15 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

Considering Silzer appeared LAST YEAR, I doubt she's "retired." If anything, she's focused on schooling. I don't see them recasting her, either. If they wanted to, they would have already. Valentini/ABC/Disney Television Group are dedicated to Silzer. That's clear.

I agree, but returning Patrick would return a former doctor to the hospital, which would be needed with cutting Easton's Finn. But I agree: Emma could exist without her parents, but I just don't see TPTB wanting that from her.

BRS retired from acting a while ago, and her guest appearances in recent years have just been a favor to the producer.

7 minutes ago, Khan said:

But could she still make Joss empathetic enough that viewers would love to hate her and not just hate her?  As good as actresses like Eileen Fulton and Susan Lucci were at playing vixens, they also had that quality that nonetheless made them endearing to audiences.  IDK whether Eden McCoy has that same quality.

I mean, I already hate Joss so it couldn't be worse for me lol.  I think Eden does better work when she's bitchy.  I really don't find her endearing now, so I think if the show just went with her as a vixen or bad girl it would work more to her strengths.  Joss being the best and brightest doesn't work now.

 

6 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

Oh NO! That would be for Matt Hunter, LOL! 🤣

I wouldn't mind Matt back.  Is the poor guy still in jail for killing Lisa?

15 minutes ago, carolineg said:

I really don't find her endearing now, so I think if the show just went with her as a vixen or bad girl it would work more to her strengths.  Joss being the best and brightest doesn't work now.

No, it doesn't.  But if she were to become a "bad" girl, I still need to see something in her that I could love and empathize with.  Otherwise, I almost think I would hate her even more than I do now, if that makes any sense, lol.

Edited May 24, 20241 yr by Khan

4 minutes ago, Khan said:

Part of me would want to recast Patrick with David Tom just to be cute.

🤣 And then a few months later Burgess Jenkins? Oh, David Tom's return was brilliant... but was poorly executed against Amelia Heinle's Victoria.

2 minutes ago, Aragorn said:

BRS retired from acting a while ago, and her guest appearances in recent years have just been a favor to the producer.

You really cannot accept she did not retire, can you?

1 minute ago, carolineg said:

I wouldn't mind Matt back.  Is the poor guy still in jail for killing Lisa?

He and Steven Lars serving lifetime sentences, while criminals like Sonny Corinthos roam free. SMFH.

LOVED Finola & LW. 

Loved that little shade Carly aimed at Ava, ignoring her the rest of the time. 

More than a little peeved we did not see Tracy get the news of Gregory's passing. Oops. I jumped to an unfounded conclusion! My bad. 

LOVED Liz suddenly finding her backbone. It had been MIA for such a long time. 

Giovanni is a lovely name. Don't care for "Gio." But, also really like "G." I didn't see it coming, his moving into the Q mansion. So far, works, we'll see. 

I count myself among the people who think he may be for Trina. 

One brave soul on TwiX has suggested what if he's for Aiden? IDK. 

Edited May 24, 20241 yr by Contessa Donatella
more

I strongly dislike the general opinion that a character cannot thrive without a love interest.
(to clarify:  This is not directed at anyone here. I'm referring to general commentary across the internet about all characters on all shows).
Especially female characters.  I truly believe that female characters can be strong, fun, and vital, even if currently without a love interest.  Yes this is a soap, but love interests shouldn't be required nowadays.

Edited May 24, 20241 yr by janea4old

28 minutes ago, Khan said:

No, it doesn't.  But if she were to become a "bad" girl, I still need to see something in her that I could love and empathize with.  Otherwise, I almost think I would hate her even more than I do now, if that makes any sense, lol.

See, I think I would hate Joss less if she was an overtly bad person.  At this point she's subtly awful, but we aren't supposed to think that.

28 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

You really cannot accept she did not retire, can you?

He and Steven Lars serving lifetime sentences, while criminals like Sonny Corinthos roam free. SMFH.

