Okay, so I've seen Dorothy Lyman in the role and I have seen Jill Larson since day one. Ms. Lyman was pretty damn entertaining, and I was wondering would any AMC fan love to see her come back and play Tad's mama, or at this point is Jill Larson pretty much the actress best associated with Opal?

Erik

Dorothy Lyman was an original. Totally outrageous and OTT. She was so memorable and so hysterical. Larson, who I think is the better actress, took a more subtle, low-key approach, which actually fit perfectly with the more intentional supporting nature of the character when they brought the her back in 1989. When AMC relocated to LA and Larson was still recurring and not asked to move at that point, there was talk of them trying to get Lyman back. Sure, it would've been cool to see the more outrageous Opal again, but I think it would've been a slap in the face to Larson, who's always seemed like a real team player. So, the better actress I think is Larson, but the more fun to watch is Lyman.

I never heard that. Hasn't Lyman basically retired from acting to direct, mainly sitcoms? We'd prob get one or two performances with her (did Lyman ever really even interact with Lucci?) and that would be it and the character would be forgotten (a more exagerated version of what we've gotten with old Janet back).

Schemering claims that Lyman's character on AMC was very close to a chgaracter she briefly played on AW (Or was it Edge of Night?) Anyone know more?

I think it was her Edge of Night character, Elly Jo. saynotoursoap talked about her in the Edge thread, if you're interested.

http://lavender.fortunecity.com//casino/403/female.html#ellyjo

October 26, 1982 Digest.

Thanks for posting that Carl, that's the interview I was talking about earlier if anyone's confused. It's reprinted online somewhere, didn't realize it was from SOD. Ever since I read it I was confused by Dorothy saying she was doing a "Beverly Hills" accent but I now see that that was a misprint, Hillbillies.

I thought this might have been the one but I'm glad you didn't mind reading it again. I never had. I guess this wasn't too long before she left AMC. I love her attitude in the interview. You probably can't get away with that on a soap today.

I have a few other interviews with her somewhere.

I wish I could see that Coupla White Chicks show. These days they'd probably revive it with the Wayans brothers.

I thought this might have been the one but I'm glad you didn't mind reading it again. I never had. I guess this wasn't too long before she left AMC. I love her attitude in the interview. You probably can't get away with that on a soap today.

I have a few other interviews with her somewhere.

I wish I could see that Coupla White Chicks show. These days they'd probably revive it with the Wayans brothers.

LMAO!

I have a SOD Robin Strasser pictorial somewhere and there's a pic of her and Brynn Thayer doing Coupla White Chicks directed by Dorothy, Robin's in these huge shades and a leopard pantsuit. I'll try to post it next week.

Yeah, that's a really fun interview and it sounds like she had a ball with Opal. I mean, how could you not? I wonder what her Emmy reels looked like. I don't think any of her wins are even online.

I think it was her Edge of Night character, Elly Jo. saynotoursoap talked about her in the Edge thread, if you're interested.

http://lavender.fortunecity.com//casino/403/female.html#ellyjo

I only watched EoN a couple of years, 81-83 I guess, and caught 1980 online at aolvideo, bit reading that list of villainesses really makes me wish someone pop up with their 70s stuff, they all sound so great. The only one on that list I watched in realtime was Nora Fulton.

How did people react when JL took over? Was there resilience against her? For those that watched DL, how long did it take you to accept her recast

Looking at those clips of Dorothy in the role, 1 phrase comes to mind. Trailer trash. She is like the epitome of it

In the Digest issues from Jill's first year there was a fair amount of editorial hostility to her marriage to Palmer and her friendship with Erica, with SOD saying flat out that they would never be friends and that it was ridiculous.

I think over time Jill won fans over, especially since her Opal was very different, but I know a lot of fans still never believed her with Palmer or Erica.

Well, at least AMC built a friendship between Erica and Opal, instead of pretending they had always been friends. I hate it when any soap does something like that.

How did the two become friends anyway? They were friends as early as Jill's first year?

I think Erica's friendship with Opal is completely realistic. All of Erica's female friends are women she doesn't see as threats (usually on the romantic end). Her only female friends were Myrtle and Opal.

I think Erica's friendship with Opal is completely realistic. All of Erica's female friends are women she doesn't see as threats (usually on the romantic end). Her only female friends were Myrtle and Opal.

she was friends with Krystal for a minute...lol

she was friends with Krystal for a minute...lol

For real?! When was this??

BTW, I guess you could say that Olga (her former agent) was a friend, too. What ever happened to Olga? She hasn't been mentioned in years.

But my point is that Erica is bitchy to women she sees as competition (Brooke, Natalie, Maria, ect.).