Jump to content

All: 25 biggest blunders in Daytime Soap History

dragonflies

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 255
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members
All My Shadows Rising Star

All My Shadows

Posted
  • Members
Posted

It was a sh!tty move, yes, but a blunder/mistake? Had they kept AW and passed on PSNS, AW probably would have gotten the axe within five or so years. If not that soon, it definitely would have been out before GL.

I can see what sungrey's saying though, that the mistake was in cancelling AW to make room for PSNS instead of just adding PSNS to the lineup.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
Max Apprentice

Max

Posted
  • Members
Posted

Although I believe that Frons was not the most destructive person to the soap genre (that distinction belongs to JER, although--of course--many other individuals caused the demise of soap operas as well), I do believe that appointing him as ABC Daytime chief should have ranked around #4 or #5 on the list. (#9 is much too low.)

While AW is my very favorite soap, its cancellation (on its own) was not the most damaging thing to happen to the genre. (And it was justified based on the ratings it got on the time, although it pisses me off that the much lower-rated SuBe did not go first.) However, the failure of Passions was one of the very worst things (if not the worst) to happen to the soap genre. (That being said, Passions deserved to fail because it was a piece of s#it.) I think most of us agree that the main thing that doomed the genre was the high failure rate among "new" soaps. Yet, many new soaps were practically guaranteed to fail as a result of poor network promotion and/or being placed in erratic timeslots. In fact, during the last 35 years, only B&B (which obviously succeeded) and Passions were handed that precious combination of intensive network promotion and great timeslot. When a new soap is this lucky, there is no excuse for it not to succeed, but of course Passions did fail because JER fu*ked it up so badly. (One can also blame Passions' failure on the horrendous "actors" who were on the show, but that is ultimately JER's fault becuase he hired those people.) And because of this failure, all the networks concluded that the soap genre was irreversibly in decline. (Thus, it is no coincidence that Passions was the last ever daytime soap to debut.)

I am thrilled that JER's first stint at DOOL made the top ten. Although his ardent defenders loved the Marlena possession storyline and others that he wrote, his tenure forever ruined the credibility of soaps. And while it is true that nobody held a gun to the heads of the executives of the other soaps who copied JER, immense pressure would not have been put on those executives had JERs first tenure at DOOL deservedly flopped in the first place.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
Eric83 Newbie

Eric83

Posted
  • Members
Posted

How much longer was AW going to last pulling in 2.2's in 1998 and 1999? The show had been in the bottom portion of the ratings for 2 decades. I think some are letting the stories and things Passions did affect their view. If the show's ratings stink replace it with something new and cheaper. Same thing as now except it was another soap. The only reason AW went first was because they wanted Passions to have Days as a lead in and if replaced SuBe it could have gone anywhere.... 11am, midnight, 3am, 9am lol...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
Shawn Newbie

Shawn

Posted
  • Members
Posted

I can totally see your point in respect to the Marlena possession storyline being the final nail in the coffin of Days' credibilty (a coffin that would remain nailed shut for years and only occassionally come loose), but I have to give credit to where credit is due.

I am the first person to judge the bad moves by JER, though with many faults during his time on Days ( I don't count his second stint because that was just an unbelievable piece of excrement without any merit whatosever), he DID introduce some pretty long lasting and loved characters/storylines. Kristen Blake Dimera became one of the best vilians in daytime history. Austin, Billie, Lucas, Kate, and Vivian became staples on the show, and are even today (even off screen, they're talked about). Carly being buried alive was twisted, but it was mesmerizing. The Carrie/Austin/Lucas/Sami storyline was epic. He brought back Laura. He penned the Alan Stalker/Rapist storyline which fueled the hatred/rivalry of Carrie/Sami. The Who's Will's Daddy? storyine was great too.

The best thing about JER, besides creating a ratings spike almost unheard of at the time, was that he created a very gothic atmosphere on the show, but yet grounded it in family and love. I bitched a lot, but I watched because I couldn't stop myself. He did his job in that aspect.

During the last year on Days, if I miss more than one episode, I don't care. That never happened during 1993-1997.

With all the horrid mistakes, he did have some pretty amazing moments. That I have to give him credit for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
Cheap21 Experienced

Cheap21

Posted
  • Members
Posted

Frons at #9? I wonder what will be top 5 bc I sure thought he would be.

I agree on the Kay/Jill debacle. I didnt mind them as mother/daughter mainly bc I wasnt watching in the 70s/80s but I hated what MAB did as she did make it even worse

I dont agree on Marlena's possession. I thought that was good for Days

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

  I accept