Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

American Idol: Discussion Thread

Featured Replies

  • Member

I don't know. This will be very close

It will be either Jason or Brooke!

  • Replies 138
  • Views 19.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member

Andrew Lloyd Webber night was probably the worst theme night ever of IDOL history. Whomever thought of this idea should be fired imho.

#1 TIED --- DAVID COOK and CARLY SMITHSON----Cook was freaking awesome , with "Music of the Night", Surprising me some, because I thought he was gonna have a hard time with this night. But he's so talented, DAVID COOK's the REAL ONE who can sing anything (not the pitiful David Archuleta).

Carly also gave one of her best performances, freaking awesome . I'm glad she took Webber's advice and did "Jesus Christ Superstar". Gonna vote for each about 50x.

3) Syesha Mercado----one of her best performances, although I've never heard of this song in my life.

The Bottom 3-----which are the exact opposite of the Top 3 imho. Bad, horrible, sucking, forgettable.

4) Jason Castro---wrong song choice. But I doubt anything in Webber's songbook would've fit him. So I'll say he did good with what he was given. But still sucked.

5) Brooke White------I agree with Paula that you donot restart a song on live tv. She's in the top 6 and should not be forgetting lyrics to a song. This is proof that she shouldn't have made it this far. Her "You Must Love Me" is probably my least fave Madonna song, and Brooke I don't think put enough emotion into it either.

6) David Archuleta-----totally forgettable, horrible. Never heard this crappy song ever. He's singing songs that sound the same every week and seems to be singing the same tune to him. He does seem like a robot, and so damned fake.

I so hope David A gets his ass kicked to the curb, but I doubt it. It'll be Brooke imho.

Edited by Mulder

  • Member
Andrew Lloyd Webber night was probably the worst theme night ever of IDOL history. Whomever thought of this idea should be fired imho.

#1 TIED --- DAVID COOK and CARLY SMITHSON----Cook was freaking awesome , with "Music of the Night", Surprising me some, because I thought he was gonna have a hard time with this night. But he's so talented, DAVID COOK's the REAL ONE who can sing anything (not the pitiful David Archuleta).

Carly also gave one of her best performances, freaking awesome . I'm glad she took Webber's advice and did "Jesus Christ Superstar". Gonna vote for each about 50x.

3) Syesha Mercado----one of her best performances, although I've never heard of this song in my life.

The Bottom 3-----which are the exact opposite of the Top 3 imho. Bad, horrible, sucking, forgettable.

4) Jason Castro---wrong song choice. But I doubt anything in Webber's songbook would've fit him. So I'll say he did good with what he was given. But still sucked.

5) Brooke White------I agree with Paula that you donot restart a song on live tv. She's in the top 6 and should not be forgetting lyrics to a song. This is proof that she shouldn't have made it this far. Her "You Must Love Me" is probably my least fave Madonna song, and Brooke I don't think put enough emotion into it either.

6) David Archuleta-----totally forgettable, horrible. Never heard this crappy song ever. He's singing songs that sound the same every week and seems to be singing the same tune to him. He does seem like a robot, and so damned fake.

I so hope David A gets his ass kicked to the curb, but I doubt it. It'll be Brooke imho.

Hehehhehehe...love your post Mulder. B)

  • Member

I missed it tonight, but I'm sure that I didn't miss much. Thanks Mulder for your input. :)

  • Member

I felt bad for Brooke.

Heres the rankings according to Dial Idols

David Cook 8.23

David Archuleta 6.11

Syesha Mercado 4.88

Jason Castro 4.64

Brooke White 3.87

Carly Smithson 3.45

  • Member

Whoa!

Carly and Syesha in the Bottom Two!!!

I am not shcoked. Like Simon said Brooke made herself human because everyone makes mistakes,

  • Member
Leona live. OMG is she good. :wub:

I love Leona. I have her import CD. I couldnt wait for her US debut to be released. :lol: She rocks!! B)

  • Member

I'm [!@#$%^&*] through with Idol. They sent the best one HOME?????

I'm beyond furious.

NEVER watching again.

Assholes!

:angry:

  • Member
I'm [!@#$%^&*] through with Idol. They sent the best one HOME?????

I'm beyond furious.

NEVER watching again.

Assholes!

:angry:

Eh...I didnt think she was that great. The one that is getting on my nerves is Jason Castro. He is not all that. His songs sound all the same. All the teen boppers are voting for him..ugh.

  • Member

Brooke or Jason were suposed to get voted off.

Brooke felt guilty and I really appricate her for that. She thought she was going home. I really was happy for her because she has the up most respect for the judges, other contestants and her viewers.

Jason did not feel guilty. He was like all happy and waving! :angry:

  • Member
Brooke or Jason were suposed to get voted off.

Brooke felt guilty and I really appricate her for that. She thought she was going home. I really was happy for her because she has the up most respect for the judges, other contestants and her viewers.

Jason did not feel guilty. He was like all happy and waving! :angry:

if Jason wins this year, I wont watch next year.

  • Member
Hehehhehehe...love your post Mulder. B)

Thanks Ron. :)

I missed it tonight, but I'm sure that I didn't miss much. Thanks Mulder for your input. :)

You're welcome Noel. You really didn't miss much except for the great performances by David Cook, Carly & Syesha.

Eh...I didnt think she was that great. The one that is getting on my nerves is Jason Castro. He is not all that. His songs sound all the same. All the teen boppers are voting for him..ugh.

Carly was freaking awesome Ron. She is by far the best woman on IDOL this season. IDOL's really pissing me off this year. How the F*ck does Carly get voted off, yet Brooke who can't remember her damned lyrics stay and not even make the Bottom 2?? :angry: If David Cook is kicked off or does not win, then I'm DONE with IDOL FOR GOOD!

Brooke or Jason were suposed to get voted off.

Brooke felt guilty and I really appricate her for that. She thought she was going home. I really was happy for her because she has the up most respect for the judges, other contestants and her viewers.

Jason did not feel guilty. He was like all happy and waving! :angry:

I agree. Brooke does seem like a good person. Jason maybe. But I think he's high on pot all the time. LOL.

if Jason wins this year, I wont watch next year.

Ron, I don't think Jason will win, or be in the Final 2. But David Archuletta winning would be just as bad. That little kid needs to be the next axed off, right after Brooke & Jason (Heck, I'd be happy for David Fakealeta to go next week).

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.