Weird hill to die on when BRS has literally recently returned to GH and said she would like to continue.  The entire take that she's retired is made up lol.

Forgot about Steven Lars.  Matt really got a raw deal.  I still don't know how him killing psycho Lisa was not self defense.

Edited May 24, 20241 yr by carolineg

6 minutes ago, janea4old said:

I strongly dislike the general opinion that a character cannot thrive without a love interest.
(to clarify:  This is not directed at anyone here. I'm referring to general commentary across the internet about all characters on all shows).
Especially female characters.  I truly believe that female characters can be strong, fun, and vital, even if currently without a love interest.  Yes this is a soap, but love interests shouldn't be required nowadays.

I completely agree, as well!

Just now, carolineg said:

Forgot about Steven Lars.  Matt really got a raw deal.  I still don't know how him killing psycho Lisa was not self defense.

Even Heather has forgotten about Steven Lars at this point. 🤣 And I think Matt got the book thrown at him because of the situation with Maxie taking the blame, and then their marriage of convenience.

I vehemently disagree with any suggestion that the character Trina be cut altogether or changed to recurring.
*In my opinion* Trina should be one of the leads of the show.
Why would you want her time cut or reduced?  There's plenty she could do.  She doesn't need Spencer to be relevant!
 

3 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

I completely agree, as well!

Even Heather has forgotten about Steven Lars at this point. 🤣 And I think Matt got the book thrown at him because of the situation with Maxie taking the blame, and then their marriage of convenience.

Heather mentioned Steven in her last scene.

2 minutes ago, janea4old said:

I vehemently disagree with any suggestion that the character Trina be cut altogether or changed to recurring.
*In my opinion* Trina should be one of the leads of the show.
Why would you want her time cut or reduced?  There's plenty she could do.  She doesn't need Spencer to be relevant!
 

They’ve really failed at Trina as a character in this post-Spencer period. Unfortunately, I wish I could say I expect that to change, but I can’t. 

2 minutes ago, janea4old said:

I vehemently disagree with any suggestion that the character Trina be cut altogether or changed to recurring.
*In my opinion* Trina should be one of the leads of the show.
Why would you want her time cut or reduced?  There's plenty she could do.  She doesn't need Spencer to be relevant!

My cutting Trina to recurring has to do with diminishing the Ashford family altogether, in exchange for the Ward family, and I just don't see the need for Trina to be on-canvas in a full-time capacity when recurring would suit her just fine. Time to graduate to the next generation.

5 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

My cutting Trina to recurring has to do with diminishing the Ashford family altogether

Bring back Réal Andrews as Taggert, and reestablish him as Trina's father.  (Regardless of whether the paternity test was altered or not, they can still recognize Taggert as Trina's father of the heart.) Then cut Curtis.   Problem solved.  Réal can recur while Tabyana is on contract.

.

10 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

diminishing the Ashford family altogether, in exchange for the Ward family

well yes I'd like to see the Ward family, but I still want Trina/Tabyana on contract.

Edited May 24, 20241 yr by janea4old

1 minute ago, janea4old said:

Bring back Réal Andrews as Taggert, and reestablish him as Trina's father.  (Regardless of whether the paternity test was altered or not, they can still recognize Taggert as Trina's father of the heart.) Then cut Curtis.   Problem solved.  Réal can recur while Tabyana is on contract.

Again, Ali can be on recurring for all of this. I don't see any justifiable reason to keep her on as a series regular other than the fact Trina was part of a multi-year social media fan campaign for a couple that, realistically, was short-lived. 🤷🏻‍♂️ She can exist on recurring, which is essentially all she's been following Nicholas Alexander Chavez's exit as Spencer and it's perfectly fine to keep her there.

4 hours ago, Aragorn said:

The good actors can get other jobs. The mediocre actors don't have anywhere else to go.

Are you serious with this? This is your idea of good casting on a soap?