Jump to content

WGA Nomination: Daytime Serials


Recommended Posts

  • Members

I do not understand this Guild. I do not.

How can you award a show whose head writers took fi-core status? Sure, that's better than scabbing, but still... :mellow:

However, like I said, this award in daytime — and it seems in primetime too, with a flood of new categories and thinner offerings from year to year — is quickly becoming a joke. It just has a bizarre, ineffective nominations/winner prodcedure...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 69
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Administrator

One of the episodes was September 17, not September 16.

March 26- BDW: Hogan Sheffer; SW: Janice Ferri Esser

April 3- BDW: Marla Kanelos; SW: Janice Ferri Esser

September 17- BDW: Natalie Minardi Slater; SW: Amanda L. Beall

Hooray for Janice and Amanda for the winning scripts. :D Janice is my favorite Y&R SW, so I'm especially happy that 2 of 3 scripts were hers.

I actually think it's good. From what I understand, the voters read the outline/script and they're from other fields (film, primetime, etc). So they read the outline/script without any preconceive notions - they don't know the characters, history, storyline. They just read the actual words/episode and judge that. And sometimes what's on page is so much better than what appears on screen (and of course vice versa). If I'm wrong about the procedure, please correct me. :)

Well, those Fi-Core writers don't actually get the award. There's no need to punish those who didn't go fi-core.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Amanda L. Beall <_<

This woman writes the most ridiculous and out of character dialogue for people like Jack, Victor, Katherine, and Jill, AKA the characters that really matter.

I guess it's safe to say Janice carried them to this win, with two of the three scripts being her's. Even with her faults, she's still better than most, if not all, of that writing team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I copied something from the rule book here. The whole problem for me is... That I can't think of an effective and fair way to judge it. You'd have to read the projections, see it on air, read the outlines, scripts etc. Too much work, never going to happen. This how it's not really best written soap, it's three best written episodes out of [insert number (all soaps)] submitted. Not for the whole year, the best written soap is [insert name]: it had the best dialogue, best outlines and best stories.

Yes, I understand that. I have no problems with that. It's when I take into account what I wrote above (best written soap for the whole year) that I see some problems. Because, if you judge a year, than it's also Maria's work and the awards is hers. They should just rename it into Best Daytime Script or something.

But who cares anyway, I don't. After giving the award to Kreizman...

Wait. Is it September 16th or 17th? :unsure:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Administrator

Janice writers the best for those 4.

Looking at the credits, I think Janice edited the September 17th episode too, so she had a hand in all 3 winning episodes. :)

That's because there isn't a better way unless they want to add more episodes. Having 3 episodes is better than the Daytime Emmys where they only submit 1 episode. I think 3 is a good number.

It's a tv award show. There's no possible way to judge an entire year for any category (ie acting where you only submit 1 episode). Nobody wants to sit through so many episodes.

17th.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Let me mention, that I'm glad Melissa Salmons managed to land herself in the wining team, even if she was there for about 5 minutes. I loved her scripts, and I think her OLTL scripts are often the best on that show. Now that's the mark of a great writer - when you go to different shows with different characters and manage to put out compelling dialogue that isn't ridiculous or out of character for most of the characters you're writing for.

