. When she told Todd that she had not forgiven him and at best only tolerated him, or when she told John that she knew he was covering for Natalie and asked him to stop walking around acting as though he was all alone in the situation - awesome. She may be emotional, but she is one of the strongest characters on the show. I think it's funny that many people think Natalie is a stonger woman than Marty just because they associate "strong" to finger-in-your-face-"you-better-stay-away-from-my-man" BS.

I do wanna see Danielle talk to Marty. I think ultimately, it has to happen. And it should be good stuff.

JMHO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I am a couple days behind, but is it just me or do some of the glimpses of Martin's nightmare look like a police traffic stop?  
    • IIRC, there was fan outcry when viewers realized Donna was going to be killed, although someone more in the know might have a better idea. Donna was always more popular with viewers than she probably should have been, which I credit Stuart for. I do agree she would have been easier to write out than Felicia or Rachel.  Cass and Donna dated briefly during the Malone run (late 1997). http://www.anotherworldhomepage.com/cassd.html AW should have invested much more in Quinn than they did. All the pieces were in place for her to, at the very least, have a steady build in importance the way Jessica did on ATWT at that time. AW had moved away from usual patterns by bringing Henrietta and Quinn into the show to diversify the canvas. What always bothers me is the comment an AW person gave to SOD after fan complaints over Quinn's death - essentially, they did not know Quinn had any fans. Says it all.
    • I like that the Martin story hasn't been frequent.  The nightmares are airing only periodically.  Each time, we viewers see more of the accident or whatever happened.  I think we might (or at least I might) be annoyed if we saw the nightmares too often.  At this point, I've become more curious, and so, when it's finally revealed, I think the timing will be just right.
    • Total agreement.  But wasn't AW wonderful with all those servants?  Louise, Brooks, Rocky, Karl (never seen), Beatrice, Helga, Sven, Vivian, etc.  None of the post-Lemay servants ever seemed to resonate, nor did any of them last very long.  I do think BTG would benefit from casting at least one servant for Anita and Vernon.  And perhaps another for Nicole and Ted.  The show needs more have-nots for the different perspective.   
    • Interesting, I didn't know the origins of their "friendship." Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against Linda Dano or Felicia, but maybe the show would have been better off if they killed off Felicia instead of Quinn and built around her. Correct me if I'm wrong, but weren't OLTL & ATWT pretty white at that time? Of all the stuff they threw at walls during that time to see what stuck, appealing to Black viewers seemed like a no-brainer. Especially since NBC had success at that time in Primetime with The Cosby Show & 227. Even in the mornings with Bryant Gumbel on Today. Of course, didn't have to be an either/or. I didn't mean to convey that Donna's isolation was the reason. Rachel, Felicia & Donna were all rich, 50ish brunettes whose characters started bleeding together by that point. Granted, mostly due to the bad writing of the writers she hired. Of the 3, getting rid of Donna would have been by far the easiest as VW had the most longevity/caused the biggest uproar; and Dano was the face of the show to the industry (and her favorite of the bunch). Thanks for the info of the alcoholism story. It was right before I started watching so I've only seen the clips of the intervention. Don't remember Cass & Donna at all. Was it last year of the show before he got with Lila? I was mostly checked out at that point.
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Phillip/Harley made more sense as friends (as they were portrayed to be during the Pam Long era).. and I could even buy them being a short-term couple.. but end game they were not. Didn't GA say he thought it out of character that he would choose Harley over Beth.. or that he would leave Beth/Lizzie back in AZ in order for him to chase a vendetta?  I know that when Beth Chamberlain came back as Beth in late 1997, she was told instantly that the writing would be slanted toward Phillip/Harley.. which surprised her as well. When the Lorelei story came up, it actually made all of her out there/out of character behavior Beth displayed from 1997/1998 through the early/mid 00s make sense.  I liked that the final months of the show, Beth became more like Beth of old so at least the show ended on a positive for her character.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy