Martha is the ONLY Lily. I hope that the show collapses like a souffle for letting royalty go without a fight.

Noelle will never have a chance, good actress or not.

This is what I dont understand

so people are fans of the show

And when someone leaves or gets recast some hope the show fails

so because one person is out you want a cast and crew of hundreds or so to lose their jobs

Edited March 25, 200817 yr by John

This is what I dont understand

so people are fans of the show

And when someone leaves or gets recast some hope the show fails

so because one person is out you want a cast and crew of hundreds or so to lose their jobs

Its quite simple. When TIIC treat those that are the true faces of the show, actors that are synonymous with daytime, like garbage, its the same as treating fans like garbage. Its like taking a family member whom you've watched grow and mature over two decades and kicking them to the curb for some stranger that is like an eyesore on the canvas of the show, regardless if they have talent or not.

Lily is Oakdale. Just like Zimmer is Springfield. Lucci is Pine Valley. Hall is Salem. and Cooper is Y&R.

You remove such a pivotal ingredient and you are left with bile.

^^Yeah, and I like Noelle Beck just fine and I think she's a wonderful actress and person. The statement that I said yesterday wasn't attacking Noelle Beck or Martha Bryne. I was just talking about the soap fans and how crazy they can be. You know, it's kind of like what the fans of Jericho did by sending tons and tons of cases of Peanuts to CBS because they were "nuts" for Jericho. However, in Susan Batten's case, she got fired in one of the most worst and ugly ways in my opinion.

I agree that Martha shouldn't have been let go, but if we have to have a recast, I can't think of anyone better than Noelle. I've been wanting her back on daytime for years! I sort of have similar feelings for both actresses--I was watching ATWT when Martha first appeared, and I was also watching Loving when Noelle first brought Trisha to town. It's nice seeing them both growing into beautiful, talented, mature women.

Its quite simple. When TIIC treat those that are the true faces of the show, actors that are synonymous with daytime, like garbage, its the same as treating fans like garbage. Its like taking a family member whom you've watched grow and mature over two decades and kicking them to the curb for some stranger that is like an eyesore on the canvas of the show, regardless if they have talent or not.

Lily is Oakdale. Just like Zimmer is Springfield. Lucci is Pine Valley. Hall is Salem. and Cooper is Y&R.

You remove such a pivotal ingredient and you are left with bile.

[/quote

I get the lily stuff with MB and that outrage

I just dont get why some fans would want the show to fail which would cause all those actors and crew to lose their jobs.

It completely infuriates me how everyone is saying "She'll do great", "I love Noelle", "She'll be fine".

It's almost as if Martha Byrne quit for nothing. What she stood up for is completely null and void.

I am so beyond fuking pissed right now.

I found this pic of hers.

That's Kate Beckinsale!

^ LOL We know.

That's Kate Beckinsale!

Umm..hello!!! I know. Had you read the previous post by Toups. He already mentioned it to me. YOu dont have to beat me over the head with it.

Umm..hello!!! I know. Had you read the previous post by Toups. He already mentioned it to me. YOu dont have to beat me over the head with it.

I think someone just woke up on the wrong side of the bed here, Ron! SIMMER DOWN!

She looks like Christina Chambers. We all know how well HER recast of a popular character went.

Noelle and Chambers do not even resemble each other.

Edited March 26, 200817 yr by Cheyenne

Umm..hello!!! I know. Had you read the previous post by Toups. He already mentioned it to me. YOu dont have to beat me over the head with it.

That's Kate Beckinsale! JUST KIDDING!

For anyone not sure what Noelle Beck looks like/acts like nowadays, I found a few snippets of her in Cashmere Mafia.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2qVIH_hyVNI (at 0:08)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8BkGwUCR7FE (at 0:15)

She seems a little too sex-kitteny for Lily and would maybe be better suited to a role like Emily. I'll give her a chance though, maybe she's a versatile enough actress and will change her look a little for the role. I hope.

She's just not gonna work, and your right UKBoi she does come off a little to sex kitten like for Lily.

I wish her luck because she has a lot of work ahead of her to get fans to accept her as Lily...if they do