Melissa is underrated and deserves more credit for her scriptwriting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Oh God, she's back? I thought those first scenes were well-intentioned but hysterical.
    • More Guiding Light 1976 At dinner the next evening, Grainger tells Rita he still can’t understand why she inherited from his father and he’s hired a lawyer to help him discover what her role was in his father’s death. Telling her he knows she lied to him, he again warns that he will destroy her reputation in this town. As Rita insists she’s done nothing wrong, Grainger, growing even more angry, lashes out, “Ill see you charged with m—”. Suddenly he clutches his head and collapses to the floor. As people rush to help him, Rita quickly slips out of the restaurant. Grainger is rushed to Cedars and treated for stroke. Rita is even more frightened and upset when it appears that he’s going to recover under the excellent treatment and care of Ed, who is assigned as his attending physician, and Peggy, who is a fine specialty nurse. Rita, drawn by an unseen force to his door, is further shaken when Peggy, seeing her, presses her into temporarily spelling her so she can take a short break. Ed is determined to come to Rita’s aid, as she did his, and brings a big steak for dinner to her apartment. But Rita is too unnerved and shaky to even be with Ed, and disappoints him by asking him to leave before dinner, explaining that she’s extremely tired. Ed knows it’s more than that, and is doubly determined to help her out of this depression, but when she starts to cry, he leaves her, as she wishes. Roger, remembering how Grainger fired him from the oil fields for- being a friend of Rita’s, is disappointed to learn that Grainger has come out of his coma and that Ed feels Grainger’s paralysis and inability to talk may just be temporary. Rita is pressed to assist Tim with a spinal tap on Grainger, and is frightened when her presence causes Malcolm’s pulse rate to rise rapidly. His doctors are unable to understand his rapid pulse changes. Rita tells Roger why Grainger is so hateful toward her. While she was his father’s special nurse, Malcolm made physical advances toward her and she fought him off. His father noticed her bruises~and instantly guessed his son had manhandled her. The old man then swore to her he’d never forgive Malcolm for this cruelty. Roger again warns Rita that nobody is to know about his connection with her and with the Graingers. He fears that if Peggy learns about it, she will leave him.  Ed continues to press his concern and support on Rita, and while it helps to a certain degree and she’s grateful, Rita can’t bring herself to tell him what the source of her worry is. Each day, as Grainger rallies a bit more, her fear and tension increase. Finally, Grainger is able to barely murmur, “Lie... father ... Rita,” to Peggy and manages to crudely letter “RITA S” on a pad of paper. Peggy, assuming that Rita has somehow managed to get Grainger to respond, summons her to the hospital in the hope that she can further stimulate him and thus hasten his recovery. But a major catastrophe, a train derailment, - has immobilized the entire area, and Cedars, as well as all local hospitals, is being overrun with patients. Even though she’s off duty, having served her full shift, Rita is pressed into distributing the patients’ medication. Peggy, explaining that Grainger has already had an accidental delay of medication, which could have caused a major setback, must receive his dosage exactly on schedule. The sight of Rita again agitates Grainger, but she finishes her extra duty and returns home, drained and oversensitive as well as exhausted. When the regular nurse does her usual check, she finds Grainger lying over the side of his bed, unconscious. She issues a “Code Blue” call for the emergency team, and Steve, there almost immediately, starts resuscitation and then gives adrenalin, right into the heart, but Grainger is dead. As soon as he hears, Ed rushes to Cedars in amazement. This is all impossible to him, as he saw Grainger’s recovery as a certainty. He immediately institutes an investigation to determine the cause of death. Roger, told by Peggy what has happened, notifies a stunned Rita just before Ed arrives to question her about everything she can remember about the last time she was in Grainger’s room. Rita, unable to understand what’s happening around her, breaks down in tears, crying that she could be responsible for his death. Ed comforts her, assuring her that he’s not blaming her, just trying to find out what happened.    
    • Carly, considering Robin's daughter as a possible daughter-in-law .... I think the technical term for it would be "plotz"! Or to put it another way, the top of her head would explode!  

      Please register in order to view this content

    • What AW stories do you think of as DOOLish? I mean AW, in a very positive way was KNOWN for its comedic elements. From Iris's maid, Vivian, to the naming of plants, to highjinks with Cass, Felicia, Wally & even Lily, plus remember Dee Evans & Tony the Tuna? In a way at one time DAYS had similar with Caliope & Eugene. 
    • Were those reasons to do with having younger children on set? Other shows seem to manage. The ageing up of the kids has been one of the mistakes the show has made.
    • I agree.  Lemay was supposed to start in early 88 and we saw some of the writing on the wall with character reference from the past.  Notably, the core families Frames, Cory, Matthews.  The stupid Reginald Love was wrapped up.  Not even a year later Mary was written out of the show along with Vince and the McKinnons who came and left .  The previous writers tried to introduce a new family that never aspired with the viewers.  1988 was focused on the 25th anniversary of show in 1989 and suspect why Lemay was asked to come back in 88.  Prior to 1988, the storylines were so DOOL stupid.
    • That's true. He may have ended up keeping her on a recurring basis, like Dr. Michaels on ATWT. I'm trying to remember if GL had a similar long-running therapist.
    • Oh in terms of ratings I think it would have been in a dicey place probably even before then. I mostly was just thinking of if the show could have carried on creatively. 
    • Even if by some miracle Knots Landing continued, 1994/95 it would have been killed by ER.
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy